Sapphire's Review Store 3.0

By TreasureCommunity

11.9K 1.2K 1.1K

Since both our first and second review stores have exceeded 200 chapters (with a grand total of 379 reviews p... More

Welcome!
Review by Faye: A World of Broken Thoughts
Review by Faye: Water and Fire
Review by Gnome: Random Stories
Review by Alisha: Obsession
Review by Cynthia: Bloodlust and Butterflies
Review by Sunshine: Tale of the Power Walker
Review by Elysia: Welcome to Baker Street
Review by Grey: The Line Between Light and Darkness
Review by Sunshine: The Elvin Enigma
Review by JJ: Pain
Review by Faye: Dear No One
Review by Elysia: If I Should Fall
Review by Jacob: Stumbling Forward
Review by Elysia: The Stuff Heroes Are Made Of
Review by Sunshine: Secrets Come With Lies
Review by Gnome: Are You Crazy?
Review by Bella: Our Differences
Review by Sunshine: A Day That Changed Everything
Review by Faye: Friendships and Other Disasters
Review by Sunshine: Heart in a Shell
Review by Faye: No Blessed
Review by Grey: Little Encounters
Review by Bella: Tainted
Review by Sunshine: Rock the Miles Away
Review by Faye: The Melody of Our Heartbeats
Review by Sunshine: A Heart of Snow
Review by Gnome: Demon Highschool
Review by Elysia: Mind Reader
Review by Elysia: The Spectacular
Review by Sunshine: Manticore Hunter
Review by Bella: When Inyanga Gets Into Magicians College
Review by Lina: Vishta
Review by Sky: Darkling Academy
Review by Jacob: The Butterfly Effect
Review by Sunshine: The Grimoire
Review by Lina: The Eye
Review by Elysia: Rogue in Paris
Review by Sunshine: In Between the Lines
Review by Faye: Of Jangling Chords and Symphonies
Review by Kirsty: Romanian's Forbidden Love
Review by Lina: A Modern Love
Review by Elysia: Sweetly Bitter
Review by Sunshine: Ashes of Lost Love
Review by Sunshine: The Undead and Other Teenage Problems
Review by Jacob: Letters in the Whirl of Time
Review by Bella: Peaceful Chaos
Review by Gnome: Leyland Adventures
Review by Faye: The Art of Life
Review by Sunshine: Wrong Lies
Review by Brooklyn: His Last Wish
Review by Lina: June's Blues
Review by Elysia: Forever June
Review by Kirsty: Cursed
Review by Sunshine: Surviving You
Review by Lina: The Cases of George Alpha #1 - Cupcakes
Review by Brooklyn: Another Chance
Review by Brooklyn: Emberspark Academy
Review by Faye: Sanctity
Review by Brooklyn: A Reckless Soul
Review by Jacob: Adrift
Review by Cynthia: My Thought that Flow
Review by Kirsty: Startling Starlight
Review by Sunshine: Iris
Review by Faye: The Soulmate Guide
Review by Jacob: The Imitator
Review by Elysia: From the Perspective of a Player
Review by Jacob: Are You Crazy?
Review by Brooklyn: The Lady in the Weeping Mansion
Review by Faye: Dear Tressi
Review by Kirsty: Ninja in Disguise
Review by Mimi: Lockdown's Our Cupid
Review by Sunshine: Con Science, not Conscience
Review by Gnome: Living Monsters
Review by Sunshine: Curse of the Moon
Review by Alisha: Vishta
Review by Faye: Remember Me
Review by Sunshine: What She Left Behind
Review by Faye: Skylight
Review by Kirsty: Two Truths and a Liar
Review by Jacob: Nameless Thoughts of an Onlooker
Review by Danielle: The Death Wish
Review by Elysia: My Anthology
Review by Jacob: Dreamcatcher
Review by Sunshine: Started with a Project
Review by Jacob: Variant
Review by Jacob: Nescience
Review by Faye: Midnight Coffee
Review by Kirsty: The Cursed Empire
Review by Faye: Falling for my Enemy
Review by Sunshine: The Widow Maker
Review by Lina: A Gamble of Paintings and Poison
Review by Faye: Vivid
Review by Sunshine: The Boy with the Snow Hair
