Judge: ggukminheart
book : bangtan one-shots
author : Sugakookie-nd-tae
cover : (7/10) I think it's very pretty. the black swan cover of bts is extremely eye catchy and I believe that it completely suits the theme of the book.
title : (10/10) suits the book perfectly.
blurb : (8/10) the blurb given in the description made me curious and it also had me wanting to read the book then and there.
pace : (8/10) since each and every short story had a different pace, I'm judging this on an overall basis. I did think that pace was apt (considering the fact that this is a short story) but increasing the word count would've looked more amazing.
writing style : (16/20) undoubtedly amazing but I can not give this a 20 because like I said, I would've liked each and every part to be a little bit longer.
grammar : (20/20) found no errors.
overall enjoyment : (18/20) everything was absolutely amazing. I loved how everything was a mixture of mystery, love and murder but! a few of them were also very predictable.
total : 87 /100
______
book : pretty marriage little vows
author : Seong_Grace
cover : (7/10) the backdrop is extremely beautiful but a better font style would've made it even more pretty.
title : (10/10) absolutely apt for the plot. jk x female lead readers out there would be intrigued.
blurb : (7/10) the blurb gives us a tiny insight into what we're going to read further but the only error I found was the grammatical one. if provided the luxury of time, then I'd recommend the author to use grammarly <3
pace : (7/10) I understand that this is one-shot but despite of that, I found the pace extremely quick. I would suggest trying to include a few more descriptions or backstories to improve the reading experience.
writing style (15/20) : the writing style was in first person pov and the only suggestion I have is to again improve on the grammar because I found a lot of grammatical errors in between.
grammar : (15/20) : once again, I found too many grammatical errors and I'm stating this from the perspective of a reader, too many grammatical errors often pulls the experience of the readers down.
overall enjoyment : (16/20) the story was cute. really. but the grammatical errors prevented me from enjoying it thoroughly and I believe that a few scenes could be delivered more beautifully.
total : 77/100
______
book : oneshots | bts
author : Mrs_Namnam
cover : (9/10) suits the book perfectly but the fonts could be a little more beautifully edited
title : (10/10) perfect
blurb : (7/10) the blurb tells the readers to enjoy reading and believe me when I say this, if one were to choose to spend their time on your book, they would absolutely never regret it one bit.
YOU ARE READING
The Red Petals Awards(Judging)
FanfictionWelcome fellow readers and writers to the Red Petal Awards! Are you feeling your books aren't getting enough recognition? Have you felt your talents are going to waste? Very well, you are just at the right place! These awards have exciting benifits...
