Wampus - (Genuinely surprised) "....thanks but why?" Then they go home and treasure it.
Pukwudgie - "aHh thank you so much I love it!!!!!!!!!!!!!" They use it even if they dont particularly like it and they make you something five minutes later to feel like they aren't selfish.
Horned Serpent - They're probably flustered depending on who gave it to them, but they try to keep their cool. "Oh thanks." And you may think they don't like it, but they use it more than you expected them to and they secretly love it.
Thunder Bird - "Oh you shouldn't have" Yes you should have. They will either love it or hate it, there is no in between, but they will make sure they repay you....eventually.
YOU ARE READING
Ilvermorny Houses As...
RandomI see stuff everywhere about Hogwarts Houses and things like that, and I think that Ilvermorny is so underrated, so go take your test and get ready to be analyzed in this Harry Potter horoscope thing. Cover by @WhenTheFireComes , check out her graph...