Isaac Lahey has always been the perfect boyfriend. He's always been loving and unselfish. He's always been sweet and kind. Isaac was just that kind of guy when it came to a girl. He knew just how to make a girl's heart melt and how to make her swoon.
It's exactly what happened with Y/N. After a few months of knowing each other and becoming really close, they started dating. The two were perfect for each other in every way. Isaac's charm was matched with Y/N's. They even shared a love for scarves.
Seemingly perfect, right? At least that's what she thought. Lately, Isaac's been... off. He hasn't made much time or effort to see Y/N outside of school and he barely talked to her during school even though they shared the same group of friends and had many classes together.
This all left Y/N completely puzzled. Isaac had been staying with Scott and was closest with him, so Y/N asked him if he what was up with her boyfriend.
"Hey, Scott!" Y/N called out as she caught up to Scott in the school parking lot. He was just taking off his helmet and had helmet hair. "Hey, can I talk to you?" Y/N adjusted the strap of her bag in her shoulder as she got to the boy.
Scott smiled, the light morning sun causing his eyes to squint a little bit. "Morning, Y/N. What's up?"
"You're close with Isaac, right?"
Scott shrugged. "I guess. Is everything okay?" He got off the bike and shoved the keys in his pocket.
"I was hoping you would be able to tell me it was. Something's up with Isaac, do you know if anything's going on?"
"Not that I'm aware of. What do you mean off?" The two started walking towards the doors of the high school, still talking.
Y/N sighed as they walked up the steps. "It feels like he's been avoiding me. I've been trying to talk to him, but he always says he doesn't have time."
Scott's eyebrows furrowed. "That's weird. I don't know what's going on, but I could talk to him if you want me to."
"Really?" Y/N smiled softly. Scott nodded. "Thank you, Scott. That means a lot."
"Anytime." Scott grinned. "Isaac should be home after school today if you want to come and talk to him."
"Yeah, I will. I'll talk to you later?"
"Of course, see you at lunch." Scott nodded and waved, saying his goodbye's as he walked towards his locker.
Y/N decided that she would go over to Scott's house and talk to Isaac after school. Whatever was going on, they could get through it. She would always have his back because she loved him and never wanted to lose him.
After a long day of nervous butterflies and overthinking everything, Y/N got in her car and drove to where Scott said Isaac would be. As she drove, her fingers tapped against the steering wheel in anxiety. Getting closer to her destination made her nervousness grow. For some reason, she had a really bad feeling.
Finally, she pulled into the driveway and saw an unfamiliar car. Y/N couldn't think of a valid explanation, but she got out of her own car and walked up the driveway and to the house. She knocked three times and waited for an answer. It never came. Y/N knocked once more before entering the house.
There was a muffled voice upstairs, that Y/N had placed as Isaac's. Y/N smiled, thinking he was possibly studying and talking to himself, but the uneasiness was still set in her stomach. She made her way up the stairs slowly, the stench of anxiety probably rolling off her in waves.
Y/N came face to face with Isaac's door, and the muffled voice grew louder and she realized it was two voices. It couldn't be.... He wouldn't, would he?
