Rewind (A Hamilton AU/ Hamgel...

By uhohspaghettiHOE

13K 373 316

Angelica Schuyler has been having a odd dreams of her sister marrying an unnamed man and him breaking her hea... More

Author's Note
Chapter I
Chapter II
Chapter III
Chapter IV
Chapter V
Chapter VI
Chapter VII
Chapter VIII
Chapter VIX
Chapter X
Chapter XI
Chapter XII
Chapter XIII
Chapter XIV
Chapter XV
Chapter XVI
Chapter XVII
Chapter XIX
Chapter XX
Chapter XXI
Chapter XXII
Chapter XXIII
Chapter XXIV
Chapter XXV
Chapter XXVI
Chapter XXVII
Epilogue

Chapter XVIII

424 16 13
By uhohspaghettiHOE

Angelica danced around her room as she held the letters from Alexander. She was smiling and jumping around like she was a teenager again

Peggy leaned against the doorframe and watched her sister with a smile on her face, it made her happy to see Angelica so excited, she hadn't been this way for years

But at what cost?

"Angelica, I'm pleased that you went through with the plan, but maybe you should speak with Eliza. I don't want the both of you to hate each other. She was very upset at the ball." Peggy advised

"You're right, even though I was angry, I shouldn't have snapped at her like that. I just felt as if she was undermining all of the sacrifices I've made." Angelica replied, ashamed

Angelica got up and strut down the corridors of the Schuyler Mansion to Eliza's room

She walked in to find her reading letters addressed to her from

A. Hamilton

She knocked the door slowly

"Eliza, May I come in? I wish to speak with you." Angelica announced herself

Eliza was laying on her bed face down, her face buried in a pillow "What's the use? You made your feelings of me clear at the Winter's Ball." Eliza said sadly

Angelica sat on her sister's bed and stroked Eliza's hair in an attempt to comfort her

"Eliza...you're my sister and I love you more than anything in this life. I would never try to intentionally do anything that could hurt you. I said what I said because I was angry. Not at you, but at the world. I felt as if it was keeping me from being happy and only forcing me to make sacrifices I didn't want to make. I'm so sorry, 'Liza. We've lost so many siblings... I couldn't bare to lose you due to a lapse in my judgement. Please forgive me?" Angelica spoke sincerely

Elizabeth Schuyler, so trusting, so kind

So forgiving

Eliza looked up and saw the sincerity in her sister's eyes and enveloped her in a hug that spoke words

Love

Patience

Forgiveness

"Angelica, I forgive you. However, I must also apologize. I was very selfish that night and I shouldn't have yelled at you. You're right, maybe this crush on Alexander is temporary. It was an 'in the moment' sort of thing. However there is something I must know. Why is it that whenever I think of that speaker in the square, my heart begins to flutter?"

Angelica gasped "Oh lord, please no. Is it who think it is?"

"You're not talking about Samuel Seabury, are you? He's so stuffy, so formal, so—" Angelica ranted about everything unsavory about Samuel

"That one! He was quite charming, I must say. Devilishly handsome as well..." Eliza looked up into the sky with dreamy eyes

"Eliza...of all people, you chose Samuel Seabury? His opinions are disgraceful to our country and he is siding with Britain? How would Alexander and his fellow soldiers feel knowing they sacrificed so much and won this war to have someone bash them. It's disgusting." Angelica sighed bitterly

"Angie, we haven't won the war...the war isn't even over. What do you speak of?" Eliza said with confusion

Peggy told me don't mention anything from the present!

"Oh nothing, wishful thinking, that's all..." Angelica covered

"Oh alright, well I love him. I wish to meet him and marry him. I pray father will like him." Eliza said

"Eliza, he's a loyalist, father is a patriot. He's fighting for the other side! Do you truly think he will approve of this, do you?"

"We'll elope!" Eliza suggested

"You say it like it's easy, 'Liza..." she said

"It is, I will meet with him every Sunday, he'll fall in love with me, we'll run away and get married, we'll have 12 beautiful children, and we'll grow old together, and—" Eliza started to ramble

"Eliza. Let's meet him first. Alright?"

"Alright...oh, there's also a surprise for you, Angie! I forgot to mention." she suddenly realized

"Oh?" Angelica asked

"Hello, mon chèri." A male voice joined in

Alexander Hamilton stood leant up against Eliza's door frame

"Alexander? Alexander! What are you doing here, mon chère?"