Review by Faye: One Fated Night
Review by Sunshine: Finding Love
Review by Elysia: My Thoughts that Flow
Review by Sunshine: Bandaids and Punches
Review by Faye: The Obsessions That We Hide
Review by Lina: Smoke and Mirrors
Review by Sunshine: Lost in Havoc
Review by Faye: Fated to Love
Review by Gnome: The Royal Wedding
Review by Sunshine: Secret of Samudra
Review by Elysia: Inevitable Mistakes
Review by Lina: 32 Days in a Month
Review by Sunshine: All She Knows
Review by Sunshine: Authored By You
Review by Sunshine: Lost in Loneliness
Review by Lynn: Maman
Review by Gnome: Protector or Lover
Review by Sunshine: Liberation
Review by Faye: Jaded
Review by Sunshine: Alpha
Review by Sunshine: You're My Light
Review by Lina: The Lost Wolf
Review by Sunshine: Sister Zone
Review by Faye: Entangled Love
Review by Gnome: Only Mine
Review by Sunshine: When I Leave
Review by Ember: Legacy
Review by Lina: Life Meter
Review by Ember: The Last of Us
Review by Elysia: Bumbling Butterfingers
Review by Sunshine: Lilith
Review by Addie: Whirlwind
Review by Faye: When the Ocean Calls
Review by Elysia: Maybe This Time
Review by Sunshine: Storm of Light
Review by Gnome: Jihad
Review by Joanna: Paint Me a Heart
Review by Faye: The App
Review by Sunshine: Variant
Review by Sunshine: Splintered Moon
Review by Faye: Empress of the Sea
Review by Gnome: When Spring Ends
Review by Faye: Short Stories
Review by Sunshine: Dear Tressi
Review by Lina: When Cole Started a Flame
Review by Sunshine: This Heart of Mine
Review by Lina: Sushi and Sea Lions
Review by Gnome: A Sleepover and Death
Review by Lina: What Matters Most
Review by Sunshine: The Perfect Harmony
Review by Joanna: Queen of LA
Review by Sunshine: Crown of Roses
Review by Sunshine: The Dating Proposal
Review by Hana: The Vampire Invasion
Review by Eliza: Loving You, Always
Review by Kanika: The Lone Home
Review by Addie: Her Soul
Review by Sunshine: Badass with a Past
Review by Gnome: The Corrupted Saint
Review by Lina: The Lost City
Review by Addie: What Lies Within
Review by Sunshine: You're Mine
Review by Sunshine: Divided We Fall
Review by Addie: A Normal Morning
Review by Lynn: Paint Me a Heart
Review by Addie: 91-DIVOC
Review by Eliza: Bad Boy Blues
Review by Sunshine: The Keeper of My Heart
Review by Faye: An Exquisite Empress
Review by Joanna: He
Review by Addie: A Twisted Deception
Review by Eliza: Insanity
Review by Faye: Dreams
Review by Addie: Murder in Room 205
Review by Sunshine: Floating Stars
Review by Sunshine: Bribe Me
Review by Joanna: Grimm
Review by Faye: Five More Minutes
Review by Addie: The Lost Knight
Review by Faye: The Wings of Night
Review by Sunshine: Beautiful Chaos
Review by Addie: Until The Very End
Review by Joanna: The Huntress
Review by Sunshine: I Married My Best Friend
Review by Lina: Swapped Mate
Review by Faye: The Beast, The Beauty and The Castle
Review by Eliza: My Infrequent and Oddish Love
Review by Sunshine: Winning Over His Heart
Review by Faye: Heart in a Shell
Review by Hana: Stay With Me
Review by Faye: The Wings of Night
Review by Sunshine: Bhabra
Review by Sunshine: So Much Was Never Too Much
Review by Faye: Thorns and Roses
Review by Gnome: Ages
Review by Faye: Again
Review by Sunshine: Swaying by the Odds
Review by Sunshine: Destiny
Review by Shravani: Returning the Favour
Review by Sunshine: What Lies Beyond You
Review by Faye: The Stains Beneath Our Skin
Review by Eliza: Ethereal Thread
Review by Sunshine: Inside Marissa's Heart
Review by Kanika: Hard to Love
Review by Faye: The Summer Side

