Brad: a bunch of flowers and a letter reading "dinner today! I'll pick you up at seven and no backing out"
Tristan: a heart charm bracelet, engraved saying "tris+y/n 02~11~13" (that's the date you first met ok I thought it was cute bcos boys don't normally remember this stuff"
Connor: a hugeee teddy bear at your door
James: a pandora charm to add to your bracelet but you've been wanting it for ages and he knew you couldn't afford it.