The One That Got Away || Benn...

By _weasleylife_

211K 3.9K 503

Reagan Sullivan was never the one to cope. She always liked to avoid things. For example, feelings. When she... More

00
01
02
03
04
05
06
07
BONUS
Season One
08
09
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
Season Two
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
41
Author's Note
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
EPILOGUE

40

1.8K 33 0
By _weasleylife_

Reagan sighs as she just finished her two hours of geometry homework. She leans back in her chair and closes her eyes-- right as her computer beeped.

Groaning, she opens her eyes to see Benny calling on a video chat. She clicks the accept button and a smiling Benny appears on the screen.

"Why are you smiling like that?" Reagan questions with suspicion. 

"Can't I just smile at my beautiful girlfriend without her questioning me?" Benny asks but sighs at the look on Reagan's face. "Fine. Ethan wants us to come over to play Hectbots Rebellion--"

"Correction. He wants you to come over and play. Ethan needs my help with watching the boys." Reagan corrects with a smirk. "Sarah already called me."

Benny groans. "I knew something was up when she overheard mine and Ethan's conversation. Okay, see you there. I love you."

Before Reagan could say the three-letter word back, Benny hangs up. She chuckles as she shuts her computer and stands up.

"I love that dork." She mutters to herself before exiting her room.

When Reagan arrived at the Morgan household, she saw Benny and Rory walking up the porch steps. 

"Hey, boys."

The two boys turn around and saw Reagan stepping up the porch steps. They smile at her and she noticed the nerf guns in their hands.

She chuckles. "You really think those are gonna stop them?" Benny and Rory shrug. "We're hoping so."

They enter through the front door, making their way to the kitchen. Benny creeps up behind Sarah and Ethan, yelling, "Benny--!"

Reagan lets out a wince as Sarah turned around and punches Benny in the stomach. "Ouch." Benny groans, leaning onto Reagan. The girl gently pats his head as Sarah gasps. "Oh my gosh, Benny! I'm so sorry!"

"Booyah!" Rory yells, shooting up from behind the kitchen counter. Ethan spins around and shoots a dart between Rory's eyebrows. "Hey! Is this for me barfing down your chimney?"

"No, no. I just-- wait, you what?" Ethan questions. "Nothing. I'm here to help battle the Tornado Twins."

"Yeah, us too. Are they here yet? I don't see anybody bleeding." Benny says. Ethan points over to the kitchen table where the two boys were sitting at. "See for yourself. Hey boys, this is Benny, Rory, and Reagan."

"Hello, Benny, Rory, and Reagan." The twins said in unison, before turning back to their drawing. The five teenagers looked baffled. "Whoa. That is a tornado of weird." Rory spoke.

"Kids speaking in unison. That's never good." Benny comments. A knock from behind startled them and they turned to find Erica looking board at Ethan's back door. "Are we going or what? I'm starving." She says to Sarah before looking at Reagan. "Wanna join?"

"I'm good, thanks." Reagan replies, then Sarah says, "Coming, Erica." She sighs and begins to leave before Ethan stops her. 

"What. Going? Going where?" 

"New safety rule from the council-- they want us to hunt in pairs," Sarah explains before she and Erica left the house.

"What now? Do I check their crayons for sharp edges?" Ethan asks. "Dude, relax. Can't you see? They know what they're up against. In their eyes, we're the grown-ups."

"Grown-ups." Reagan snickers. "Please."

"Let's go play video games!" Rory yells, and Benny cheers as they race up the stairs to Ethan's room.

Reagan playfully rolls her eyes before looking at Jane. "You got them, right? I have to watch the actual kids."

Jane chuckles as she fake salutes. "Got it."

The teenager smiles before walking up the stairs.

*

"Kill the queen, destroy the hive," Ethan orders Benny and Rory. The three boys were huddled around by the tv as Reagan watched from Ethan's bed. 

"But it's more fun shooting Rory!" Benny smirks.

"Not for Rory!" Rory argues.

"Should we check on the kids?" Ethan asks. Benny shrugs before yelling, "Hey, creep brothers! If you're okay, say nothing!" There was a moment of silence and Benny continues, "Yeah, they're fine."

The three teenage boys continued playing the video game for a while, and Reagan was starting to fall asleep. "Rory! Snacks!" Benny tells him. "I'm on it!" Rory speeds downstairs, coming back in two seconds.

