Ponyboy: Gone With The Wind. Hey, it may not seem like a good gift, but it has a deep meaning to him.
Johnny: His old jean jacket, since you got him a new one, he knew you'd get cold at night, and you loved his jackets.
Sodapop: He'd get you a packet of Coke, and a gift card to your favorite store, $100 gift card, even if he used his Christmas money on you.
Steve: A new car, and I ain't talking about a used car, a fresh new car, which also cost his Christmas money as well. It had a huge red bow on top!
Dallas: Heh... so at first he forgot it was Christmas (honestly, Dally don't care) but once he saw that you did care, he took you to Buck's party, and a rodeo. Then, he proposed.
Two-Bit: He's always pumped for the holidays! He got you basically the #1 thing you wanted, and then under the tree, were two Dalmatian puppies, with collars on them that said: Mickey. The other: Minnie.
Darry: He got you so much, and he worked his ass off for it! Clothes, and so much more!