Andy x Peter oneshots (Requests Closed)

at the Christmas party

(I'm Canadian so Thanksgiving already passed for me so now you know why I'm making this... ye)

Andy woke up, his friends surrounded him.
"What happened?" Andy asked as he sat up.
"You passed out after you opened your present." Margaret explained.
Andy looked at the box, he grabbed it and looked inside.
Inside was just a hatchet.
"I must have been just... nothing." Andy sighed.
"Are you alright?" Claus asked.
"Yeah, yeah, I'm fine." Andy said as he got off the floor.
"Well, while you were out, we found more decorations and put them up to pass time." Melody explained.
"That's good." Andy smiled.
Andy looked around.
He saw a decoration he never used since... who does now a days.
The mistletoe.
"Hm."
"You should sit down just in case." Felix said.
"Yeah, good idea." Andy walked over to the couch and sat down.
Just then, there was a knock at the door.
They found it strange, knowing that they were the only ones who lived on this farm.
Andy sighed and got up again.
He walked to the door and once he opened it.
"Oh fuck no!" Andy slammed the door right in Peter's face.
"Andy! Let me in!" Peter whined from the other side of the door.
"Who was that?" Felix asked.
"A monster." "That's hurtful!" "Go away Peter!" "You should treat a friend better!" "I'M NOT YOUR FRIEND!" "Your hurting my feelings Andy!"
"Okay, who is that? Actually." Margaret crossed her arms.
"I'm Peter the Pumpkin!" Peter cheered from behind them.
They jumped in fear.
"How!? Weren't you just outside!?" Melody yelled.
"Uhhhhhh, magic?" Peter's lie wasn't convincing.
"Wooooow! You're so tall!" Felix was the only one who wasn't disturbed by Peter.
"I guess." Peter shrugged.
Andy ran past Peter and grabbed the new hatchet.
He threw it at Peter's head but Peter caught it.
"Chill Candy Apple, I ain't here to mess with you, I just wanted to hangout." Peter turned to Andy.
"How can I trust you?" Andy asked.
"Like I fucking know, I also got you this."
Peter handed Andy a box.
Margaret took the box before Andy could grab it.
"I'm just going to mske sure it's safe for Andy."
Margaret took a peek inside and closed it.
Margaret was snickering.
"What is funny?" Claus asked.
Margaret handed the box to Claus.
Claus looked inside and he too started snickering.
"Let me see!" Felix took the box from Claus.
He looked inside and started laughing.
Melody grabbed the box and looked inside.
Mekody started giggling and handed the box to Andy.
Andy looked inside.
Inside was a picture of Peter standing over Andy's sleeping body with a marker in hand... and Andy had penises drawn all over his face.
"Man, fuck you." Andy threw the picture into the fireplace.
"Meh, I knew you wouldn't like it but I didn't knw what you would like." Peter chuckled.

Andy was doing his best to stay away from Peter but Peter was just always near Andy.
The only thing that Andy actually enjoyed about Peter is that when he would walk into another room, he would bang his head on the door frame.

"I HATE BEING TALL!" Peter yelled.
He yet again hit his head on a door frame.
Andy walked over to Peter and helped him up.
"Hey Andy, Peter, look up." Felix snickered.
They looked up... they were right under the mistletoe.
"No-"
Peter kissed Andy right on the lips.
Andy froze.
"I didn't know apples could be that red." Peter smirked.
Andy covered his face in embarrassment.
"You two would make a great couple." Melody smiled.
Andy glared at Melody.
"You know what, we'll see you tomorrow."
Margaret immediately pushed everyone out leaving Andy with Peter.
"Hey." Peter looked down at Andy.
"Hi." Andy was a but confused.
"Sooooooo, wanna do something?" Peter asked.
"What do you have in mind?" "We could watch a movie." "Sounds good to me."

Andy looked through his pile of movies as Peter made popcorn.
"Why did Peter kiss me? I thought he would've just said no." Andy mumbled.
Andy found two movies, one was a Christmas horror movie and the other was just a normal Christmas movie for a family.
"I got the popcorn, did you find a movie?" Peter asked.
"Uh yeah, I found two though, I've seen both of these so which one do you wanna see?"
Andy walked over to Peter and showed him both of the cases.
"This one seems more interesting." Peter pointed at the horror one, doing his best not to drop the big bowl of popcorn.
"Alright."

Halfway through the movie, Andy was scared and Peter noticed.
Peter wrapped an arm around Andy.
Andy looked up at him then back at the tv.
He leaned on Peter.
Peter smiled amd they continued watching.

At some point, Andy was really scared.
Andy hugged Peter's torso tightly.
"Calm down Andy." Peter laughed.
"I'm scared." Andy whined.
Andy looked up at Peter
"What?"
Andy didn't say anything.
"Why are you looking at me like that?"
Andy pulled Peter closer to him.
"Hey-"
Andy cut off Peter with a kiss.
Peter was shocked, but he kissed back.
...
Just then, a loud noise came from the tv.
Andy immediately fell of the couch.
"You okay?" Peter asked.
Andy sat up.
"Yeah." Andy laughed.
Andy got back on the couch... then out of no where, he was hit in the face with a pillow.
"What the hell!" "Pillow fight?" "No."
*Insert Peter crying in the corner*
"Alright." Peter chuckled.
"The movies almost over." Andy just noticed.
"How about we go to bed, I'll stay the night." Peter grinned.
"Sure, just don't draw dicks on my face." Andy crossed his arms.
"How about-" "I'm not going to have sex with you." "Worth a shot."

Andy and Peter laid down in Andy's bed.
Peter was holding Andy like a teddy bear, Andy didn't mind, he felt safe in Peter's arms.
"I want to-" "No Peter." "Please." "No." "I'll do anything." "Are you sure?" "Yes." "You'll help me with work tomorrow." "I changed my mind, it's not worth the sex." "Are you sure?" "I am." "Good, now go to sleep." "I love you Andy."
...
"I love you too Peter"

(I accidentally published it before it was done so if y'all got a notification before, I'm sorry)