It's Not Your Fault- Armin x Reader

2 Days

"Well I realized one of us may not make it back after the expedition so this could be my only chance."

"One of us?"

"Uhh..."

"(y/n), how many times do we have to tell you that you're not going. I don't want to lose you too, you're not well. You physically can't handle it."

"Corporal I can! I need to-"

"No. What you need is to get your head examined. Seriously, there's something wrong in there."

"Pleeease!" you pleaded, giving him your puppy eyes.

"I told you multiple times and my answer won't change. One more time and I'm tying you down to a post in the basement."

You turned your head down and mumbled something under your breath.

"Mind sharing what you just said?"

"I'm not like her! I'm not her! You can't expect me to just act all obedient to you just for that reason. Yes, you're my superior, but only in the ranking sense. You're not my father, you're not my guardian, and you're most certainly not my brother!"

"Is that so? Fine. Your punishment is to stay away from Armin Arlert." he smirked.

"Did you not just hear me? You can't restrict me from seeing my comrades over a petty reason like being over protective."

"Eh? Try me. I'm still your superior in the ranks. Also, no training sessions for the next six weeks and no expeditions for the next six months."

"What?! All of this because I told you I'm not like my sister!? I'm 99 percent confident that you fucked her at some point, so you're being very hypocritical here."

"And you lied to me, and fucked Armin. You are underaged, its different. And yeah, maybe I did fuck your sister."

"Hmm, it would be such a shame if there was a repeat of a few nights ago after you leave. The only difference this time being there wouldn't be anyone to stop me."

"You shut your damn mouth before I break your other leg-" Levi paused, realizing who he was talking to.

"Is that a threat, Captain Levi?"

"Maybe it was, maybe it wasn't. Keep talking back to me like that and you'll find out."

"I know you wouldn't~" you teased, "You might make Maya mad." you smirked.

"YOU BITCH!" Levi yelled back, "DON'T MAKE HER INTO AN EXCUSE! SHE WAS YOUR SISTER! HAVE SOME RESPECT GODDAMMIT!"

"YOU WERE THE ONE THAT BROUGHT HER UP IN THE FIRST PLACE! YOU WERE COMPARING ME TO HER AND SHIT!" you screamed back, "I CAN TALK ABOUT HER HOWEVER I WANT! LIKE YOU LITERALLY JUST SAID, SHE IS MY SISTER AFTER ALL!"

"WELL AT THE VERY LEAST, MAKE HER MORE REAL! NOT SOMEONE TO USE TO MAKE UP FOR YOUR MISTAKES!"

"You think that I'm just using her as an excuse. Oh, you're so very wrong. I've known for all of my life that I'm nothing but a mistake myself. Those were just the basics I was taught. All my life I was blamed for everything that went wrong, no matter what it was. Out of money? Its because of (y/n). No more alcohol in the house? (y/n) did it. My mother died from an incurable illness when I was merely a toddler, blame me for it. You know nothing about what really happened. Not you, not Maya, not Rita. Only me. She only let you see the pretty parts of my life, much like her's. Hell, I wouldn't be surprised if you didn't know about our family life from her perspective!"

"Well... I never knew about this." Levi said, almost surprised.

"I didn't expect you to, nor did I intend to tell you, but look where we are." you glared at him.