Theo wasn't lying when he told the boys he was persistent with Naomi. He hadn't stopped calling her phone ever since the shitshow that was Halloween night. Where the two of them had both kissed someone else who wasn't each other. Where they were both hurting.
At least she agreed to meet, he thought to himself.
He paced his room as he anticipated her arrival. He had just gotten back from talking to the boys. He didn't know if she would show up. If she didn't, he was definitely climbing up onto her balcony. He wanted to talk to her and he wasn't taking no for answer. He wouldn't allow this to be the end of him and Naomi, all because of a girl wanting to get revenge on her boyfriend.
Suddenly, there was a knock at his window. He knew it was her.
Walking over to his balcony, he was met with a very disinterested Naomi.
"Baby I'm-"
"Save it Theo, just tell me why you kissed her" she interrupted, walking past Theo into his room and sitting on his bed.
"I-" he started, following after her and sitting down next to her
"Actually, let's start with, would you of even told me if I never walked in on you?" She hissed, getting up and moving away from him because she knew he'd touch her to make her weak and forgive him easily
"Naomi, can I talk?" He asked, watching her keep a safe distance away from him. It was annoying. He just wanted to reach out and touch her, but he knew he couldn't.
"Yes, talk away. I've given you enough time to come up with a successful lie to attempt to convince me you didn't kiss her, even though I saw it" she laughed bitterly
"I'm not lying to you when i tell you this. I walked into the bathroom that night because I obviously needed a piss and all the boys had directed me to that one. I ended up going inside the toilet and find Melissa crying her eyes out, sat on the bathroom floor. I obviously know her through Jimmy and she's a nice girl so I comforted her because why was she crying at her own party. She then told me that she literally walked in on Jimmy shagging another girl in her bed and kicked both of them out and had been crying in the bathroom ever since"
"Okay but that doesn't explain why you kissed her" she pointed out, watching Theo stand on the other side of his room
"I didn't kiss her, she kissed me. I was there with her for a while and she must of gotten the wrong idea because she kept saying things like 'whoever is my girlfriend is a lucky girl' and i was smiling, thinking of you and then she starts saying that 'I'm so nice', then next thing I know she's jumping onto me and kisses me. Maybe it was because she saw me smiling, thinking that I was smiling at her when I was really thinking of you"
"I was just about to push her off of me because I'm with you and I like you, and then suddenly you open the bathroom door"
"So she kissed you because she wanted to get with a 'nice' guy who wasn't like Jimmy and in a sense wanted to get revenge on him because you're on the same team with him?" She reiterated
"Exactly, baby" he stressed walking towards her
"I still can't believe you Theo" she revealed, as she moved away from his close proximity, tugging on the sleeves of her oversized hoodie and hugging herself
"I promise you" he reassured, noticing her movements. He knew that she only did that action when she was nervous or upset and he hated the fact that he was the cause of it
"I'll make it up to you. I will." He stressed, watching her downcast eyes finally look up at him with hurt and uncertainty swirl around in them.
"And to answer your other question, I'm going to be honest with you. I don't know if I would of told you that she kissed me because it didn't mean anything. I didn't even kiss her back. So no, I don't think I would of told you" he admitted, wanting to be fully truthful with her.
He remembered the hurt in her eyes when she opened the bathroom door and found him in there with Melissa, there was no way he would of told her if he had to see that same look of hurt on her face, it would break him, it would break him again. He remembered that same look of hurt from when he said what he said to her last year in his room about her hair. He couldn't hurt her again.
"But Naomi, that doesn't excuse why you kissed another boy" Theo mentioned. He was always going to bring it up because he obviously knew she wanted her own revenge, but the fact that she was acting so innocent and hurt right now, annoyed him. She was allowed to be hurt, but the fact that she hadn't even mentioned it was annoying. He was allowed to be hurt as well, after watching her not only kiss another boy, but he saw how that boy had his hands on her body and then led her out of the party, with whatever intentions.
"I kissed him as pay back" she stated
"You kiss someone else, I kiss someone else"
"You get your dick sucked, I get eaten out"
"You fuck another girl, I fuck another boy"
"An eye for eye, take it or leave it Theo" she raised her eyebrows at him, waiting for him to question her.
"Well then looks like you're mine and mine only" He rasped, as he began to walk towards her, this time without her moving away from him.
Naomi didn't even get time to register what he had said before he had her backed up against the wall, kissing her neck. She wanted -. To be honest, she didn't know what she wanted, anymore.
"If you're going to kiss me, kiss me properly" she whispered, as his hands made their way to her ass and grasped it making her moan.
Theo smiled against her neck and connected their lips in no time. They were hungry for each other. They hadn't had sex since the night of the arcade.
