What If dio killed the crusaders? And then you found out about it in the future?
Ever since dio found out about Jonathan's descendants he was determined to kill them... And that what he was going to do now.
He tucked you in your bed and let you sleep after he said goodnight, after that he left to face the crusaders.
The fight began and as we all know first to die was avdol and iggy by vanilla ice.
Later on kakyoin died because of Dio, and after a while Joseph died for good. Polnareff followed behind after dio send him flying through some buildings and the impact killed him immediately.
Now Jotaro was the only one standing, he was the one left to save his mother..... But he too died after dio threw the road roller at him, dio laughed in victory after he confirmed that his enemies died.
That same night the crusaders died, Holly sadly passed as well, suzie was there and cried over her daughter's dead body.... In the city of morioh another joestar died, Josuke, we all know he suffered the same fate as Holly, his mother was heartbroken.
Jonathan felt one by one his descendants and he was sobbing uncontrollably.
Dio came back while feeling victorious, Jonathan saw him and he was very angry, he got up to him and punched him multiple times before leaving to see his descendants dead bodies.
He was horrified when he saw Joseph and Jotaro.
"no one deserved this... No one, Jotaro was just a teenager, he didn't deserve to die... And Joseph was a father and husband, he didn't deserve to die as well, no one deserved this kind of death!" Jonathan said as he sobbed even more.
While sleeping you had felt that horrible things were happening, when you woke up you felt Jonathan's pain... Maybe through the connection you both had.
"are you alright (y/n)?" dio asked you, you looked at him
"I felt like something bad happened... something very bad happened... Like many people died tonight, people that didn't deserve to die" you said
"I'm sure it was nothing" he said
"where did your long hair go?" you asked
"oh, I decided to return to my old haircut, short and simple" dio said (just imagine that he doesn't have the ugly ass short hair he had in Pt3, imagine the beautiful short hair he had in pt1) and you nodded.
Jonathan was very heartbroken when he came back and you could see it.
"are you okay?" you asked him, he looked at you and he realized something, maybe his bloodline isn't over, yes the family he had with Erina, his first love, that family is gone, but then there's you.. Yes you're also related to dio but you're also Jonathan's kid. Jonathan started crying again and he hugged you.
"you're the only one I have left, please promise me that nothing will happen to you" Jonathan said
"I promise that nothing will happen to me, I'll always be fine so I can be by your side" you said with a smile, he hugged you more and continued to cry.
Over the years you noticed that whenever dio entered the room and Jonathan was there, Jonathan would get angry and then sad and then he would disappear.
When you were 10 you moved to Italy, there you met your friend (but didn't know he was your brother) giorno.
"Do you want to have a sleepover?" you asked him and he agreed.
"here's my home address, you can come over at 6pm, I need to get some snacks before you arrive... And I also need to prepare my dad, he won't be happy if I bring a boy over" you said
"lucky you, you have a dad, not a step-dad, I wish I knew my dad, I only have a picture of him" giorno said
"you tell me about him at my home, see you then!" you said and left, when you arrived home you informed dio and then Jonathan, Jonathan took it better than dio, dio was adamant that he won't allow this boy over.
"not fair! He's my only friend!! He's going to be over here whether you like it or not!" you said and then went to your room.
Around an hour later Jonathan returned with the snacks you'll need, he saw dio in the kitchen, they glared at each other until Jonathan called out to you to tell you that he arrived with the snacks.
"sweet!! And giorno will be here soon, you better not destroy this dad!" you told dio and he sighed.
30 minutes later giorno arrived, you opened the door and greeted him, you then introduced him to Jonathan
"where's dad?" you asked Jonathan
"he had somewhere to go, he'll be back late at night" Jonathan said, both you and giorno noticed how bitter he talked about dio.
You and giorno went and played with your Playstation in the living room, right now you were destroying giorno!! He was getting frustrated but he accepted his fate.
After you two played as many games as you could, Jonathan prepared the snacks and something more to eat for you two. You both thanked him and went to your room to play some board games.
"you want to play monopoly? Or something else? I have many board games, me and Jonathan love to play board games, sometimes I play with my dad as well" you said
"monopoly is fine" giorno said and you both agreed on playing monopoly.
Hours passed and at some point Jonathan came over to tell you both that you needed to go to sleep
"after we're done playing with this round" you said
"alright, I'll stay here to watch you both play" Jonathan said
You both were done playing with monopoly and soon got ready to go to bed.
"alright, goodnight you two, tomorrow we'll drop off giorno at his house at around 11am, goodnight" Jonathan said
"goodnight" both you and giorno said as Jonathan turned off the lights and closed the door.
