Always For Keeps ( For Keeps part 2)

Thirty Four. Scarlett

We spend our last day together doing tourist things. We visit St. Nicholas Orthodox Cathedral, Castle Hill Waterfall, the market, and a beautiful lighthouse.
By the time we get to the restaurant, it's early evening. The kids are exhausted, but make it though dinner fine. We walk on the beach back to the hotel. Sadness washes over me as I know we have to say goodbye. I've come to love Luke's family like they were my own.
We say our goodbyes for the night and Cooper, Luke, and I head inside.
"So who gets you tonight?" Luke teases as I take my sandals off.
"Maybe..." I say and pull my dress over my head and walk backwards to the bathroom, "myself." I wink as I toss my bra at them and laugh at their stunned faces.
They follow me quickly and I don't have time to protest as Luke's lips find mine.
He kisses me deeply as Cooper lifts me up on the counter, and kisses down my body. My head knows what's going on, and I know I should push on the breaks, but I'm lost in the moment, and I don't really care about anything else at this moment; except being in the bathroom.
"Wait." I finally breathe. "You're really not going to do this in a bathroom, are you?" I tease and Cooper throws me over his shoulder. I gasp and Luke laughs and smacks my ass.
Cooper sets me on the bed and I sit up and watch as he rips my panties from my skin.
"Fuck." I say and lean back and close my eyes. Luke resumes kissing my lips as Cooper kisses my lower stomach, working his way down.
I don't even know how this is going to work; am I going to fuck them both? What am I even doing?
As Cooper reaches his destination, all coherent thoughts float out the window and crash onto the sand below.
I can't focus as Luke moves to my chest.
This is so wrong, yet, I don't want them to stop. My hands grip the bedsheets. I can't hold back any longer as I come. Luke kisses me hard as I come down. I don't dare to open my eyes.
"What do you want, Scarlett?" Cooper breaths next to me.
"I don't know." I whisper.
"Do you want to stop?" Luke asks.
"No." I smile as my face heats up. "But I literally have no idea what to do now."
"Me either." Cooper laughs.
"Don't look at me." Luke laughs. "Mandy and Stacey played with each other. Cooper and I won't."
"Yeah, that's a boner killer." Cooper says and I laugh.
"How about we just fuck one on one?" I say awkwardly.
"Whatever you want." Cooper says.
"But let's make it interesting." Luke says and I brave a look at him. He moves from the bed and returns with a tie. He ties it around my eyes and I laugh.
"Okay, someone has watched fifty shades one too many times." I laugh.
"This is what you get for forcing it upon me." He laughs.
"Okay." I say as excitement courses though me.
"Neither of us will talk. We will go Rock Paper Scissors out in the hall to see who goes first."
"You're hilarious if you don't think I'll know who is who." I reach out and touch their chests. Subtle differences will easily give it away.
"She's right." Cooper says.
"One minute." Luke says.
When he returns, he gently ties my hands to the headboard.
"There." He says and I know he is smiling.
"One more thing." Cooper says. They put his Bose Headphones over my ears and Coldplay comes through playing softly in my ears.
I feel them move off the bed and I wait.
It feels like an eternity before someone gets back on the bed. He kisses my neck, my chest, my stomach, back up to my chest. I'm trying to focus on little things to tell them a part. Neither have shaved in a few days, so stubble lightly covers their chins. I wait for him to fuck me. I'll know then... right?
When he presses into me I try to move my hands to touch him, but the restraints tug at my wrists.
With most of my senses taken away, I focus solely on the feeling building between my legs. This is so exhilarating.
I bite my lip trying to hold back, but it's short lived as I come hard. I feel his body still, before moving out of me and moving off the bed. One kiss to my lips before he disappears.
I'm breathing heavy, trying to regain my composure. I don't have long to recover as he bed shifts again, and he kisses almost the same places the other did; those fuckers planned it that way. I'm almost annoyed, but when he thrusts into me, I can't focus on anything other than the feeling.