Naomi wrapped her legs around Theo's waist and her arms around his neck as he carried them over to his bed.
She broke the kiss, pulling off her hoodie, leaving her in a bralette, and gripped the hem of Theo's T-shirt and pulled his off too.
He reconnected their lips, whilst he had his hands on his hips, guiding Naomi to grind against his hard member.
She moaned into the kiss, feeling him tug the waistband of her joggers. She felt one of his hands snake their way into her underwear, rubbing her core.
"Fuck" she moaned, feeling Theo know exactly what to do to set her off
"Baby"
"Hmm?" She asked
"I can only give you want you want if you promise me one thing"
"W-what?"
"Promise me that I'm the only one who gets to see you like this, touch you like this and I'll give you what you want"
"Theo... You're the only one who gets me like this" she breathed out, feeling him adjust her panties so that he could touch her bare pussy.
"Good girl" he rasped, kissing her neck, slipping a single finger inside of her
Naomi shuddered from the single finger moving in and out of her folds. Even though it wasn't that long ago that Theo had touched her, she felt starved. She craved his touch.
He added another finger, as he felt Naomi increase her speed in riding him.
"S-stop" she moaned out
Theo halted all movement. He listened to Naomi. He didn't know what just happened, but he removed his lips away from her neck and pulled his fingers out of her and looked at her. He needed to make sure she was okay. She had never stopped him before.
Naomi let out a breath and climbed off of Theo.
Theo began to panic. Did he do something wrong?
Before he even got to ask her if she was okay, he noticed she had unclasped her bralette, letting it fall to her feet and begun to pull off her joggers and underwear. She then reached forward and pulled off his joggers along with his boxers.
She wasn't stopping them, she was just pausing because she wanted to feel everything. She didn't want their clothes restricting them.
She straddled his lap, and began to grind herself against him.
"Oh my god" she breathed out, feeling so much better with their clothes gone. She coated Theo's dick in her juices as she slid back and forth against him.
"Fuck" Theo grunted, getting off on the soft sounds of Naomi's moans just by her letting the tip of his dick poke her sex ever so slightly.
Theo returned his fingers inside of her, as she grabbed his dick.
She began to pump him, as she rode his fingers.
"Y-yes" he hissed, feeling Naomi pick up her speed of stroking his dick when he began to curl his fingers inside of her.
"Theo I'm close" she panted, rocking her hips faster
"That's it baby, ride my fingers" he cooed, before attaching his mouth to one of her mounds, swirling his tongue against her nipple piercing.
Naomi's back arched in pleasure as she tugged on the hairs on the nape of Theo's neck, as she rode his fingers. His dick long forgotten. She intended on getting her orgasm.
"Oh fuck!" She moaned out, feeling Theo increase his pace and insert another finger inside of her, stretching her out even further.
"Fuck you look so sexy right now" Theo hummed, watching Naomi as her eyes were closed, seeing her face contorted in concentration and pleasure as her breasts jiggled to the movement of her hips.
That was his girl.
He couldn't help but stare.
"Mmm daddy, let me cum" she whimpered
It wasn't the fact that Theo needed to do anything more than he was already doing, but it was his dominant aura of him telling her to cum, made it so much better. So much more pleasurable. She wanted him to let her cum. To let her release it all. All over his fingers and onto his thigh.
"Cum baby, I know you want to" he grunted, feeling her walls tighten around his fingers and seeing her twitch out of pleasure. Her head falling into the crook of his neck as she panted.
"Oh my... yes!" She cried out, feeling her body allow her to release the tension in it. Her body shuddered from the climax which had just flowed through her.
Theo slowly pulled his fingers out of Naomi's pulsating heat and sucked them clean, moaning at the taste of her.
"Baby you wanna taste yourself?"
Naomi removed her head from the crook of Theo's neck, catching her breath. She looked into his eyes, with a devious smile, as she nodded her head.
Theo ever so slightly leaned forward, letting his lips brush against Naomi's.
Naomi whined out of desperation. She wanted him to connect their lips already.
Theo chuckled lowly at his girl.
As he was too busy taking in every detail of her, when Naomi smashed her lips into his.
Their kiss started off slow, disconnecting and reconnecting every now again. Letting their mouths melt into each other's, when Theo grew tired of the teasing and inserted his tongue into her mouth.
Naomi moaned into the kiss, tasting herself on his tongue, feeling his dick poking her at lower lips.
Without breaking the kiss, Theo raised Naomi's hips, so he could position himself against her pussy.
Naomi sunk down on him. The sudden feeling of being wrapped inside of her made Theo whimper. It felt so long since he had been inside of her.
Naomi couldn't help but bite down on Theo's lip, pulling it as she broke the kiss, smiling at how full he made her feel.