"so your mom is a model?" you asked giorno
"yeah... But she's not the best sadly" he said
"that's bad... I sadly don't have a mom, so I don't know if it's better to not have a mom or to have a mom that is not the best" you said
"it's better to not have a mom, my mom and step-dad deserve each other, he's garbage" he said
"really?" you asked
"yeah, sometimes I wish I could find my dad and live with him" giorno said
"can you show me a picture of him?" you asked him
"yeah, I have one of him, my mom gave it to me" he said and he took out a picture from his bag and showed it to you
"no way, we need to tell Jonathan!!" you said as you got up and you both run to find Jonathan
"what happened? Are you both okay?" Jonathan asked
"you won't believe it! Dad is also giorno's biological dad!!! Giorno is my brother!!" you said said, both of them were shocked
"giorno, do you have a star-shaped birthmark?" Jonathan asked and giorno showed the birthmark, Jonathan was still shocked but soon smiled
"I'm sure if we tell dio that he'll be happy to hear it" Jonathan said, speak of the devil, right then dio arrived
"why are they both awake this late at night?" dio asked
"dad! Giorno is not only my friend! He's also my brother!! He's your child" you said, dio was shocked to say the least, but after he got some proof he believed it.
"I see.... I'll speak tomorrow with your mother, for now you go to sleep, both of you" dio said and you both left to sleep.
The next day you and Dio went to leave giorno at his house, when his mom opened the door she was shocked to see dio (forgot to mention that you unfortunately made dio to be able to go out in the sun, but you can control it)
"what are you doing here?" she asked
"yesterday I found out that giorno is my son" dio said
"yes, he's your son" she said
"honey, is that useless thing home?" giorno's step-dad said
"did he call my son useless?" dio asked and then got in the house, let's just say that someone was beaten and giorno was brought home, his mother didn't mind not having him there.
Some years passed and giorno became the mafia boss.... But now you and giorno found out the truth, how? This is how.
You both were coming home a little earlier than usual, when you opened the door you heard Jonathan and Dio fighting.
"they will never know okay?!? Don't you dare tell them!!" dio said
"one day they'll find out what you did, and I don't promise that they'll be happy about what you did" Jonathan said
"if you don't tell them they'll never know" dio said
"what will we never know?" you asked, both of them were shocked but dio was mortified
"dad, tell us now" giorno said
"if he doesn't tell you then I will" Jonathan said
"don't you dare tell them!!" dio said
"I don't care anymore dio, I'm sick and tired of you!!! I don't care if they hate you after that or not! I'm going to tell them what kind of monster you are!" Jonathan said
"your father is a vampire but that's not the only thing! In 1889 he killed me when I was on my way to my honeymoon with my wife, I've known dio since we were 12! He killed me when we were 21. In 1988 he killed the last of my descendants, he killed my grandson Joseph joestar, he also killed Joseph's grandson, Jotaro kujo, Jotaro was only 17 when he died. And because of your father's stand, jotaro's mother died, your father hated my family, he killed me, my father, my grandson and the rest of my bloodline! And on top of that right after I died he stole my body, the body he has now was once mine!" Jonathan said, both you and giorno were speechless
"why? Who in their right fucking mind would kill a teenager?!? And for what fucking reason?!? WHY DID YOU HATE HIS FAMILY SO FUCKING MUCH?!? DID THEY DO ANYTHING TO YOU?!? did you do anything to him?" you asked Jonathan
"no, my father treated him like he treated me, he treated him like his own son, but dio didn't want this, dio wanted money, he wanted power, he wanted everything!! So he killed my father but after he became a vampire he wanted to take over the world!!! THAT'S THE TRUTH OF YOUR FATHER!!" Jonathan said
"wow, and here I thought you were nice, all my life I lived in a lie, you are a monster, you killed a whole bloodline for no reason at all, no reason! You did all of that because you were A TWISTED BASTARD!!! YOU WANTED PEOPLE TO SUFFER!!!" you yelled, dio was shocked, he never heard you talk to him like that.
"I had my reason!" dio yelled
"okay, what was your reason?" you asked
"they looked down on me!" dio said
"that's really your excuse? You're pathetic as hell!" you said as you grabbed your coat
"are you really going to leave?" dio asked
"you expect me to stay? You expect me to stay with a monster like you?!?!? YOU KILLED THEM FOR NO FUCKING REASON YOU DISGUSTING MONSTER!!! YOU'RE NOT MY FATHER ANYMORE!!! I REFUSE TO HAVE A FATHER LIKE YOU!! I'D RATHER BE DEAD THAN BE RELATED TO YOU ANYMORE!!!" you yelled in frustration and left, throughout all of these giorno was shocked and disgusted..... You soon came back
"if I leave I'm Taking my stuff with me" you said and you went upstairs to take your stuff.
