The Reaper's Sister (A Black...

By the2anime_fanatics

125K 3.9K 1K

Scarlet Sutcliff is nothing like her brother, Grell Sutcliff. She's smart, pretty, and much more skilled with... More

DISCLAIMER
Chapter 2
Chapter 3
Chapter 4
Chapter 5
Chapter 6
Chapter 7
Chapter 8
Chapter 9
Chapter 10
Chapter 11
Chapter 12
Chapter 13
Chapter 14
Chapter 15
Scarlet's Backstory Has Been Posted!!
Chapter 16
Chapter 17
Chapter 18
Chapter 19
Sequel!!!

Chapter 1

27.4K 612 326
By the2anime_fanatics

(Welcome to my story, everyone. Since I'm tired of comments of everyone telling me I'm wrong, I'm going to post this note here. Scarlet is written in a few scenes to be homophobic and against Grell being trans. I wanted to warn all of you of this because so you know. Like I've said in a previous note that is posted later in this chapter, Black Butler takes place in the 1800s, and being a member of the LGBTQ+ community could get you arrested. Scarlet is just being someone who lives in this era. Also I wanted to be historically accurate. I'm sorry if anything she says offends you, but I'm not changing it and her views in no way represent mine. I'm very supportive of the community. Anyway, if my warning hasn't scared you away, I hope you enjoy the story.)

(Warning: Any and all comments calling me homophobic, transphobic, or stupid in any form of the words will be deleted. I will not be dealing with all of the negativity anymore. This story was originally posted in 2013 and I have dealt with these types of comments for seven years. This is not an invitation to be rude just because the comment will be deleted. Please think before you say something cruel. Your words have meaning and past comments have affected me greatly. If you are offended in any way by any of Scarlet's actions, I ask that you please silently leave the story and move on with your life. If you can understand that I wrote this when I was young and do not mean to offend anyone, then I invite you to enjoy my story.)

"Grell, for the last time, stop staring at men!" I yelled at my brother, who was making googly eyes at a random man walking down the streets of London, England. We were sitting on top of an old apartment building, or at least, I was sitting. Grell was standing at the edge of the roof so that he could see this pedestrian that was trying to mind his own business, I'm sure.

"Scarlet, the only man I want is my Bassy. But when I'm away from him, I feel so empty inside!" He put the back of one of his hands to his head and fell onto the roof.

I sighed. "This 'Bassy' must have his hands full if he has to put up with you."

"Scarlet, you be nice to you older sister!" Grell yelled, standing up again quickly.

"Grell, you are not my sister!!!" I screamed. "When will you realize that you are a MAN?!?!"

Grell looked offended. He must really think he's a girl, I thought. I sighed again as he searched the street for the man he had been watching, sighing in disappointment when he saw that the man had disappeared.

"Grell, can we please get back to work? I really don't want to get in trouble because you are looking at men." I shuddered as I said the last word. I had had plenty of experience with the reaper dudes. They were all insanely impressed that I was a female good enough to be a reaper, but when they found out that I'm a better reaper than them and they try to take advantage of me. I don't date anymore because of that.

"Calm, yourself, Scarlet," Grell said with a wave of his hand. "You're just jealous because you can't find a guy who you love like I have!" He twirled as he said the last few words.

"You shouldn't crush on a guy at all!!!" I yelled.

(Quick A/N, guys. Sadly, since people seem to be enraged by what I've written, I am going to tell you all now that I am NOT homophobic, and actually very supportive of the LGBT community, even if I'm not a member myself. When I wrote the sentence above, I thought it would be for comedic effect, but people are taking it offensively instead. I apologize if I've affected you, and hope you understand. Also, I have recently looked up the acceptance of homosexuality in the 19th century, and found out that it was very much frowned upon. Acts of homosexuality could have gotten you arrested if people found out. Again, I'm very sad that I had to put this, and what really bother me is that everyone who has commented between the time I posted the chapter to the time that I added this note will never see it. This was longer than I  had expected, so sorry about wasting your time. Please enjoy the rest of the story.)

Grell crossed his arms and turned away from me.

I sighed, then grabbed him by his long red hair and pulled him along the roof of the building. "We don't have time for this. I have humans to reap tonight and I have to babysit you! Please, be the the male that you are for one night!"

I stopped dragging Grell when I reached the other side of the roof. He agreed to behave for one night, emphasizing on the "one night" part. I rolled my eyes and looked at my notebook to see who I had to reap next. It was a woman who lived nearby. I told Grell to follow me and we took off toward the woman's location, which was at a coffee shop down the street.

We traveled by the roofs of buildings and houses until we reached the small coffee shop, then we waited for the lady at the back door. She worked at this particular coffee shop and always left through the back door.

I saw her walk out the building, and then watched to see how she would meet her end: by me or someone else.

