Creepypasta x Reader (A New Beginning- Book 2)

Chapter 6- Updated

"What the hell is going on with you?!" Nathan snapped quietly. "The whole reason I asked you along was because I thought you were the most level headed!"

Hoodie couldn't help but avert his eyes despite Nathan not being able to see.
Nathan didn't know that his sister was alive, if he did he was sure that he would put his middle finger up to the law, he doesn't know... but hoodie does and he needed answers.

He slid off his gloves and then hesitatingly his mask.
'I have to get her back... I can't be so calm this time' he thought to himself.

"Slender give me strength..." hoodie whispered as he took a sharp inhale. "Nathan" he started as he cupped his face.

"What are you doing?" He asked surprised.

"Just look at me" he told him as his eyes fixated on his. "You're going to leave this house okay?" His thumb couldn't help but instinctively stroke his cheek. "You're going to let me finish up here by myself. You will not argue. Just leave" he demanded sternly, yet there was a hint of guilt that couldn't help but force its way through.

Nathan couldn't help but blink slowly at hoodie as his face fell blank. He proceeded to place his hands upon hoodies.
"I'm sorry" hoodie muttered leaning his forehead against Nathans as blood lightly trailed from his nose "but it's for Y/sn"

Nathan, who's face was now empty of any emotion, gently removed hoodies hands and made his way out of the house without any trouble.

Hoodie let out a shaky breath as felt himself grow a little weak.

He wiped the blood from his nose as he made his way back into the bedroom where Rick still sat on the floor, leaning against the wall for support.

"No mask anymore?" He asked cockily

"Not acting so innocent now that the cop is gone?" Hoodie cocked a brow.

"Look man, I don't want any trouble" he sighed "whatever mick did? I had nothing to do with it"

Hoodie pulled out his phone and pulled up a picture.

"Your friend mick robbed a grave and I don't have any doubts that you helped." He then showed the phone to him to which ricks eyes widened "you took this woman didn't you?Where is she? Is she alive?"

"Look man i don't know what you're talking ab-"

"Enough!" He raised his voice as he pulled out his firearm.

"Woah!" Rick panicked raising his hands.

Hoodie crouched down in front of him.
"I'm sick of your lies and excuses. These next words coming out of your mouth best be telling me the truth or there's going to be a bullet straight through your pea-sized brain" he threatened as he pressed the barrel of the gun to his forehead. "I have very good aim"

"O-Okay just let me explain!" He stuttered frantically, crumbling under the threat in front of him, realising there's nothing to protect him.

"I needed cash so I partnered with Mick by robbing graves! Yeah we robbed hers, but we weren't expecting her to be alive! We would've gotten her help but then the cops would know what we were doing! So we kept her here!"

"SO WHERE IS SHE NOW?!" Hoodie snapped cocking the gun. He considered Nathan a good friend and it filled him with guilt having to use his manipulation on him like that just so he could get answers out of this scum. He owed it to Y/n and her family to find her and bring her home safe. He was burdened with guilt and he wouldn't be able to rest until he's done right by bringing her back sage, he had no time for others.

"M-Mick sold her! He didn't want the burden of keeping her here! I-I-I didn't agree with it, I didn't want anything to do with it!"

"WHERE?! WHERE DID HE SELL HER?!" He continued as he pressed the gun harder against his forehead.

Rick couldn't help but gasp from fear, trying not to hyperventilate, fearing his death.

"I don't know! I don't know! I just know they took her in a white van with graffiti on it! I would guess the next town over- I don't know man!" He panicked "all Mick told me was that she was going to a gentlemen's club! Wealthy men! Sick bastards! Much worse than me simply robbing the dead!"

"A gentleman's club?" Hoodie repeated.

"All I know is she belongs to them now! For whatever they bought her for! It's all I know! It's all I was told!" He trembled as hoodie stood up pulling the gun away.

Rick felt himself catch his breath as he was no longer facing death down a barrel.

Hoodie heard a pair of footsteps enter the house and their way up to him.

"Hey what happened?" Liu called out to him as he met him and masky halfway down the corridor out of Ricks sight "We saw Nathan driving back alone"

Before hoodie could think of an answer he fell on all fours as his chest clenched agonisingly tight.

"Woah!" Masky knelt next to him and helped sit down comfortably.

"What's going on with you?" Liu asked concerned. The pain started to fade as he felt himself grow dizzy.

"You didn't" Masky muttered as he checked out his his condition.

Hoodie glanced up at masky with guilt ridden in eyes.

"You did" he sighed annoyed. "...Fucking hypocrite."

"What? What did he do?" Liu asked concerned

"That's why Nathan was driving home alone, hoodie manipulated him with slenders power." Masky informed "although he told me before that he couldn't."

"He wasn't going to stop making things difficult until I did it his way! But there's a lot of stake and we don't have time for his nonsense!"

"He used whatever he had left and it's really taken a toll on his body" Masky turned to liu.  He turned back to hoodie, lifting his chin to look up at him. "Your body can't handle this until slender is back, you'll die from exhaustion, you need to go home"

"I'm fine" hoodie gritted swatting him away.

"Look at you, you can barely catch your breath" Liu sighed with worry.

"You told me not to kill myself searching for
Y/n" Masky began "If you need to go fucking ape shit that is fine, hell I'll do it with you and kill any fucker we come across until we find her, it must be hard just having to keep your shit together all the time. We won't be able to find her at all if you run yourself down into the ground, we're counting on you and Nathan, you guys have got the hang of finding her and when the time comes, we're all going to bring her back."