"you see what you did?!? It's all your fault she hates me!!" dio yelled.
"you're too easy to put the blame on everyone but yourself!!! You selfish bastard!" giorno finally talked
"your actions have consequences and non of them are Jonathan's fault, we're glad Jonathan told us the truth" giorno said and went upstairs to get his stuff as well.
After a while you both came back and glared at dio
"I'm also getting back the ability I gave you, the ability to enjoy the sunlight.... You filthy monster, now if you want to die you can just go out during the day.... I also wouldn't mind killing you on my own, you know, to avenge all these deaths of innocent people " you said and you left and giorno with Jonathan followed behind.
That left dio destroyed, his own kids hate him.... And of course it's justified.
The weeks passed, dio had some hope that you'll both return but nothing happened.
Meanwhile you and giorno found suzie q and went to tell her the truth.
"what did you both want to talk about?" suzie asked, both you and giorno saw that she was still mourning
"we know the truth of what happened to your family... Your husband, daughter and grandson, but we're still not sure if you'll believe us" you said, her eyes teared up
"please tell me what happened to them, please they left so unexpectedly" she practically begged. So you explained everything, you told her why Holly died and why Joseph and Jotaro were killed.
"we're so sorry for what happened to them" giorno said as he fell on his knees
"we're very ashamed that we're related to a monster like him, please forgive us" you said as you fell on your knees as well, you both stayed like that as you heard her cry.
"it's not your fault... It's not your fault that you father was a monster, at least after so many years I got closure as to what and why it happened" suzie said as she gently brought you both up to your feet.
"how old are you both?" she asked
"15" you said
"you both are so young... When all of this happened you two were only 4, so young and innocent, you didn't know what happened back then... But how did you find out the truth?" suzie asked
"you might not believe this.. But since a young age I was able to contact with your husband's grandfather, Jonathan joestar... You could say since dio stole his body he's somewhat of our father as well. We learned the truth thanks to him, this would explain why that day and the following days he was devastated, he was crying day and night" you said
"I believe you, he must of gone through a lot as well, because of that guy named dio" suzie said and you both nodded
"come on both of you, let's go somewhere" suzie said and you all left.
After 30 minutes you ended up at the cemetery, you walked through it and then stopped in front of some Graves.
"this is where we buried them" she said, you read the names on the Graves.
"who's that with the name sadao?" you asked
"that's jotaro's father and Holly's husband, while everything was happening he was on a world tour, he was a musician, when he returned he found out what happened, he was devastated and he didn't want to live anymore so he ended his life, even before everything happened he had requested to be buried wherever his wife was buried" suzie said
A few days later you came back to their Graves and decided to test your stand, you called their spirits and it worked.
"where are we?" holly asked, then everyone looked at you, you couldn't hold it anymore and fell on your knees and held your hands together
"I'm sorry for what happened to you, I'm so sorry" you kept apologizing again and again while crying, they were all confused
"hey, why are we transparent?" Jotaro asked
"I remember now... I came back home and Ms. Suzie told me that you were all dead" sadao said
"hey now honey, why are you crying?" holly asked as she walked closer to you
"I'm sorry... Because of that monster you all died" you said as you held your head down, you wouldn't dare to look at them in the eyes.
"you mean dio" Joseph asked and you nodded
"then why are you apologizing?" holly asked
"because I'm ashamed to say that I'm related to him, I wish I wasn't" you said, they were shocked
"it's not your fault, you didn't do anything so stand up straight and wipe those tears, if dio was an asshole and a psychopath then that's on him" Joseph said, Holly helped you on your feet and you were able to wipe your tears
"tell me how do you want me to avenge you, you all got killed for no reason, he was a bitter son of a bitch that had no life, he was jealous of everything.... Tell me, do you want me to kill him, anything to avenge you all" you said as you finally looked at them
"there's no reason for that, losing you already makes him suffer, I'm sure of it" Joseph said and you nodded
"by the way.... Me and my brother, unfortunately my brother is related to that monster as well, we talked with your wife, she told us she was glad we talked to her and told her what happened, she got some closure about what happened, and now she's less sad of what happened" you told Joseph
"suzie.... She's all alone now" Joseph said
"she had one request from me and my brother" you said
"and what was it?" Jotaro asked
"she requested us to stay by her side until she died, she already started acting like a grandmother to us, which I still feel very guilty about" you said
"no need to feel guilty, if she acts like that then it means she likes you, you have nothing to feel guilty about" Joseph
"let's make a few things clear, if dio told you to kill him, or requested for a fight, would you do it?" Jotaro asked
"yes, I don't care anymore, he's not my father, I refuse to have a monster for a Father" you said
"then that must be your brother fight dio" Jotaro said, you looked behind and saw giorno fighting dio, you immediately went to help giorno.