Letting his lip go, Theo stared at her with so much desire. He didn't think it, but everytime they had sex she brought out something new inside of him.
It was as if the two of them were in sync, because without saying anything, Naomi began to rock her hips, riding Theo, as he began to kiss her neck.
Naomi began to slow down her movements, as she was already so sensitive and Theo kissing her neck wasn't helping. Her heat was throbbing and Theo's dick inside of her, constantly twitching with every moan that left her lips made her dazed and disoriented with lust.
Theo noticed Naomi's lack of movement and grabbed two handfuls of her ass. He smacked it repeatedly until Naomi's eyes burned into his, her lips parted, beginning to move her hips again, with the pleasurable pain motivating her.
"That's it, baby" he praised, watching her bite her lip with the amount of pleasure flowing through her.
"D-daddy please" she whined, hoping for Theo to take control. She couldn't do this anymore. He was doing too much to her. She was already so sensitive and it was so intense.
"Use your words" he rasped, as he reach down in between their bodies and began to rub her clit.
Naomi choked on her breath as she felt Theo stimulate her even more. Her body was on fire.
"F-fuck..." she stuttered
"What was that?" He questioned, feeling her clamp down on him
"F-fuck me, please!" She moaned out
Theo smirked at her, removing his hand from stimulating her. He held her hips and began to pound into her from underneath.
"L-like this baby?" He asked
"Yes!" She cried out, feeling his dick pound into her repeatedly. His balls slapping against her pussy. His fingers digging into her hips, a pleasurable pain. His low groans and grunts which left his mouth in the attempt to contain himself. His praising words of how good it felt to be inside of her. It was all so good.
Naomi's nails dug into Theo's shoulders as she felt that similar knot in her gut build up. The same waves of pleasure flow through her quicker and quicker. Her toes curling.
"D-daddy I'm gonna-" she moaned
"Cum, baby" he whispered into her ear
Naomi let it all go. She let her cum wrap around and coat Theo's dick, as he continued to pound into her from beneath, reaching his own high.
Naomi's moaned in Theo's ear as she felt him twitch inside of her. She wanted him to cum. She wanted him to cum for her.
"Daddy cum for me" she whispered, licking Theo's ear
Within seconds, Theo pulled Naomi's body on-top of his, holding her above his dick, as he let out a low groan, feeling his cum release.
"Fuck" he breathed out, guiding Naomi to lay beside him.
Naomi giggled. She reached over to his bedside table, pulling some tissues from the box and cleaned him up.
"Thanks baby" he whispered as he kissed her forehead
Naomi smiled at him.
Before he could grab her to cuddle with him, Naomi moved away, out of his reach.
He watched her get up from her previous position and begin to gather her clothes.
He sat up in bed, watching her.
He was confused.
"Where are you going?"
"Leaving" she stated
"You don't get the perks of having me stay over if you let other girls kiss you so easily" she explained as she begun to put her on her clothes
"Baby, I'm sorry, you know that, stay, please"
"No" she whispered. She couldn't. She couldn't let him her off so easily. There was still something holding her back from them being fully okay again.
"Baby, the kiss didn't mean anything, at this point you're jealous for no reason"
"I'm not jealous, this is just sex" she smiled
"Just sex? Just sex, really Naomi? There is no way this is just sex between us. And it certainly didn't sound like it a few minutes ago and if anything I'm the one who has the right to be pissed, you kissed that boy infront of me" Theo pointed out. He wanted to make a joke about her saying this was 'just sex' there was no way, not after their conversation about their feelings.
"Have you ever heard of faking it?" She laughed, wanting to tease him a little. "And like I said, the kiss was pay back, you can't be pissy with me about that" She said not bothering to look at him, whilst she put on her shoes
"Well come back over here and I'll make sure you can't walk tomorrow" he smiled
"Aww cute, your ego has been so damaged you're begging for a second round, but no thanks" she stated, checking her phone. She just wanted to get home and do her uni work, because once again Theo was always distracting her so she never got a chance to complete it.
"Naomi stop playing" he stressed, noticing she was now fully dressed and she was really leaving
"No. You knew what you were getting into when you met me, I don't do relationships and I especially don't do the 'L' word so it's just sex okay? Or what? Because as far as I know other girls have kissed you without me knowing. Therefore you're not mine. You never were. So I guess this arrangement between us is just sex." She exclaimed, revealing why she was acting so distant with him, as she finally looked up at him. She was pissed. Yes she had sex with him, she enjoyed it, but now things had changed. She may of been acting a bit dramatic right now, but she was doing everything for her own benefit now. She was putting herself first, her feelings came first.
"Naomi" he warned
"Bye Theo" she smiled as she made her way out to the balcony and the back route to her house.
