Who to choose? (Jeff the Killer x Reader) (Reader x Ticci Toby) by UnicornLoverF1
Who to choose? (Jeff the Killer Sum
(Yn) (Ln) was never normal. She read about creepypasta's from time to time. She was abused by her parents and only had one friend. She was bullied and had attempted suic...
  • whotochoose
  • ticcitoby
  • creepypasta
+10 more
Jeff The Killer x Reader ~Completed~ by StupidFxckingNerd
Jeff The Killer x Reader Nerd 🌻
Jeff The Killer x Reader!! ----- You hated your birthday. Always have. Always will. 'Why can't she just get the message I am trying to put out?' You thought. Ever since...
  • xreader
  • jeffthekiller
  • love
+3 more
The Innocent Eyes (Jeff The Killer X Reader) by MusicIsGreat678
The Innocent Eyes (Jeff The MusicIsGreat
Strange things happen under strange circumstances and sometimes the most unsafe people make you feel the most safe. When you meet Jeff, he's not exactly like the stories...
  • masky
  • jeffthekiller
  • bendrowned
+9 more
Make You Beautiful - [Jeff the Killer x reader] by IceT3a
Make You Beautiful - [Jeff the IceT3a .
(Y/N) didn't have an easy life. But she only realized how happy she actually was after she had lost it all to a bipolar maniac who wanted her all to himself. DISCLAIMER...
  • murder
  • readerxcharacter
  • gory
+17 more
Jeff the killer x Child reader by FlawlessMistake7
Jeff the killer x Child readerby FlawlessMistake7
There aren't many stories like this, so I decided why not? this story is about a child named Y/N who gets adopted by the creepypastas. (No photos are mine, unless said o...
  • reader
  • eyelessjack
  • parent
+13 more
Sweet Cheeks | Jeff The Killer X Reader {Book 1} | ✔ by pecksniff
Sweet Cheeks | Jeff The Killer X Yumi
You slightly smile,"You look like a bad boy to me.." You giggle,"Oh, really? How?" Jeff lets go,"Um, well, you just look hot. Hot boys are usual...
  • jeffthekiller
  • romance
  • lemon
+4 more
Bloody Rose 🌹creepypasta x killer!reader! by ChocolateLoveHeart
Bloody Rose 🌹creepypasta x ChocolateLoveHeart
(y/n) is one of the top most wanted killer in the whole world.With her (h/l)(h/c) hair and her glowing (e/c) eyes she is known as Bloody Rose. Her mother is a shadow de...
  • creepypasta
  • fantasy
  • love
+3 more
Jeff the killer X reader by Creepypasta70
Jeff the killer X readerby Creepypasta70
You hate your life and your Suicidal. You felt like you were worthless because your abusive boyfriend. Jeff changed that. He thinks your annoying but when your in tears...
  • creepypasta
  • bendrowned
  • sally
+2 more
Going Insane For You by Spxcer
Going Insane For Youby Ace
I've read about 4 or 5 Jeff x Reader fanfictions so I decided to make a Jeff x reader fanfiction o3o. I don't know much about all of the creepy pastas so if I get some o...
  • jeffthekiller
  • allthatshit
  • creepypasta
+7 more
(Creepypasta x Reader) Insanity's Little Game  [ON HIATUS] by MultiFandomTrashx900
(Creepypasta x Reader) Insanity' Exhausted Pigeon
You've seen the title, no description needed ----------WARNING---------- In this story there will be • Somewhat graphic content • Language (cursing/cussing) • Some refer...
  • insane
  • maskyxreader
  • creepypastaxreader
+17 more
Mr. & Mrs. Woods | ✔ by pecksniff
Mr. & Mrs. Woods | ✔by Yumi
  • jeff
  • romance
  • love
+7 more
Creepypasta x reader (A Jeff the Killer x Reader Fanfiction) DISCONTINUED by catherineannewaffles
Creepypasta x reader (A Jeff the CoryxKenshin
You were always abused by your foster parents but now.. You were saved by two women who went on a killing spree that surprisingly met you! Now,that the three of you bum...
  • creepypasta
  • creepypastaxreader
  • jeffxreader
+3 more
Jeff Atkins x Reader by Achy_xx
Jeff Atkins x Readerby Achy_xx
Jeff deserved better
  • hannahbaker
  • justinfoley
  • brandonlarracuente
+8 more
My bloody Romance (Jeff the killer x reader) by ShaylaPhantomhive
My bloody Romance (Jeff the Shayla (Ayy whaddup)
Your name is (Y/N) (L/N). Your father has gotten a job at some far away place he refuses to tell you the name of and says you suddenly have to move. You're forced to lea...
  • romance
  • creepypastas
  • fluff
+11 more
Seeing Things (Jeff the killer X Reader) by Gabthesecond
Seeing Things (Jeff the killer X Goals.
(Y/N) has been seeing weird things lately. Her friend, Jayden, keeps saying it's because her lack of sleep. However, (Y/N) has a vision that she knows isn't fake.
  • creepypasta
  • interesting
  • ilovecreepypasta
+13 more
ACE (Jeff X Reader) ~The Death Card by iPsychoPast
ACE (Jeff X Reader) ~The Death Cardby Atrimix
"Hey Jeff?" "Hm?" "C-Can I ask you a question?" "What is it?" "Why did you cut your eyelids..?" He chuckled softly and...
  • jeffxreader
  • fanfiction
  • horror
+3 more
Little Princess | Jeff The Killer X Reader {Book 2} | ✔ by pecksniff
Little Princess | Jeff The Yumi
SEQUEL TO: 'Sweet Cheeks| Jeff The Killer X Reader {Book 1}' -EDITING- "Damn cats." You smile and giggle. "Hu-!" Jeff pulls your body towards his and...
  • creepypasta
  • fanfiction
  • lemon
+4 more
With Every Smile(jeff x reader) by Lost_Amber
With Every Smile(jeff x reader)by Amberonii
It was EXTREMELY late, you had went to a friends 16 birthday party and on the way home you encountered someone breaking into your home! You rushed there you didn't fi...
  • adventure
  • twistending
  • creepypasta
+7 more
Jeff The Killer Boyfriend Scenarios (One Shots) by Cian_Perks
Jeff The Killer Boyfriend p o t a t o s a u r u s.
Just some random boyfriend scenarios and oneshots with one of my favorite Creepypasta character Jeff The Killer. Angst/Fluff/Smut *MAYBE* ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°) ...
  • creepypasta
  • jeffthekillerboyfriendscenarios
  • shortstories
+5 more
Our Forsaken Princess (stitched kisses: book 2) by WolvenWhiteRabbit
Our Forsaken Princess (stitched Alice Winters
jeff and y/n now have a beautiful baby girl. after jeffs return they thought nothing could go wrong. but it can. becareful what you wish for. the girl is now 6 and doesn...
  • sequel
  • backstabbing
  • jeffthekillerxreader
+9 more