'Be mine' (Jeff the Killer x Reader)

Chapter Four

(Reader POV)

I wake up in a weird room, with Jeff sitting on the other side. "I-I'm so sorry..." I start. "I just don't know what happened, an-and no matter how hard I tried I couldn't stop myself." I say. "I know you wouldn't have done it on purpose. I'm going to figure out who did this to you." He said.

"Don't untie these ropes until this is over, I really don't want to hurt someone else.." I say. "I really hate to say it, but I think you're right." He said. "And now might be a good time for you to meet some people.." he says. "Ok-Okay." I say.

*Time skip brought to you by Toby in a tutu*

I watch a tall, faceless man walk in with a few other people. "(Y/N)," it says. "I'm Slenderman, but call me Slender." Wow, he's kinda scary. "I'm not all that bad" he says. Wait you can read my mind? "Yes, I can." He says. Wow.

There was a guy beside him, with fluffy brown hair, orange goggles, and a mask. On the other side, was a guy that looked like Link, from The Legend of Zelda. "This is Toby" he points to the one with goggles. "This one is Ben." He points to the other. "They know who you are already, but I think I can help with your mind control problem." Slender says.

He puts his arms on my head, and I shut my eyes. "Now this might hurt for a second." He says. Something happened, I'm not sure what, but it was painful. It was a little worse than getting hit in the head with a brick. Ouch. I try not to scream, because it might make it harder on Slender.

After that, I felt free of something. "Do you remember anything?" He asks. "No-Not yet." I say. "Don't force yourself, it'll come to you. But you're good now. I got rid of the mind control." He says as he unties me. I hug him. "Thank you!" I say. "You're welcome.." he says hesitantly.

I go to greet Toby and Ben. "Hello! I know you already know me, but I'm (Y/N)!" I say excitedly. "I'm To-Toby." Toby says. "Ben" the other says, reaching his hand out for me to shake. I shake his hand. "I've got work to do, I'll see you around cutie." Ben says. My face turns red. "Don't min-mind *tic* him." Toby said, rolling his eyes.

"You have to stay here, and be a proxy. Unless you want to die." Slender says. "I'll be a proxy then.." I say. "Alright, but you have to stay with Jeff until you have a room." 'That won't be a problem, I know him well' I thought.

*Another time skip brought to you by Jeff chasing Ben*

I walked into Jeff's room, and he was laying on his bed playing with his knife. "Hey Jeff" I say. "Sup" he replies. "Sup? Are you too cool for me now?" I laugh. He chuckles a bit. "You've always been way cooler than me" he jokes.

I sit on the floor, bored. "Why are you on the floor?" He asks. "I didn't want to bother you on your bed." I say.  "You won't." He said. I sit down awkwardly. He glances up at me, but I look at him and he quickly looks away. Was there something on my face?

"So...." I start. He doesn't answer. "I'm sorry about all that stuff with the mind control.." I say. "It's Fine, you couldn't really do anything considering how weak you are." He says, smirking at me. "I am not weak!" I said. I tackled him on his bed. He flips me over where he's on top, "You should never fight a psychopath with a knife." He says and chuckles. I blush, because he was on top of me. He notices and get off. I notice his pale face has a slight pink tint on it.

"I'm going to go talk to Toby." I say, "Okay, be careful around Ben though" he advised. "Alright."

I knock on Toby's door and wait. "Co-Come in!" He calls. "Hey Toby!!" I yell. "Hey (Y/N)!!" He yells back. "Wanna talk and have waffles?" I ask. "Of cou-course!" He says. "Let's go!!!!!" I yell. We run downstairs and make waffles. "So, I need to talk to you. And I need youre honest opinion as my best friend." I tell him seriously. "Okay?" He says.

"How do I know if I like Jeff?" I ask him. His face lights up. "YOU LIKE JE-" I cut him off before he can say his name. "Shut up!" I yell. "I can't beli-*tic*-believe it!" He exclaims. "How do I know if he likes me too?" I ask. "Okay, I'll pre-pretend to ask you ou-out, and see what he does." Toby explains. "Okay.." I agree hesitantly.

When Jeff was walking in the kitchen, Toby gave me a signal to start. "So (Y-Y/N), I wanted to ask if yo-you wanted to *tic* go out to dinner some-sometime?" He says. "Sure!" I say, and glance over at Jeff. He looks annoyed. "Actually Toby, (Y/N) and I are going to the fair together." He says and walks to us. "Oh okay," Toby says. "Isn't that right, (Y/N)?" Jeff said, and looks over at me. "Y-Yeah!" I say, going along with it.

"I'm heading off to bed.." I tell Jeff and Toby. "I'll come with you." Jeff says. My face turns a little pink. I stand up, but slip on a puddle of syrup. DANG IT TOBY. I close my eyes, ready for my face to meet the floor. But it didn't. Jeff caught me. My face turns even more red. He picks me up and carries me upstairs. "H-Hey! I can walk you know!" I say. "Yeah if you don't trip every step." He teased.

He sets me down, and I lay down on his bed. He stands in the corner. "What are you doing?" I ask. "I'm sleeping here." "No! That's too uncomfortable, just cmon." I say, pointing to the spot beside me. I realize what I said and try to hide my face. I feel him lay down beside me, and I drift off to sleep thinking about him.
________________________________
Hey! I won't be able to update until Monday, unfortunately. But I have some things planned and I'll update soon!
Word count:1091
-SnoozeDoodle