Requested By Anon [I got a request, it is Connor x Reader x Jay. Reader is a pediatric trauma surgeon and very talented. She and Jay are dating when she finds Jay cheating on her with Hailey. The reader decides to leave Chicago and go to the city Connor is in. A few months later Jay shows up at Connor's door begging for the reader to take him back until he finds out she and Connor are dating and is happier with him.]
Pairings: Jay Halstead x Reader, Jay Halstead x Hailey Upton, Connor Rhodes x Reader
Featuring: Y/n, Jay Halstead, Hailey Upton, Connor Rhodes.
Summary: Y/n finds Jay cheating on her with Hailey and leaves Chicago to go see Connor
Warnings: angst, cheating, nudity, sex [kind of], betrayal, crying, jealousy, mentions of explicit sexual content, errors I missed.
w/c: 1513
Your eyes were heavy with sleep. All you wanted to do was go home and sleep. Especially you wanted to cuddle with Jay. But no, the universe had other plans for you.
A yawn escaped your mouth as you parked your car. Putting the handbrake up. Then turned the car off. You grabbed your work bag from the front seat. Slinging it across your shoulder. You took the keys out of the ignition, as you opened the door. Getting out of the car. Shutting the door and locking the car. You quickly rushed into the apartment complex. Rushing to the apartment you shared with Jay, all the while taking the apartment keys out of the bag.
Once you reached the door. You put the keys into the keyhole. Unlocking the lock.
Your hand grabbing the doorknob. Turning the doorknob. Opening the door, and walking in. you closed the door behind you. Your eyebrows furrow as you heard moaning and squeaking of the mattress coming from the bedroom. Dread filled your body as you slowly walked to the bedroom. Breathing hitching. You peaked at the half-open door. Your hands cupping your mouth. Muffling the gasp. Your heart felt like it was shattering into millions of pieces. As you looked away. Yet the image of Jay on top of Hailey, thrusting into her was burned into your mind.
You turned around. Rushing to the front door. Your gasp must have startled them because you heard the rustling of sheets, a few curse words slipping out of Jay's mouth. It made you rush to the door faster.
Jay rushed to put his boxers on. Hailey quickly put her clothes on. Guilt washing over them.
"Y/n," He shouted. As he exited the bedroom door. Hailey trailing after him. He saw you stop at the door. Hand hovering above the doorknob.
You turned around to face him with a look of heartbreak. Tears falling from your eyes like a waterfall. Lip quivering. Jay felt his heart clench. Guilt washing over him like a ton of bricks.
He was about to say something, but he heard footsteps behind him. Your gaze turned to Hailey, looking more crestfallen. You turned around quickly. Grabbing the doorknob and twisting it open. Opening the door and exiting the apartment as well as his life. Tears fell from his eyes, but he only had himself blame....
Tears blurred your vision as you drove out of Chicago. All you had on you was your work bag. Lucky had it had your wallet and phone in it.
You quickly wiped the tears away with the back of your hand. Hearing your phone vibrate constantly. You ignored it. Focusing on the road. Heartache engulfing you. You turned the radio on low hoping it would soothe your heartache, but it didn't.
It seemed the universe didn't want you to forget what you just saw. A sad song about cheating played on the radio. It made you burst into tears, as you drove. Doing your best to subside them. The only person who knew you well enough was Connor. So, that's where you were going. Maybe if you would have picked him and left Chicago with him, instead of turning him down then none of this would have occurred and you wouldn't have been heartbroken.
Self-doubt started to crawl inside of you. You should have seen the signs. The stolen glances, late nights at work, or what he claimed as work. How your works always put a strain on the relationship. But then anger sets in. he was the one that cheated on you. He was the one that wrecked the relationship. He used to accuse you of cheating on him with Connor before Connor left Chicago, but he was the one that was being unfaithful, he was the hypocrite.
It would have hurt less if it were a random girl, but no it was Hailey. His ex-girlfriend and his partner. You had a feeling this would happen. You just hoped it never did...