"Naomi!" He shouted, making her pause and turn around to look at him
"What?"
"Why are you being like this?" He asked, now realising none of this was a joke. They weren't messing around. She was pissed and she didn't want to talk to him.
"Because you keep hurting me Theo. We finally make progress and I feel like we're getting somewhere and then shit just happens. We keep taking two steps backwards instead of forward and I hate it. I don't even know how to act around you anymore, so for now this is just sex. Just sex because I can't deal with the feelings if one of us keeps on getting hurt"
"Baby-" he sighed
"No Theo, listen to me. You wouldn't of told me about her kissing you and that's something that doesn't sit right with me, to you it was nothing but a silly mistake on Melissa's end because she got the wrong idea, but it was still a kiss, a kiss where she could of caught feelings, thinking that you two are meant to be or whatever and she starts perusing you. And then what? How would you explain to me why she's suddenly started to like you? What if she went and told the fashion society and all her friends that she kissed this new boy and she really likes him and I found out through that? How would you explain that away? I would look like a dickhead finding out through something like that"
"Shit, when you say it like that I understand. I didn't even think about that. I'm sorry baby, I really am" he stressed, pulling on his boxers to walk up to her
"I know you are" she sighed looking at him, as he cradled her cheek and looked into her eyes
"Naomi" Theo mumbled, whilst he stared at the girl he liked.
"Yeah" she furrowed her brows at his change in expression, as if he was having a mental debate about what he wanted to say next.
"I need you to answer this honestly, did you sleep with him?"
"What?" She asked, taken aback
"Did you sleep with him? That guy at the Halloween party?" He repeated himself. He needed to know. It had been playing in his head from the moment he watched her leave the party with that guy. All the way till now. He needed to hear her say it. He needed her to tell him. He needed to know that she was still his.
"No I didn't" she replied
"Then why did you leave with him?" It was Theo's turn to ask the questions now. Yes, Melissa has kissed him, but when Naomi kissed that guy, it wasn't five seconds, like his was, it was a kiss with desire behind it. A kiss where she initiated it.
"Because I couldn't stand in that party with you staring at me. With you there after you let another girl kiss you. So I left with him. He drove me home, that's all that happened. He thought we were going to do more, but I stopped him and I let him know that I wasn't interested. See, Theo, even when I thought you were a cheater, I still didn't go any further when I had the opportunity to" she explained
"I don't believe you" he mumbled. He couldn't pinpoint it, but he felt like something was off between him and Naomi. More so, he thought that there was something off with Naomi. The way she was acting so distant, it made him doubt her. He didn't believe her. He wanted to, but he didn't.
"What?! You don't believe me? Why? Because you think I open my legs for the first boy who comes along? Or why because you think I would sleep with another boy to spite you?!"
"Well you did with Seb" he whispered, not wanting to remember how Seb was laying on the floor in pain, rubbing it in Theo's face that he had slept with Naomi just to spite him. That seb was there first. That he got to hold Naomi like that, make Naomi moan for him. It made him pissed off. And now he had the thought of another, new guy seeing her in the same way. Having her legs open for him, instead of himself.
"What the fuck are you even talking about? I never fucking slept with Seb. What? You're saying because I was doing sexual stuff with Seb, when me and you somewhat were getting to know each other and figuring out our feelings in some weird toxic way, that I was using him to get over you? Wow, how self absorbed can you be Theo?"
"Well he said-" Theo started
"You believe Sebastian over me. Wow, alright then." She gritted out, pulling Theo's hand off of her body
"Let me just reiterate this one more time. I didn't sleep with Seb, I never did or ever will, and I didn't sleep with that guy on Halloween, I only kissed him. Don't believe me, I guess this is done then" she answered
"If neither of us trust each other..." she trailed off, grabbing the door handle to leave
"Naomi I didn't-" Theo rushed out, realising what was happening and how quickly it was happening. He didn't think things could go so south so quickly. He was meant to be sorting things out with her, what the fuck was happening? What was she saying?
"No, let's spend some time apart, I think that'll be the best thing for us" she finished, as she walking down the stairs of the balcony to go home.
Theo watched her leave. He didn't even know what to say. He didn't know what would even stop her at this point. What the fuck just happened? One second they were having sex and he thought everything was calm and then she was leaving. What did he even say? It all happened so fast. His head was spinning.
Throwing himself onto his bed in frustration, Theo buried his head into his pillow shouting for some sort of relief. Why couldn't he ever get his words right around her.
Maybe they did need time apart. Maybe she'd come back to him, realising that she was overreacting and would ask for his forgiveness. Maybe this time will make her realise how much she likes him. Maybe then he could convinced her to be his. He could do this. He was just waiting on her. Well. he hoped he could do this.