If you guy would've chose to turn down the potion you would've been in for a real treat. I'm going to give a brief explanation.
Liam and you would've gotten pretty close. He confessed that he had a crush on you for the longest time but you couldn't return those feelings. You had Garroth and only Garroth on your mind. Garroth felt the same way with you. So when Phoenix drop welcomed Lucinda Garroth had asked her to turn him into a merman and she made him a potion. AND GARROTH WAS A SEXY ASS MERMAN THAT YOU GUYS MISSED OUT ON AND I WOULD'VE ENJOYED WRITING THAT! THANKS GUYS!
I hope you all are happy with your decisions. *goes to bed and cries self to sleep*.