The Ones Who Drowned

Start from the beginning
                                        

Jeff was so happy for you to train with him. He taught you how to carve organs, wait that was EJ. He taught you how to stab brutality. You both laugh insanely. You were insanely jealous and wanted to kill her. Badly. You got a tight feeling in your chest and a another series of laughs hit. You were laughing and then jumped onto the branch being quiet but your breaths were jagged. You calm down as soon as they got under you. The girl tells BEN to go ahead. He nods and walks home. He ignored her as he heard her screams and just walked away. You were ontop of her and stabbed her brain making sure she couldn't do anything. You stabbed her in the neck making her choke and she bled out. You opened her chest and took the organs out you grabbed some kidneys for EJ. He'd be so proud. And Jeff too. But BEN? He will definitely be mad at you. She was going home. But nope. She died. Jeff appeared from out of nowhere.
"Did you do it?" He asks. You smile insanely. "Of course I did." He chuckles and pats your head. "Let's get you cleaned up." You felt like a small child again. "Jeff!" He looks at you. "What?"
You look up, since you were shorter then him. "Carry me!" He chuckles. "Okay. Shortie." You smirk and start singing. "Go shortie it's your birthday! Party hard like it's your birthday!" He rolls his eyes. You both got home. Nobody was in the living room and it was dark in the house. You checked the time. It was pretty late. You ask Jeff to get your bubble bath ready. (deal with it.) He rolls his eyes for the millionth time. (suprised they haven't fallen out yet.) He sighs. "Fine." He puts strawberry scented bubble bath. (Since he likes red. And It kinda looked like blood.) "A shower would be too loud." You smirk. He sighs and got you your clothes. "Here." You smile up at him. "Thank you bro!" He pats your head. BEN was asleep. "His phone was next to him." He smiles evilly. "I did not check it." You looked at him. "Tell me!" He chuckles. "Okay. Come in my room when your done. But go back to BEN's when I am done telling you." You smile "Okay!" You asked him one more thing. "Get me some rubber ducks!" He laughed. "Alright." They looked like the pastas. You smile. "Yay!" He chuckled quietly and closed the door. You got undressed and turned off the water. You put the ducks in the water and played with them. And thirty minutes later you were having a battle with the rubber ducks. "PEW PEW!" You shout quietly. Jeff walked into the bathroom and saw you were having a rubber duck battle. He took his jacket off putting it on the door knob and his black shirt has some light splotches of blood. Some were here and there on his shirt.
He played with one group of rubber ducks and you got the other.and you both had a battle until all the bubbles disappeared. He chuckles. "That was one battle." You nod in agreement. "I'm tired. I'll text you." He says while yawning. "Okay!" He smiles. "Get dressed ghostie." He walks out.
You roll your eyes and put on some black pajama pants and a black T-Shirt and a black hoodie Jeff left you. Jeff left his hoodie so you put the black hoodie in a cabinet. You slip on the hoodie and walk into BEN's room. He opened his eyes and looks at you. "Oh hi Jeff.." His eyes widen. "Wait." "(y/n)?!"

"In the flesh. Well decayed flesh that is." You smile. "Where is my girlfriend!!" He shouts quietly. "Oh uh she died." Your face darkened. "How?" He ask looking at you suspiciously. You smirk. "I dunno I wonder why." You walk away out the door and drag her body to a pit and set it on fire. BEN was looking for you. Her face was weird, so you pulled a knife out of the pocket of the hoodie (Well Jeff's hoodie that is.) You started carving a smile and put the knife in the pocket walking inside the house. BEN was still outside looking for you. He walked into the house.
The fire that was burning couldn't burn anything except bodies.
He pins you to the ground. "Where. Is. She?" You look up at him. "Uh her body is kinda burnt so I can't really know." You smirk. "Oh and by the way if you chop my head off now I will look so cool." You smile. "I will find a pumpkin head and be the headless horseman!" You say cheerfully. He growls. "Listen to me BEN." He glares at you. "Why should I?" "I have done some terrible thing." His gaze soften as your gaze was sad and broken. He sighs. "Fine. What?" You sigh. "I guess it's time I tell you." He sighs. "Tell me what?" You smile awkwardly. "I like you." His eyes widen. "I actually more then like you. I love you."
And you looked down sadly. "I killed her to be with you. Because I was jealous BEN." You were crying. "I just wanted you to notice me!" You sob into his tunic.

"I love you too (y/n)." He pats your back. "I just thought you didn't feel the same." You both were crying. Jeff was standing there watching. "Uh, Good morning?" You ran over and hugged Jeff. "Thank you!" He smiles and looks and BEN. He sighs. "We killed her. Well mostly (y/n)." You see BEN walk over. "She did what now?" You all chuckle. "I know she told me." Jeff laughed. "Her first kill too." You all sigh. "I'm surprised her parents called haven't me yet. Besides, I probably deleted and blocked their number anyway." You all laugh. "Yeah." Jeff smirks. "Shorties."
You roll your eyes. "Says you! You played with rubber ducks!"
He glares at you. "Maybe." You all break into a fit of quiet chuckles. You randomly pull out a jar of kidneys. You and Jeff look at each other challengingly. "I will get there first." You both race to the door. And you won. "Ha ha you loose!" You say quietly shouting. He smacks you upside the head. "Owie." You knock on the door. "EJ? Do you want to build a snowman?" You hear a sigh and he opens the door. "Just give whatever you want to give me." You hold the jar out to him. He takes it. "Thanks." He nods. "No prob EJ!" You smile. He closed the door. You got some new hatchets for Toby too. You knock on Toby's door. "Yo tobs. I got you something." He opens the door tiredly. "What is it?" You give him the gifts. "Here you go!" He smiles. "Ah thanks. Mine were rusted and a lot of crusted blood." You smile. "No prob Tobster." He chuckles and closes the door. You walk to Masky's door. Jeff was making some toast. So it was you. Alone. "Maskyy?" He opens the door. "What." You gave him a picture of you and him and a knife. He nods. "Thanks (y/n)." You smile. "No problem!" You close the door. And you hear him shuffling. You walk to Hoodie's door.

"Yo hoodster." He opens the door. "Y-yeah (y/n)?" You hand him a new gun. He smiles. "Ah a new pistol. Thanks." His was bloody and rusted. "No problem!" You walked to every Pasta's room. They thanked you and went back to whatever they were doing. You left a present for BEN and Jeff when you were done. BEN walked up to you and hugged you. You hugged him and took in the smell of his clothes. It smelled like faint colonge and (Your Mom.) blood. "(y/n) I love you too." You pull back from his embrace and kiss him on the lips. He kissed back and smiles. "I am glad you do too."

The End.

Random X Reader One-Shots (REQUESTS OPEN)Where stories live. Discover now