Creepypasta Boyfriend scenarios

Part 17| Makeup challenge

Authors P.O.V

Slenderman

"Slendy!" You called
"Please don't call me that-" he groaned
"Slendy" you smirked and he sighed in response
"Yes?"
"I have a surprise for you!"
"What is it?"
"Basically, there's this challenge and whoever does the best makeup on each other wins!"

Slenderman went silent for a moment and sat beside you on the couch.

"Do I have to?"
"Yep!" You sang in a cheery tone
"... I guess I didn't really have a choice"
"Nope!" You said in the same tone

After you realise you didn't have guidelines (eyes, nose, mouth ect...), you decide to improvise. You grabbed some eyeliner and drew out some eyes,, grabbed some red lipstick and drew on some lips and added some blusher and over features. When it came to your turn, he was so baffled at the makeup he had never seen. You laughed at how hard he was trying and thought it was kinda cute. Soon, you both were ready to pick up your mirrors and look.

"3...2...1... Go!" You smiled

Looking at yourself in the mirror, you basically looked like miles Cyrus and lady gaga in one. You laughed at how weird it looked then looked at slenderman who sighed once more...

Jeff the killer

"Jeffery!" You said, running into the room and hugging him from behind
"Was'up?" He asked as he gazed down at you
"Can we do the makeup-"
"No" he said with a harsh tone
"Pleaaaaase" you begged
"N-O spells-"
"PLEASE"
"UUUUUURG, WHY DO I HAVE TO?!"
"Fine you said, letting him go and eyes began to tear up
"O-ok I will, just don't cry" he hugged you
"Yay!" You cheered

-later-

"Ok... Now!" Jeff held a mirror to your face and you gasped. He did a pretty good job... Except the lipstick which he drew a massive smile on your face.

"Now your as beautiful as me" he said proudly
"Sure" you rolled your eyes and laughed before holding a mirror to his face
"MY FACE!" He practically yelled and ran out...

'I guess he doesn't like being a girly girl' you thought to yourself and laughed

Ben drowned

"Pleeeeease" you begged
"What do I get out of this?" He smirked
"Something special" you smiled
"Oh yeah?" His smirk remained and his face was close to yours "and what's thay
"You will look pretty for once!" You laughed

He groaned and fell back onto the couch.

"As long as you don't do permanent damage. I guess it's fine" he sighed
"Yay!" You hugged him

You did his smokey eye look with ease, adding wings to his eyelids (for the people who don't know, you can look it up :3) with some blush and skin tone lipstick.

When you showed him the mirror he smiled and laughed before turning it towards you, looking at yourself in the mirror you laughed at the similarity.

Eyeless Jack

You and Jack were on the sofa, him watching TV and you on your laptop. You starting watching random stuff on YouTube to pass time and eventually came across a video labelled "'MAKEUP CHALLENGE". Jack peered over and questioned it for a moment and you briefly explained the rules and so on so forth.

Then you turned to jack and smiled~

"(Y/N), I know what your thinking and it's a no"
"I know your going to agree with me either way" you smiled
"Oh yeah? Whys that?" He said slightly confused
"I will get slender to put you on a strict kidney-free diet for a month"
"................. Fine"
"YAY!"

You grabbed your makeup and looked at jack, slowly lifting his mask and looking at his pale face. He smiled and you smiled back, grabbing some concealer to brighter up his face and add some mascara, lipstick and other things you thought looked nice. Once it was his turn, he looked at the makeup and it felt like he added barely anything to your face.

You handed him a mirror and he laughed, staring at his face a moment before shaking his head. He handed the mirror to you and you were surprised only to find some mascara and pale lipstick. You looked up and as if he already knew your question, he answered-

"You beautiful without makeup"