James: he gives you a new broomstick, because yours broke while playing a quidditch match.
Sirius: he gives you a pair of leather gloves and a new pair of heels.
Remus: he gives you a necklace with a wolf on it, because it's his patronus.
Lucius: he gives you a new black dress.
Severus: he gives you his favourite book, because you'll love it to.