Lost (in Your Emerald Eyes)

By Rivernugget

198K 12.8K 10.2K

"They said opposites attract. Like the Sun and the moon, they draw to one another. Then why, now that I know... More

F O R E W O R D
P R O L O G U E
O N E
T H R E E
F O U R
F I V E
S I X
S E V E N
E I G H T
N I N E
T E N
E L E V E N
T W E L V E
T H I R T E E N
F O U R T E E N
F I F T E E N
S I X T E E N
S E V E N T E E N
E I G H T E E N
N I N E T E E N
T W E N T Y
T W E N T Y - O N E
T W E N T Y - T W O
T W E N T Y - T H R E E
T W E N T Y - F O U R
T W E N T Y - F I V E
T W E N T Y - S I X
T W E N T Y - S E V E N
T W E N T Y - E I G H T
T W E N T Y - N I N E
T H I R T Y
T H I R T Y - O N E
T H I R T Y - T W O
T H I R T Y - T H R E E
T H I R T Y - F O U R
T H I R T Y - F I V E
T H I R T Y - S I X
T H I R T Y - S E V E N
T H I R T Y - E I G H T
T H I R T Y - N I N E
F O R T Y
F O R T Y - O N E
F O R T Y - T W O
F O R T Y - T H R E E
F O R T Y - F O U R
F O U R T Y - F I V E
F O R T Y - S I X
E P I L O G U E
S E Q U E L

T W O

4.5K 323 136
By Rivernugget

Reading books was like an escape from the world for Jughead. He could just lie on his pullout couch, ankles crossed, and get lost in somewhere else, with someone else, as somebody else. There wasn't anything better than that.

"Boy!" his father's voice called. Jughead jerked and sat up, pushing the book under his pillow and quickly lighting a cigarette next to him. FP walked into the trailer that exact moment and Jughead took a deep breath, releasing the smoke afterward.

"I told you not to do it in the trailer," the man grumbled.

Jughead rolled his eyes and stood from the couch, wondering that if he already lit it for a show, he could just as well finish it. Bumping into his dad's shoulder, he left the trailer, shutting the door behind him with a small thud, and sat on the few steps outside.

Releasing another steam of smoke with a growl on his face, Jughead looked at the homeless dog who was always wandering around the trailer park, looking for food and shelter. He had started calling him Hotdog a few years back, and the animal had adapted it pretty quickly.

He blew a whistle and the dog started jogging towards him immediately, the boy keeping his face neutral while waiting for the three-year-old sheepdog to run into his arms. Before that could happen though, the trailer door opened again, revealing his dad, and the dog stopped, afraid of men with alcohol smell on them.

"Jug." The boy didn't answer and simply kept smoking, staring at the dog twenty feet away who had started barking at FP. "You have a shift at the bar tomorrow."

"I know, I have it every night." FP frowned and scratched the back of his neck, getting Jughead's attention. Something was going on. "What?

"Uh... I need to get groceries."

Jughead sighed deeply and stared into the man's cold brown eyes, attempting to find the dad he had once known. There were no signs of him. But Jughead couldn't say no. He never could. So, pulling out some cash from his pocket, he pressed it into his dad's palm, and the man smiled, pushing the beanie he was wearing down to his nose.

Jughead hated it when people did that. The crown-shaped beanie had come to his life at nine years of age when playing on the street with other kids from the Sunnyside Trailer Park. Sweet Pea had kicked the soccer ball too hard and Jughead had been the one to go after it, into a large mud puddle. The beanie was in it, dirty and broken, but he took it with him and let his mom wash it.

Throughout the years, it had become his symbol of hope and memories. Ever since that day, no one had seen Jughead Jones, the 'prince' of the Southside Serpents without that crown beanie on his head.

There were theories on the Northside about him having a bald scalp, and his own friends made fun of it as well, but Jughead kept his head up high like always, having learned how to cope with tough emotions and moments in other ways than bullying them back.

"Get that dog away from here," FP grumbled, the animal still barking on the place. Jughead simply kept quiet and waited until his father was out of the sight, going 'grocery shopping' which he already knew meant buying alcohol, bacon, and chips. When he was gone, the dog stopped making the noise and ran over to Jughead, sitting down next to him while licking his cheek.

"Hey, boy," Jughead said, petting the fur with his free hand. "How have you been today? Did Toni feed you when she got home from school?"

"Do not worry about that, Jones." Jughead looked up and smiled a bit at the girl approaching him. "Hey Hotdog." She petted his fur and pushed the beanie on Jughead's head over his eyes as a greeting, making the guy groan. "Got more cigarettes?"

"You can finish this," he mumbled and handed the half-burnt one to her.

"Ooh, thanks." She took a long drag from it, sitting down beside her best friend. "Joaquin called," she said.

Jughead hummed. "Isn't he busy teaching a Northsider how to take orders?"

Toni smirked, the two sharing an amused look, already knowing they were going to tease the new girl working at the diner. They didn't know who she was or if they had met her before, because none of them had gotten her name when Joaquin told them, but the two knew how to have fun with new people who probably hated them.

"Well, apparently, she can bake. It can be false, but she's making trays full of cakes or some shit, and they'll give them away for testing and feedback on her skills..."

The two were surrounded by a pool of smoke when Jughead's eyes lit up. "Free food?"

Toni hummed and nodded. "Don't get too excited, Jones, the Northsider might not even know how to bake."