"leave my brother alone!!!" you yelled as you punched him away with your stand
"what do you want from us again!?!?" you yellled
"you both said that you could kill me right? Let's test the theory! Let's see if you can kill me, if you can't then I'll kill you both and then the last of the joestar bloodline will be dead!!" dio yelled
"let's do it (y/n)" giorno said and you nodded
"how crazy is he to fight his kids?" holly asked
"he's either doing it genuinely or he just wants to die because he can't stand being away from them" Joseph said
"what is going on here?" they heard avdol speak, they turned around and saw the rest of the crusaders
"so dio is still alive? Who is he fighting?" kakyoin asked
"his kids, he wants the last of the joestar bloodline to be dead... So he's going to kill his kids" Joseph said
"how twisted of him" Polnareff said
The fight was lasting a long time and you and giorno didn't seem well, you both were badly injured and Dio was fine
"(y/n).... We both don't want to do it, I know you don't want to kill him because you don't like killing people... But we have to do it, at this kind of rate we'll die" giorno said and you nodded
"YOU DARE TO TRY AND KILL MY KIDS?!?" you both heard Jonathan yell
The others were shocked when they saw Jonathan
"and what are you going to do about it? They said they were going to kill me, but if they don't I'll do it instead!!" dio yelled and went to attack you both but Jonathan stepped in front of you both.
"are you this twisted?!?" Jonathan yelled
"yes! I am this twisted!! Those two are the last of the joestars and if I want to achieve world dominance, all joestars need to be dead, even if those two are my kids" dio said
"maybe he's gone crazy" Polnareff
The fight began again and Jonathan helped as well, sunrise was near and Dio wanted to get away but you hit him and paralyzed him, he fell on the ground and didn't get up.
"5 minutes until sunrise" giorno said
"good" you said and looked at dio
"maybe you're not so different from your father, after you die you may meet him again" you said, this angered dio
"I did everything for you!!! I raised you, I was a good parent to you!! So why throw me away like I'm nothing!?!?" dio yelled
"all of these stopped mattering when we found out what kind of person you are, you thought that because you were acting as a good dad that we'll forgive all the murdering you did, all those innocent people you killed back in 1888? Or the whole bloodline you killed because apparently they looked down on you?!? You had the chance back then to have a normal life, a life with people that care about you, but you decided to act selfish and entitled, you decided to become a rotten piece of shit!" you said and you spit next to him on the ground, he then started laughing
"we're no different (y/n), you're just like me" dio said
"take that back you piece of shit!!! I'm not like you! I'm not a murderer or a twisted fuck!" you said, he just laughed until he turned into ashes after the sun hit him.
"don't worry... You're not like him, you're better than him, he was not human" Jonathan said and you nodded
At last, dio died from the hands of his own kids, that was his plan all along, he never meant to hurt you both but if things turned out like that, then he thought it would be better if he was dead, it would save some heartache.
Alternative Ending:
While the others watched, they couldn't do anything really, you and giorno fought for your lives.
At one point you both had a disadvantage and that was guaranteed victory for dio. He stopped time and looked at you both, he then killed you both one by one, before he resumed time he saw Jonathan in the distance... He then resumed time.
Both you and giorno fell down and coughed blood, the others were horrified, but Jonathan was the most, he run up to you both and held you in his arms while you both slowly died and he slowly faded away.
"no, no, no!! WHY WOULD YOU DO IT YOU SICK BASTARD!?!?!?!?" Jonathan yelled and cried.
"they said they could kill me, I wanted to see if they could.... The couldn't" dio said coldly.
The others run up to you both and tried to do something but nothing could be done.
"no, please both of you don't die, please!!!" Jonathan cried more, you two could just hold his hand
"HOW COULD YOU KILL YOUR KIDS!!!! YOUR OWN FLESH AND BLOOD?!?!? HOW COULD YOU!?!?" Jonathan yelled in rage, he was hurt, he lost yet another descendant of his.
When both you and giorno finally died everyone disappeared, all the ghosts and Jonathan, the only thing that was left were your lifeless bodies.
Dio turned around and kneeled next you both, he knew what he was doing but he was too prideful to give up, he held your hands, maybe he shed a tear but he then left because the sun would be up soon.
Who found your dead bodies? Poor suzie did, she went to visit the other's graves and she saw you both dead there.... She also died there from a broken heart... So sad.