It was early morning when you reached Connor's place. Parking your ear in his driveway. You put the car in park, putting the handbrake up. Turning the car off, taking keys out of the ignition. Then grabbed your bag. Opening the door. Slowly getting out of the car. Shutting the door then locking the car. Walking sheepishly to his door. Heart hammering against your ribcage. Hopefully, you aren't intruding.
Connor must have heard a commotion outside and came to investigate. The door swinging open as you reached the top step.
Connor looked slightly shocked to see you outside of his door. His shock turned into a concerned look as he took in your appearance.
"Y/n, what happened?" He asked. As he rushed over to you. His hands cupping the side of your face. His touch made you melt. More tears fell from your eyes. Lips trembling.
"He cheated on me with Hailey," You gasped out. Anger rises inside of Connor. Has Jay lost his mind? He thought to himself.
You fell into Connor. Connor wrapped his arms around you. As you bury your head into his chest. Crying till there were no tears left.
"He doesn't deserve you," Connor spoke softly as he rubbed soothing circles on your back.
Connor led you inside of his place. Sitting down with you on the couch. Hugging you close to his chest. Eventually, you told him what you saw. Connor's jaw ticked as you told him. You eventually fell asleep on Connor's lap. Not that Connor minded it. Connor starred at you as you slept on his lap. His fingers combing through your hair ever so softly. He loved you, and he was going to prove it to you now that you were no longer with Jay...
TWO MONTHS LATER
You felt two arms wrap around your waist from behind you. Connor pressed himself into your back. While you poured coffee.
"You look so sexy in my shirt," Connor spoke into your ear. He pressed a soft kiss against the shell of your ear. His beard trickling your earlobe making you giggly.
"Mm... just in your shirt?" You teased. Quirking one eyebrow.
"You look sexy all the time, even sexier when you are naked, underneath me," He spoke. Voice deepening with lust.
Connor spun you around to face him. You smiled as you saw his eyes darken with lust. Taking your lower lip in between your bottom lip.
"We have work soon," You spoke. Arching an eyebrow as a warning.
"Then let's make it a quickie," He growled out. Before he could kiss you, the doorbell rang, as well as a knock interrupting Connor and you.
Connor let out a frustrated huff. As you made your way to the door.
"If it's the next-door neighbor, tell then I'm out of sugar," He spoke. You let out a laugh. Grabbing the doorknob and twisting it open.
You felt your heart leap into your throat. Your eyes were wide as you looked at the person in shock. The person happened to be Jay.
"Jay..." You brokenly gasped out.
"Y/n, I finally found you," Jay gasped out. He looked like he hadn't slept in months. Your heart was beating so fast you could barely hear your thoughts. Breathing quickening.
"W...what are you doing here?" You gasped out.
"I want you back, I'm sorry for cheating on you with Hailey," Jay started to say. Taking a deep breath. When he said Hailey's name your mind immediately flashed back to the night you saw him cheating on you with her. The words cheating and Hailey stung. It was like he was pouring salt on a wound.
"These past few months have been hell, I've been torturing myself these last few months, Hailey isn't the one I want, it's you," Jay confessed. While you stared at him in shock.
You were about to say something when you felt Connor wrap a protective arm around you. Pulling you close to him. Jay looked slightly uncomfortable, confused, and jealous. Jealous of the fact you melted right into Connors touch. Like you felt safe.
Connor glared at Jay. His jaw clenching. He would have punched Jay, for what he put you through, but restrained himself.
"You have a lot of nerve coming here, in fact, you can keep torturing yourself because she doesn't want you back," Connor snapped. Speaking for you. You felt your heart flutter. Glad Connor spoke up for you. Because you couldn't form the words to speak.
She can speak for herself," Jay growled. Glaring at Connor.
"I am speaking for the both of us, and as her boyfriend, who loves her more than you ever did or could, LEAVE," Connor growled out. Slamming the door shut, but not before Jay saw Connor give you a soft kiss on the cheek. Your face lighting up with happiness. Jay felt his heart shatter into pieces. He lost you for good. His insecurities and jealousy of Connor and your friendship pushing you towards Connor. Jay felt heartache flood through him, he only had himself to blame...
FEEDBACK IS RECOMMENDED! DON'T JUST LEAVE A VOTE ALSO COMMENT!