"Free food is free food. Good or not," Jughead said and stood up, only stepping inside his trailer to grab his motorcycle keys and the leather jacket. Pulling it on, they walked up to the bike, and Toni climbed on first before Jughead took a seat in the front, letting the girl wrap her arms around him, both of them ignoring the helmet attached to the back of the motorcycle.




Arriving at Pop's together, many Northside families watched them, but Jughead wondered they weren't the rich ones who probably were celebrating their kids' last school day of the year in fancier restaurants. So, making sure his bike was parked correctly (he did not need more tickets), the two walked inside.

"Hey Pop. Joaquin," Jughead greeted, eyes fixed on the tray of cupcakes his best guy friend was holding.

"You've outdone yourself." He briefly noticed the two high schoolers on the stools and the girl behind the counter, simply digging into the cupcake he was holding when the Northsiders laughed at something.

Jughead couldn't help but let out a groan even before he had swallowed. When he did though, he took another bite, "So good," he mumbled and grabbed a second cupcake.

Only after tossing the first liner on the counter and taking a bite out of the second one, he met the girl's eyes. The emerald pools were settled on his greyish-green ones, curiously looking at the way he ate. Jughead gulped his bite down, staring plainly at her face for a moment before stuffing the other half of the cupcake into his mouth and giving her a wink, lips curling upwards.

The blonde girl, whose nametag referred to her as Betty, twitched her lips a bit too before looking at the ground, cheeks growing pinker by a second. Toni and Jughead shared a look when he finally sat down on a stool, smirking at one another.

They were going to have some fun with her.

"Here you go, V," the blonde spoke, serving a piece of one of the pies to the raven-haired girl sitting next to him. But not before powdering some sugar on it. "Hope it's okay," she added, making a face at herself.

Jughead's eyes jumped between the two girls who seemed to be friends. "Don't worry, B, if that's as delicious as the one you made on Valentine's day, I'm gonna love it."

Lesbians? Or best friends who moped on Valentine's day together? Jughead wasn't sure.

Betty chuckled at that. "It was the worst one I've ever made."

"It was," the ginger girl behind them stated. Jughead frowned looking at Cheryl Blossom. He might have not known who the two girls were at first, but everyone in Riverdale knew Cheryl Blossom and her family. He had always gotten a bitchy attitude from her, though. She seemed to think she was better than everyone.

And he had never seen that girl eating anything besides a salad.

"Well that's definitely not a compliment," the boy who was sitting next to the alleged V mumbled while rolling his eyes.

"Shut up, Keller."

Keller. Sheriff Keller. His son? Wow, he had lots of important Northsiders there... Cheryl Blossom, Keller, and the girl next to him just had to be a Lodge, judging from her pearls and high heels. But, how did the blonde baker with a ponytail fit into their group? He was curious to find out.

"Betty, right?" he questioned, getting all of their attention. The girl simply nodded, her green eyes meeting his carefully. It wasn't a judging look, and he was taken aback from the way her eyes darkened when meeting his. "You made these?"

"Yep," she said, popping the last p with a small smile on her lips.

He nodded. "And they're free?"

"I guess..." She glimpsed at Pop for a moment who nodded with a proud smile.

"How did she do? Is it good?"

"Amazing," Jughead nodded eagerly and Toni hummed while doing the same. "Just keep them coming as long as they're free I guess."

Betty frowned a bit, still smiling, and Jughead reached for another cupcake—coconut with blueberries. "What's your name?"

The blonde arched her eyebrows. "Betty..." she said. Now she was judging. She looked at him like he had just escaped from a mental facility.

"Full name?"

She swallowed, keeping eye contact, while slowly saying, "Cooper."

Jughead froze for a moment, staring her right into the eye, then gulped the bite down and tilted his head to see Toni. The girl was already smirking, planning to make that blonde's life hell if she ever happened to be their waitress. When the two looked at Joaquin though, he gave his head a shake, warning them from something.

Jughead wasn't quite sure what it was yet, but when he fixed his eyes back at the girl behind the counter, she was staring down at her fisted hands on the wooden fabric.

At least now he knew how she fit in with the gang. Her parents were the worst Northsiders besides the Blossoms. The Coopers were a nightmare.

But looking back at Betty, Jughead looked at the way her knuckles turned white while fisting her hands and then suddenly stopped, the girl turning around and while mumbling something about cleaning up to Pop, disappearing back into the kitchen.

Something wasn't right with her. And Jughead Jones made it his mission to find out what it was.

☆☆☆

You, people, are crazy. Yes, I'm very thankful for all these votes, and yes, I love every single one of you for it, but... I can't post every day. I don't have that many chapters written out, and I swear I'll try to hurry up, but until then... 120 votes for the next chapter.

Stay safe, guys! xx

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

81.5K 4.9K 94
meredith and derek have been Best friends since they were little. what happens when a just 22 years old, he has to take over the roll his dad used to...
424K 8.5K 56
One day Betty gets home and sees two men wearing Serpent jackets. Her mom informs her that she will be force to marry Jughead for her safety. Will th...
317K 26.7K 39
What happens when the person who broke your heart years back, came back out of the blues. And then you are determined to take revenge from that guy...
9.7K 324 80
Hey guys. Just a quick recap {Erin's cancer came back and it's worse than ever. Dylan and Logan got engaged ; Dyl also started med school again. Lexi...