Red Dead Redemption 2 x Reader Scenarios [hiatus]

When you suddenly take their hand and ballroom dance with them

Arthur:

He got embarrassed as you took his hand and danced around, stumbling to keep up with you, nervously saying this is embarrassing and he has two left feet for this kind of thing. He was more focused on his feet than anything, not wanting to step on your feet accidentally.

John:

He let out a shocked laugh when you suddenly snatched him and began dancing, placing a hand on his hat out of reflex so it doesn't get knocked off before he chuckled and asked what you are doing, his amused tone saying "you cute weirdo". As you shrugged and said you just suddenly wanted to dance, he chuckled and said sure and began moving along with you.

Dutch:

He put on a record on his saxophone and you just suddenly felt in the spirit to dance, so you took his hand, dragging him to a bit of an opener space, telling him to dance with you. He wasn't gonna decline the chance to dance with his lover so he placed his hand on your hip and said of course and both danced around.

Hosea:

He just chuckled and moved along, asking what's the occasion for a sudden ballroom dance. He was very good at this, having done ballroom dances a few times before when he was acting out one of his disguises at a fancy ball. He would dip you even but he doesn't wish to be stuck with back pain afterwards and he's worried his arms might not be as strong as they used to so he might accidentally drop you, so he played it safe and didn't dip you.

Charles:

He felt a bit awkward, unsure where to hold you and not wishing to accidentally step on your feet. As you chuckled and told him to just relax, he frowned a little but tried, saying he's not very good at this. But you shrugged and said you don't mind, are happy he's at least trying, he couldn't help but smile a little at what you said.

Javier:

You can't do this a lot since he's usually the one providing you the music. So when someone else played some music, you were quick to take his hand and dance. He was shocked at the sudden tug and moving, asking you what you are doing. As you told him you can rarely dance with him and just want to dance with him, he smiled and said you should have just said so then danced along with you.

Kieran:

He let out a yelp, stumbling along, nervously asking what you are doing. He stepped on your foot making him quickly lift his foot, apologizing, promising it was an accident and he didn't mean it. When you chuckled and told him to calm down and you will teach him, he frowned but calmed down and moved along with you, nervously eyeing his and your feet a few times to make sure he's doing it okay and not stepping on your feet.

Mary-Beth:

She is usually the one to sudden pull you up from your seat and dance with you, so you decided to be the one to do so this time. She let out a yelp as she stumbled against you before giggling and dancing along with you, asking you if this is how you always feel when she does it to you. As you nod in reply, she couldn't help but laugh before focusing on the dancing, unable to hide the smile that was on her face as she was very happy right now.

Sadie:

She let out a yelp then gave you unimpressed eyes, asking you what you are doing. As you shrugged and said just dancing, she chuckled and moved along. She first eyed around to make sure no one can see this before she rested her head on you and sighed, dropping the tough act and just enjoying this silent moment and wishing she could have more pleasant moments like these.