Each orgasm is more intense, and this one is building up to make me explode.
I try holding back as a thin layer of sweat covers me. He's doing good holding back himself, so I clench tightly on to him and he picks up pace.
He slams into me and I lose it. I feel so high, I swear I almost black out. He stills inside me, and pulls out.
I pull at whatever is tied on my wrists, but nothing happens.
The bed shifts, one kiss to my lips, but nothing else. Halsey sings softly in my ears and I realize they are going to take a few minutes. It would give them away, if one was trying to calm his breathing and the other was good.
Ass holes.
I slow my breathing and wait. After two more songs, the bed shifts and Cooper takes the head phones off and the tie, while Luke undoes the robe tie from my wrists.
"Hey." Cooper smiles.
"Hi." I barely say. Now that I'm back to normal and not consumed by them being inside me, I realize I just fucked them both and I feel my neck and cheeks flush.
"How are you?" Luke asks.
"Embarrassed now that I'm not distracted with your bodies making me come." They both smile and I want to smack them. "I kind of feel like a slut." I pout.
"Don't say that." Cooper frowns.
"Yeah, besides, who's to say you fucked both of us? Maybe it was one of us, twice." Luke grins wickedly.
"Was it?" I ask raising my brow.
"You'll never know." He says.
"Seriously!" I sit up.
"Was it bad?" Cooper asks.
"No." I say and blush as I remember how good it felt. Wrong, but so good.
"Then there's nothing to worry about." Cooper smiles.
"Are you both okay?" I ask.
"Yes." Cooper says.
"Yeah." Luke says.
"I guess the biggest question is if we do that again?" Cooper says.
"Yes." I say without missing a beat and instantly I blush as they smile. "I mean if you want to that is. It wasn't bad, I didn't dislike it. Like at all. It was exciting, but I mean, you're both exciting on your own anyway. Ya know?" I take a breath as the laugh at me. "Shut it." I laugh and climb off the bed. I go to stand and as I close my legs, I realize how sore I'll be tomorrow. It reminds me of the day after they proposed this to me, I was soaking in the jetted tub and thought how amazingly sore I would be.
"What's wrong?" Cooper asks.
"Are you okay?" Luke's eyes are full of concern.
"I'm fine." I roll my eyes. "Let a girl have a moment, will you?" I tease.
They both smile as I walk to the bathroom.
After a quick shower, I'm all cleaned up, and I head back out. They are both waiting on the bed.
"I'm sore." I tease. "But it's a good sore, so if you guys want, I could be persuaded to go more."
"We have created a monster!" Luke laughs.
"A very sex crazed monster." Cooper teases. "Are you- could you be-"
"Pregnant? I don't think so yet. Soon, baby." I smile and kiss him. "Should I have kept my legs up?" I ask trying to trick them.
"Nice try." Luke laughs and pulls me into his arms. "Neither of us got jealous. If you were worried."
"I was." I smile at them.
"Maybe we took turns watching." Luke says raising an eyebrow. My eyes widen as I look between them. They are teasing me. Jerks.
"Oh really?" I say and move to Cooper's lap. "Did it turn you on watching me get fucked?" I ask as I lean forward and kiss Cooper's neck, but watch Luke suck in a breath. I move my hand down and feel Cooper harden under my touch.
"Scarlett." Cooper warns.
"Yeah Scarlett." Luke smirks knowing I wouldn't do anything. I turned down a threesome because I'm a fucking prude, but something in Luke's eyes sets me off. I pull my shirt over my head; never breaking my gaze on Luke. His jaw twitches and I shift on Cooper.
"Fuck Scarlett. You made your point." Cooper says, but I know his control is slipping as he sets me on the bed next to him. Neither of them see each other when it comes to a naked me. Luke grins, but it's short lived as I reach my hand down into my wetness.
They both stop breathing and I smile. Neither move, they watch me intently. After a few minutes I almost stop because I really didn't want to sit and play with myself, I wanted to show them I am not some wuss. If they can do this, so can I.
The look at each other, a silent agreement, before moving slowly to me.

Here we go.