Angelica ran into Alexander's arms and he spun her around the room, the same way he did a few chapters ago

"General Washington let me go home early to visit you all." Alexander explained

Eliza looked away, a pang of sadness hitting her suddenly

"Oh, and Eliza?" Alexander asked

Eliza turns around, hopeful, "Yes, Alexander?"

"May I speak with you please? Alone?"

"Of course, I'll be back, Angelica." Eliza said. She seemed composed on the outside, but on the inside, a whirl wind of emotions took up her thoughts. She loved Samuel, but she still held small feelings for Alexander

He took her into a secluded hall of the Schuyler mansion

"Eliza, I shall get straight to the point. I want to marry Angelica. I'm in love with her, but I'm aware of your feelings for me."

Eliza gasped

"Y-You know? You know everything?" Eliza panicked

"Yes. I don't want us to never see each other again, so I want to tell you that I wish to remain friends. Send letters back and forth, talk, have fun. As friends. I don't wish to lose you over something that won't matter in a few years." Alexander held Eliza's hands

"Something that won't matter?" Eliza thought

"You're right, I suppose. But how did you know?" Eliza asked him

Alexander had a look of panic on his face

"I had a feeling." He said

"Oh. Well, I suggest you ask father. If you get rejected, please don't take it personally, father has always been a bit more of a serious man." She warned him

"Alright, thank you Eliza. For everything. You truly are an incredible woman." Alexander told her in admiration

"Thank you, may you always be satisfied."
-
-
-
-
Alexander and Eliza has returned and found Angelica sitting on the bed reading Common Sense by Thomas Paine.

"Angelica, walk with me will you love?" Alexander outstretched his hand to her

"Absolutely." Angelica agreed

The two walked all the way down to the garden. It was still winter, so a blanket of snow covered the bushes and trees. The water was frozen in the fountain and the winter flowers were covered in snowflakes.

"It's beautiful, isn't it?" Angelica asked rhetorically

"Yes, you are indeed." Alexander said

She looked at him and then looked away with a blush on her face

Alexander grabbed her chin with his hand and locked his eyes with hers.

"Angelica, I have not known you long. But I know you are the one for me. You are stunningly beautiful, match my intelligence, and believe in the same things I do. I cannot imagine a world where you do not live, for it is too torturous. My dearest Angelica, I am in love with you." Alexander held her hand and bent down one knee. He pulled out a pastel pink, velvet box and opened. A gold, sizable ring sat there, shining in the winter's light

Angelica held a gasp. She was so happy, she was getting what she wanted at last.

"Which is why I ask you, Angelica Schuyler, to become Angelica Hamilton. Or Angelica Schuyler-Hamilton. Whichever you prefer. I don't know which one you—"

Alexander is cut off by Angelica jumping into his arms on the floor

"Oh shut it you. I will marry you." Angelica had tears if joy in her eyes

"Oh Angelica, thank God..." Alexander held her, even though he was cold from the snow melting into his jacket

Eliza watched from a window, picturing her and Samuel Seabury. But she still felt hurt at the scene

She didn't know why it affected her so much, it just did

The reason?

In another life, it was the same spot Alexander proposed to her, with a pastel blue box and Angelica had Eliza's place by the window
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Author's note: woooooow. I finally updated after 4 days. At least it isn't 4 years. Oh well, we've got a few more chapters left and then this story will come to a close. I'm gonna miss it man. But it's good, that's not for a long ass time. Hope you enjoyed this chapter!

Love,

Kennedy Brown❤️

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

40.4K 610 16
WARNING, LANGUAGE, SMUT, ANGST(Probably) Alexander Hamilton wants nothing to do with love, especially after all the heartbreak he's been through. Aft...
9.9K 491 52
Elizabeth Schuyler is not helpless. She may be in love, but, she can hold her own. Her life may throw her through twist and turns that might hurt lik...
14.7K 415 18
Elizabeth Schuyler is happily married to her husband Alexander. She notices changes in his behavior. So, she and her sister go undercover to discover...
1.1K 4 13
Everything plays out as it normally would, but there is a small difference that leads to a big change and it is Angelica and Elizabeth's happy ending...