My Sister's Best Friend

By Believeeexoxo

442K 15.1K 6.7K

I've been in love with Maya Garcia since I saw her for the first time in seventh grade. I know it's cliche, a... More

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
The Proposal: Part One
The Proposal: Part Two

8

12.3K 504 153
By Believeeexoxo

I guess Maya really does like Five Guys. I can't seem to hide the smile on my face as she scarfs the entire burger down in less than ten minutes, not a care in the world that I seem to be sitting across from her. If this were Jennifer then she'd probably order a salad or some shit, if they even have that here, but not Maya. She's got grease all over her fingers, reaching across the table to grab a napkin.

I really shouldn't find this attractive, but truthfully I think Maya could do anything and I'd find it attractive.

"So, you'll be pleased to know that I listened and followed through on our conversation last night." I tell her as I chew down another fry.

Her eyes pop up to meet mine. "How so?"

"Well, I apologized to Jennifer for..." and then I trail off, unsure of how to explain it. I don't want Maya to know I'm a virgin. I'd rather drink bleach. "Well, just being a dick I guess. Turns out she didn't need an apology."

"Because Jennifer will fuck anything in a two foot radius." She mutters. "I'm glad you listened to my advice though."

"You don't like her, do you?" I ask with a smug grin. It's almost to me like she's jealous or something from the expression on her face. Her lips are in a thin line, eyes narrowed and jaw clenched.

"She's a bitch. Plain and simple. Just like Kelsey, and Sadie, and all of the other girls you sleep with."

I laugh. "Mhm. So many girls."

"You have a type. All I'm saying."

My type is her. My god it's always been her. She thinks I've fucked everyone in a two foot radius when it's the complete opposite. I could just come right out and say it, but what would the point be? If she's into me, we both know we can't act on this. Going out to eat with her was nice, but this isn't going to happen again. It's only a one time thing. We both know that.

"Stop smiling like that." She rolls her eyes, but I can't help myself. I'm enjoying her company more than ever. Feisty, blunt, opinionated Maya is the Maya I like best.

"No clue what you're talking about." I joke, swirling the straw around in my cup to swish the ice around, never losing eye contact with her for a second. I sit back more into our booth and let out a sigh. "Enough about my sex life. Let's talk about you."

"What about me?"

I shrug. "I don't know. Tell me about your hobbies. Your interests. Gaming can't be the only thing you're into."

"My interests..." she taps her pointer finger on her chin as she looks deep in thought. "I honestly don't know. Maybe hair, or my nails. I like doing it on other people too. Like Maddie. She has great hair to braid. It's super curly, so it holds."

I don't know much about what she's talking about, but this subject seems to liven her up even more than she already is, so I ask her another question. "Is that what you want to go to school for?"

"Oh, no." She immediately replies, shaking her head back and forth. "My parents would actually murder me. Like kill me."

"Because you want to go to school for hair?"

"Because they didn't move to the states for me not to have a formal education. Cosmetology school isn't the same as going to a four year or whatever to them. Trust me, they wouldn't understand."

It seems kind of messed up to me. I can't imagine my parents ever not being supportive of something that I love to do, and after listening to Maya it makes me appreciate them a little bit more.

"Even if it's your passion though?" I ask.

"Not a chance. One time, when I was in the seventh grade, I dyed the ends of my hair pink just for the fun of it. My mom legitimately freaked out and took me straight to the hair salon to change it back. I've never been hit with a chancleta so fast before in my life."

There's that damn accent. It was only one word, and yet it shot a rush of excitement straight down my core. "A what?" I raise a brow.

"A flip-flop." She translates, and when she sees the confusion on my face she lets out a laugh. "You wouldn't understand. It's a Hispanic thing."

"Well, regardless, if doing hair and stuff is what makes you excited about life then I think you should do it. I think you'd look bad ass with dyed hair."

"You just don't understand." She shakes her head, twirling her fingers in front of her on the table. I have the strangest urge to grab onto her hand. "They gave up everything to move us here from Mexico. They uprooted their entire lives so that I could have a better future. I would never, ever do anything to disappoint them."

I'm seeing a different side of Maya. She's vulnerable, and sensitive, and I think she realizes it too because she clears her throat and sits up straighter in the booth. It seems like we both have opened up about our lives without even realizing it.

To try and lighten the mood, I grab a straw and wiggle the wrapper halfway down, blowing into the end so that it flies directly into her face.

"Really?" She deadpans, but eventually she ends up laughing. I'm grateful that I was able to change the subject. It was obvious that she didn't want to talk about it anymore. "You really think I'd look good with dyed hair? I've always wanted it to be black."

"Any color would look good." I reply, and it comes out so quickly like complete word vomit. Holy hell. I shouldn't be saying things like that. I'll give myself away. "I mean, you know you're not ugly, so..."

"So what does that make me, then?" She smiles and leans forward onto her elbows on the table, placing her chin directly into her hands. I quickly glance at her breasts that are now right in front of me, sighing as I look into her eyes. She's happy. Those browns eyes are like honey, and dammit, I'm stuck. I'm waist deep in honey, and pretty soon I'll be in over my head.

"I think..." and then I rest my hands on the table to move closer towards her too, so close that I smell the familiar scent of daisies. "You're beautiful, Maya, but you don't need me to tell you that. I think you already know it."

Just as quickly as we got closer, she sits back into the booth, crossing her arms over her chest before she lets out an irritated sigh.

"What?" I ask.

"Nothing." She sighs again. "I guess maybe you really did take my advice."

My jaw drops open in shock. "Did you just test my level of dickness?"

"I had see to see." She shrugs, but the corners of her mouth are turning up into a smile. "You passed."

I laugh and shove another fry into my mouth, and suddenly I realize that I haven't felt anxiety this entire time here with her. For the first time I'm relaxed. I didn't even have to smoke weed like I normally do after practice.

Maya gets a text. She looks at it for a few seconds before she types a response back, bringing her eyes to mine again as she sets the phone to the side.

"Everything alright?"

She nods. "Yeah. Maddie just said she was going to spend the night tonight."

Damn. For a second I forgot Maddie was the reason we couldn't be together. For a second it was just her and I sitting alone in this booth, and it was perfect.

"I can take you back to your car. It's fine." I say when I see the look of disappointment on her face. She doesn't want this to end, and neither do I. "I'm assuming you have to go if she's on her way over, right?"

"Uh, yeah." She sighs and slides out of the booth, drumming her fingertips on the table as she waits for me to rise up beside her. "Ethan, can we just not mention that we went out to eat to Maddie? I had a great time tonight, but I don't want her to get the wrong idea. Not that there's even an idea to have, but I just-"

"Maya, it's fine." I reiterate, even though a surge of disappointment just stabbed me directly in the heart. She's not wrong for saying what she did. I just wish more than anything that things could be different. "And for the record, I had a great time tonight too."

A/N:

Ok, I am loving the back story here guys. I hope you are too!!!!

Diving deep into Maya and Ethan's characters has been sooooo much fun!

What did you think?!

Please give this chapter a comment/vote!

See you Monday!!

Twitter: believeeexoxo
Instagram: deannafaison_
TikTok: authordeannafaison

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

2.3K 303 29
Spencer isn't the average seventeen year old girl. She is intelligent, sassy, stubborn, independent and beautiful ( she doesn't see it, for she is lo...
350K 9.6K 83
"How many romance books do you read?" Devin asks me. I shrug. "I like them," I say. I keep browsing, running my fingers along the spines. "...
23.8K 799 17
She smelled like pink coconut ice from Honeydukes. My own breath hitched at the thought of tasting those lips. Would she taste the same? I closed my...