Review by Joanna: Marry Me

41 6 7
By TreasureCommunity

Title: Marry Me

Author: JayxxDaniel

Reviewer: joanna388


Cover + Blurb: 5/10

I like the colors in your cover. They're vibrant—in as natural kind of way—and catch your eye when skimming through books to read. Have you ever given any thought to changing the name? While the cover has a wolf centering it to suggest the genre, the title is a little misleading. I—for example—would have skipped a book named 'marry me', if I was looking for a werewolf book to read. Especially if I went by their names.

I also suggest you add your username on the cover, mostly to keep safe from someone else using it as their own.

Your blurb doesn't really have much information about your book, nor your character. We only know that Evan wants to find his mate, and when he does, he wants to give it up, but the bond is too strong.

Is there nothing else happening in the book? No pack conflict for example? If there's more to this story than just the mate bond and the romance between them, write about it, show a little bit of that to your readers to pull them in.

Now, if your book centers on the bond, please add more information about your characters. Both of them. And since you say that Evan wants to fight it when they first meet, make us question why. There's definitely some conflict on that.

On the other hand, if the reason you chose not to mention his mates identity is to keep it a secret at first, then consider describing his character a little without mentioning his name.


Intro: 2/5

The intro is pretty plain, but good, starting at his office. Truthfully, it could have been phrased a little better. For example:


"My phone, kept on my office desk, buzzed indicating that there were notifications pouring in. I ignored the messages and checked the time, 1:04 p.m."

There are a few unnecessary words here, and that, combined with the punctuation, makes it a little tiring to read:

My phone buzzed on my office desk, indicating there were notifications pouring in. I ignored the messages and checked the time: 1:04 p.m.


Plot + Originality: 5/10

Wattpad has an abundance of werewolf books constantly striving to out-shine each other and reach the top. That means the plot—its important parts at least—are used again and again by different writers. Of course, every writer has their own unique writing style that makes their work stand out, but I have to admit that there have been times when I just felt like I was reading the same book over and over.

I was pleasantly surprised when I started reading your book. We don't see the pack life in it as much as werewolves living in the outside world, right next to humans, and in our main characters case, work in a firm.

The plot itself—since it's about the two being mates—isn't that original, but, like I said, every writer has a different story to tell.


Grammar + Punctuation: 2/20

To be frank here, you're going to have to work really hard on both.

For starters, I noticed that you constantly switch between tenses. You go from past to present and back. That confuses the reader, and stops the flow of the book, so I suggest you choose the one you feel most comfortable writing in, and stick to that.

Your sentence structure and punctuation need some work as well. There were times were you used more words to describe something than was needed, thus overloading the paragraph and making it harder to read.

If you google it, you can find both websites, and actual videos of teachers explaining more about these thoroughly, that I'm sure will be of great help!

Also, when you write, speak the finished product aloud. That helps with punctuation especially. You can tell when you use pauses as you speak, and see if it matches in your paragraph. Be careful not to overdo it with the comma's though.

It's better to start from the beginning. Learn to recognize the subject, verb, object, etc. That's crucial when learning about sentence structure. I will be listing a few sentences that I've spotted while reading your book, and giving you recommendations about the structure, punctuation and grammar where it's due.

For example:

"I stretched my stiffen body in the uncomfortable chair on which I was sitting for almost 2 hours, wondering why was I not having a much need lunch with my colleagues instead of dying in the piles of documents. The answer came back to my mind in a bullet speed because I have a deadline."

Instead of that:

I stretched my stiffened body in the uncomfortable chair I was sitting at for almost the past 2 hours, wondering why I wasn't having a much needed lunch with my colleagues, instead of dying between these piles of documents. The answer came fast enough, I had a deadline.

Example:

"The floor was literally deserted, bringing in peace which I neededas I had a mild headache."
Instead:

The floor was deserted, bringing in a much needed peace, considering my mild headache.

Example:

"As he leads me, I couldn't help but get fascinated by my surrounding. I compared myself to the people, unlike me they will be unfazed and nonchalant about it as they routinely attend these kinds of events."

Instead:
As he led me inside, I couldn't help but grow fascinated by my surroundings. I compared myself to these people, who, unlike me, were unfazed and nonchalant about an event they no-doubt routinely attended.

If you re-read your first sentence, you'll notice the tense change I mentioned before. Leads-couldn't.

Example:

"Also, the guests are still pouring in so is why is he not welcoming them? The answer again sprinted in my mind, his wife—"

Instead:

Also, the guests were still pouring in, so why was he not welcoming them? His wife—"
Avoid using phrases like sprinted in my mind, or in a bullet speed etc. My brain did a one-eighty when I first read those.

Example:

"This old man can't live without work even on this day. I have never met his son personally but I hope that he is not like his old man."

Instead:

That old man couldn't live without work even on a day like this. I had never met his son personally, but I hoped he wasn't like him.

The word 'old man' is repeated here. There is no need for that. You can refer to him twice in a sentence if you like, but use something else. His name, title, anything the readers will understand as being him. But again, no need to be extravagant about it.

Example:

"A negligible blushed spread on my face, I am sure that my cheeks are not a hue of red."

Instead:

A blush spread on my face. I was sure my cheeks were a bright red.

