Should've Been Mine (Laurens...

By HazelTkach

38.3K 1.2K 733

John Laurens and Angelica Schuyler both meet at their current unrequited love's (Alexander Hamilton) wedding... More

Supposed To Be Satisfied
Scary Lady and Carriages
A Carriage Ride
Blushing Pink
Introducing Our Special Friends
Laf Rambles On and Peggy's Kinda Cute
RAISE A GLASS TO ELIZA!
She Says She Isn't Satisfied
The Small Ways
Home Again
Chasing Rumours
Oh Angie
A Slip Of The Tongue
new cover!
Let's Have Another Round
A Little Nothing
What Have I Done?
Burn
School-Kid Crush
OMG Peggy Answer Me
One Way Or Another
Peggy Say What?
WHAT DID I MISS? (WRITER UPDATE)
Hurried!
Ground Rules
Anybody Have A Map?
Into My Arms
I Love Him
This Is Enough
I am Satisfied
Say No
An Endless Ride
Home Sweet... NO
War
Raising A Glass To The Stars
Epilouge
new cover!
Reader Appreciation Post

If I Could

754 33 7
By HazelTkach

(John Laurens POV)

My cheeks heat up as I jog home, twisting through the city streets. My thoughts chase after me, wondering what I did that Alex pulled the 'you love me' card. 

I know I'm always complaining that I wish he knew I liked him, but now that he knows, it's terrifying. He can tug on my heartstrings all he wants, and I still can't mess with his.

Alexander's a happy jerk, with a nice wife and a skill with the pen. No matter how much I hate him, I still love him, but that's an unsolvable problem.

At least, at least maybe I have a chance with Angelica. Apparently, she has a crush on me and... If I'm being honest with myself, I like her. Angelica's better then Alex, with her intense kindness she won't admit and her insane amount of intelligence that sparkles in her eyes like flame. She's shockingly beautiful, with her pink dress and her dark hair, sometimes tied in a bun.

And, better then Alexander for sure, she likes me back. And I'm better then Hamilton, I'm not going to sit back and laugh as she struggles with liking me-- I'm going to give this a shot. 

Now I just have to find her... When I finally get to the tavern I'm staying at, I resist the urge to collapse. Instead, I hail a carriage and head to Schuyler mansion, where Peggy told me to meet her if I wanted to talk.

As the horseman travels under the starlight to take me to the mansion, I rather miss the speed of Angelica and I's flight. Hopefully, I'll go with her again soon.

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

14.7K 415 18
Elizabeth Schuyler is happily married to her husband Alexander. She notices changes in his behavior. So, she and her sister go undercover to discover...
2.1K 164 35
Angelica Schuyler is determined not to fall in love. Especially not with him. The player of Yorktown High. She's a Schuyler sister and Schuyler siste...
70.9K 2.8K 12
Everyone loves John Laurens, they love what they see. They love the freckles and the silky curls. They love the eyes and the lips. They love the subt...
1.6K 87 21
John Laurens and his friends go to Columbia University and meet Alex Hamilton, little did they know their lives would be intertwined forever... (Very...