5SOS Preferences

Pref 4: He Is Dating Your Sister And You Like Him (Pt. 2)

Michael:

Unluckily for you, a knock on the door knocks you out of your trance.

"(Y/N). Let me in." You hear the deep all too familar voice that kills your heart everytime he speaks.

"Go away." You say, but he ignores you, opening the door and showing off a key.

"If you want me to stay out, next time take the key from above the door."

You mentally yell at yourself.

"How'd you know it was there?"

"I've watched you open that door when I came over."

"Oh."

"Why did you freak out at dinner?" He asks, sincerely.

"If I tell you, you and my sister will hate me."

"I highly doubt it. Please just tell me."

You take a deep breath and shake your head no.

"Tell me."

"I like you."

"I like you too."

"More than a friend."

"Oh." He says, shocked and you cry into your hands until he welcomes you into his arms, and you then cry on his shoulder.

"I am ruining your pretty white shirt."

"It was going to get ruined anyways."

"There is mascara on it, I doubt you want it that way."

"At least it will have a piece of you on it."

"Wouldnt you prefer my sister?" You ask, and he laughs and shakes his head no.

"You are the one I like."

"Then why are you with her?"

"To get closer to you..." He admits, shyly.

I smile, and try to dry my tears, when I hear footsteps stomping.

"Dad! Mom! Come up here!" Your sister screams, and you know that you and Michael had been caught.

"What is going on up here?"

"Michael just told (Y/N) that he was using me to get closer to her!"

"Umm... Sweetie..." Your mom starts and allows your dad to finish, "He told us."

Your sister storms off to your room, and you kiss Michael, taking him and yourself by surprise.

Calum:

"Let me in sis."

"No. You told him!"

"I didnt mean anything by it!"

"Now he is going to think I am obsessed with him and not feel comfortable dating you and it will be all my fault and I cant live with myself if that happens!"

"You wont have to! Calum isnt like that. He is sweet and kind."

"And perfect. And just so darn beautiful. He lights up my whole world with just a simple 'hi'." You say, not realizing it until after you say it.

"Sorry. Got caught up in the moment." You say and decide to open the door to see them both standing there shocked.

"You guys can go on your date now. I'll be fine."

"I love you (Y/N)." Calum says and kisses you.

He ends the kiss and you see your sister standing there in shock.