Negligible means insignificant, so it doesn't stick with your sentence. You use present tense again here, even though you use past tense more throughout the book. Also, at the end, you wrote 'are not a hue' which means they're not red. I suppose that might also be an editing error so I suggest you remember that while writing. :)

Example:

"She broke the hug, grinning. "Do you know what that means your mate never rejected you—""
The question isn't made clear here, add a question mark right after the 'means', and continue.

Example:

"Wait for some time."

I saw this one constantly being repeated while I read. You meant to say 'wait for a moment'. It sounds a lot better, and is grammatically correct.

Example:

"But I knew better than smiling that is making an impression."

I was very confused about what you meant while first reading this. I assume you meant that smiling made an impression? If so, please edit that part to make it clear. This sentence seemed incoherent when I first read it.

Example:

"Park territory" = Pack territory

That was also repeated a couple of times.

Example:

"Even though he is my mate but the hella work load!!"

Again, change of tenses. There is also the fact that you used two exclamation marks instead of one, which is not needed. I can't really help with this sentence, because I could change it in a number of different ways, but I didn't understand what exactly you meant at that time. It's incoherent.

Example:

"This company is already rich, how more wealthy they want to be?"

Instead:

That company was rich already, how much wealthier did they want to be?

Example:

"I am looking for you from the past 5 minutes."

Instead:

I've been looking for you for the past 5 minutes.

Example:

"The fire in his mouth stop due to water of triumph in search."

I can tell what you're trying to say here, but I had to re-read that a bunch of times to clear it in my head. There is almost no coherence at all between these words. Stopped, would also be the correct grammar here, but the meaning is what you should work on editing the most.

I also saw "great full" a few times. The correct word here is grateful.

Example:

"Sun was shining upon me, it was golden. I stopped after I don't how long."

First of all, 'The sun was shining upon me'. The comma there should turn into a period if you wish to keep the sentence as it is. Then continue with the color. After that, there's a 'know' missing. 'I don't know how long.'

Example:

"But I made eye contact with him and him nearly submission to me."

Instead:

But I made eye contact with him, and he nearly submitted to me.
I won't be referring to any more of them, I'll just close by saying that you need to edit your book thoroughly.

Writing Style: 1/10

To be honest, your writing style was overshadowed by the grammar and the errors in your sentence structure. My mind kept constantly trying to re-arrange your words correctly, and correct the grammar while reading. After a little while, I grew tired of reading through it. I'd just get stuck to sentence after sentence, so the progress was very slow.

Editing should be your priority right now.


Character Development: 3/10

We haven't seen that much character development, since Evan falls into this routine of trying to make his mate fall for him.

We can tell that he is loyal to his friends, and wants to help them when need be. It's also pretty obvious that he is a very emotional guy, but I haven't seen a change in him from the moment I started reading. It just feels like his character is stagnant, and it all just centers around his mate.

Build into it a little more. Tell us his back story, write about his struggle when he first left the pack to join the humans. That must have been a huge change. Was it easy for him? Did his wolf constantly try to get out at first? Write more about him and his way of thinking.


Dialogue: 6/10

Your dialogue was pretty good. There were a few punctuation errors, but they weren't repeating ones.

First, and foremost, you should know when to put a comma in dialogue. Again, it wasn't reoccurring, but I thought it'd be better if I explained that part, so you could understand what

I'm talking about better.

When in dialogue, you need to use a comma if it's followed by a verbal tag. Such as: she said, yelled, shouted, etc.

For example, you wrote:

"I will come there." A tensed male voice said. I was not able to recognize the familiar.

Notice the 'said' here?

Also, there is no reason to capitalize the 'a' after it. It should be capitalized if the sentence ends with a period.

Instead it should be: 

"I will come there," a tense voice said. I wasn't able to recognize it, even though it sounded familiar.


OVERALL SCORE: 24/75

I hope I've helped you and your writing by pointing these out.

Have an amazing day!

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

2.7K 207 6
πŸ›‘ - CLOSED until 2021. ***If you're interested in my critiques, you might want to check out my weekly newsletter for opportunities to get a personal...
815 92 15
OPEN ❎ HIATUS ❎ CLOSED βœ… May 19, 2023 - September 8, 2023 #1 CritiqueπŸ… #7 Book ReviewsπŸ… #8 FeedbackπŸ… #21 CommunityπŸ… Looking for feedback on your...
RISING By M | β™–

Science Fiction

11.3K 1.8K 27
REMOVED FROM HOSTING SITES. ------------ First draft. Β© 2021 MABWrites. All Rights Reserved.