She looked pretty cheerful as we followed her to a place under a small bridge that went over a creek. She pulled out a knife from her pocket, and I almost told her not to do it, but then I realized she was waiting for something, so I stayed hidden.

A few minutes went by of nothing except Grell behind me with a mirror checking his hair. I punched him hard and he glared at me before putting the mirror away.

After Grell quit grumbling to himself about something to do with me being a rotten little brat, I heard footsteps. I silenced Grell with a death glare and then turned my attention back to the women and the person meeting her.

It was a man. He was a little taller than she was, and had a mysterious look to him. He smiled at the woman in greeting her, then she dropped the knife on the ground, threw her arms around his neck and kissed him passionately on the mouth. I looked away quickly and tried to shake the image from my head. I heard the knife fall into the stream, and that was when I looked back at the couple.

They had stopped kissing, and the aftermath of it was both of them with messed up hair, jackets were on the ground, and the man had lipstick on his mouth and neck. I was glad I looked away.

I saw the knife float downstream and get caught on a rock almost right beside me. I knew I shouldn't ruin the scene, but I wanted to know what the knife was for. If I touched it, they would kill me when I got home, but I was very curious.

I looked at my notebook and flipped to the woman's picture. All it said under the picture her name she was supposed to die. It said she would kill herself, but that was all the information given. I had to wait out whatever she did in the process to make her kill herself and not interrupt the scene at all. But I couldn't help but wonder, what if she was planning on killing a demon or a reaper or some other inhumanly being?

I glanced back over at the knife. It looked normal enough. Grell then tapped my shoulder. I looked at him and he shook his head. I guess he knew because of how many times I looked at the knife, because there was absolutely NO possible way that he could've known from a sibling connection or anything like that at all.

For once Grell was right about something, so I left the knife where it was, knowing that it had a purpose for something. I looked back at the couple, and they were w walking toward the city as the sun fell low in the sky.

I waved Grell to follow me, and we followed the woman and he man without being noticed. They stopped and turned slowly around when we had reached an alley in London. I pushed Grell behind a dumpster and quickly jumped over next to him, my scythe at the ready.

My reaper's scythe was a long sword with a black handle. I was too young for a custom made scythe, so I was using the sword until I turned 16.

I risked a glance at the couple over the dumpster, and saw that they were walking toward us. Then I saw them walk to the side of the dumpster, and I pushed Grell behind another side of it. He was able to stay quiet when he landed behind it, and that helped out a little.

The man looked over at me. I stood, my scythe visible in front of me, but to humans it only looked like a normal sword.

The man smiled at me before continuing down the narrow street. He didn't look back at me, and I didn't breathe until he had turned the corner.

I ran around the corner and saw the couple disappear into a fog that kept growing thicker and thicker. In just a few moments, I couldn't see my hand right in front of me. I turned to see if I could see Grell behind me, but everything was white from the fog, and noting was visible except the wall of mist.

I suddenly felt something around me, squeezing me. I turned my head, and saw a little bit of pink in the fog. Immediately I knew that it was Grell, the white fog made his hair appear the lighter color. I almost laughed at that.

He picked me up and jumped onto the roof of a tall building, high above the top of the fog. I couldn't see anything below, let alone the couple I was supposed to be after.

I sighed. "What time is it Grell?"

He looked at his watch that he only took with him occasionally. "Past midnight," he said.

I glanced back at the woman's page in my notebook. It said that she killed herself at 1:01 am. I had to find her again before then.

"What is the exact time?' I tried again.

"12:15," he said.

Great. 45 minutes to find her. I would need the other minute to watch how she killed herself.

I opened my mouth to speak, but I was interrupted by a scream.

I looked at Grell, who appeared to really want to see where the scream came m for who knows what reason.

"Come on Grell," I called, running along the rooftops toward the source of the scream.

Grell followed me, his excitement showing in every step he took.

On the way, I kept hearing more screams, each one more distant then the first. It was confusing me, and I heard screams from all directions. This had never happened before. What was going on?

I stopped running and tried to calm myself. I took deep breaths, held my ears, but nothing worked. I fell to my knees in frustration. My hands were pushing against my ears, but the screams grew louder and louder, until I was scared to death. I felt nauseous, and I was dizzy.

I saw Grell's worried face through tears that I wouldn't let flow as I fell to the rooftop, darkness taking over.

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

2.1K 75 13
This is my first Grell x Sebastian fanfic's. I have two other Black Butler fanfic's. But I want to see if people will like this one first. Everyone i...
358K 10.6K 37
Would you be willing to go through Hell to get your happily ever after? --- "Sebastian, do not come any closer to me," I whispered. He ignored my ple...
3.5K 113 29
**Currently on hiatus until inspiration hits me First story on wattpad ever that was written because I got bored but anyway; You died in your previ...
4.3K 136 26
Running through the streets by day, killing innocent people by night. Carol Blackwood hides the fact that she is demon. One night, it appears that he...