Reagan looks over at him and she furrowed her eyebrows. He was holding two bags of chips and a red ring was drawn around his face. "Guys, those boys ain't right."

Ethan and Benny paused the game and Reagan got up from the bed to follow them down the stairs. All the walls were a dozen papers taped to the wall, multiple red doors drawn. "Which one's the evil one?" Rory questions, wanting to know which twin painted his face.

Ethan slowly went up to one of the twins. He places his hand on their shoulder, gasping as he received a vision. "Val Mudrap is coming." The twins and Jane said together. "They said who now?"

"We've got a problem," Ethan says. The sound of the front door opening caused Benny to squeak, "Your mom's home."

Mrs. Morgan pushes the three aside as she stared at the red door painting in shock. No words came out of her mouth as her mouth dropped. Reagan, Benny, and Rory glanced at each other before the two vampires ran out of there.

*

"Your mom was so busy yelling, she didn't even notice Sarah gone or Jane acting weird," Benny says to Ethan as the two and Reagan walk through the school halls. 

"I'll tell you what's weird: my vision had snack food in it," Ethan tells them.

"Dude, I have visions of food all the time. Pizza, milkshakes, pizza-flavored milkshakes." Benny smiles. 

"Every time I searched Val Mudrap, my computer froze on that picture of a red door," Ethan says. He looks behind Reagan and Benny, seeing a bunch of students exiting the school. "Why is everyone leaving?"

"Hello there, kids." Principal Hicks greets. "Classes are canceled. All the teaching staff appears to have left."

"Left? Left where exactly?" Reagan asks.

"No idea. They just got up and took off. Not even a word of thank-you for the donuts I got them." Hicks holds up the donut and takes a bite of it. Suddenly, his expression went blank as he stared into nothing. "Time to go."

He walks off and out of the school, leaving the three confused. "Did you just see that?" Ethan asks. "Do you know what this means?"

"Yes! Of course! Sort of... nope. Just tell me what it means." Benny sighs. "It must be the donuts. They're making all the adults leave town and turning the kids into droneos. I wonder what it does to teenagers."

"I don't wanna know!" Benny exclaims, grabbing his bag. He pulls out boxes of donuts before throwing them into the hallway.

"Why did you buy--" Reagan began.

"A moment of weakness, all right?" He defends.

Reagan laughs before spotting her two friends. "Hey, guys." As result, Erica replies with a hiss and bares her fangs. "Okay?"

"Sorry. She's so hungry she can't control her fangs and I'm so hungry I can't control her!" Sarah explains before looking at Reagan. "How are you not low on blood?"

"Because I'm not." Reagan shrugs. "My body is like a temple. I can have just a sip of blood, and I'm fine."

That wasn't the truth. Reagan has been low on blood for days but since people have been leaving, she hasn't been able to restock. She's just been good at hiding her hunger. 

Another hiss comes from Erica. 

"We need real food and this town is running on empty." Sarah continues. 

"So? Just fly over to the next town and get some takeout." Benny says. "The Vampire Council says hunting outside of Whitechapel can cause a turf war." 

"Can't you just take a small nibble of a student--" Ethan begins but was cut off by Erica.

"Teenagers are full of junk food and hormones. Do you have any idea what that can do to your skin?" She angrily walks away and Sarah follows her. "Whatever's happening, un-happen it!"

"Okay, we need to go home and come up with a plan," Ethan tells them.

Benny's eyes widen in excitement. "Wait! No adults? I have been dreaming of this moment my whole life. We can do anything we want!"

A low rumble came from Reagan's stomach that was unheard of from the boys. "I uh-- I actually have to catch up with the girls." 

As she runs off, the two teenagers look at each other. "Girls." 

*

The three female vampires walked around the empty town. Reagan was explaining to them about her secret blood problem.

"If it's that serious, why don't you tell the boys? You have a geek boyfriend who also does magic. I'm pretty sure he could help." Erica suggests.

Reagan sighs. "It's not just that. Benny's been super protective ever since I had that magic incident. I don't need him worrying about my blood problem." 

In the distance, the three hear grunts and yelling. When they got closer, they realized it was Benny and Ethan.

Getting beat up by little kids.

Erica pulls out her phone and starts videotaping as Sarah and Reagan laugh. "Wave to the camera, guys! You're gonna be internet stars!"

"Sarah, Reagan! Help! This is serious!" Ethan yells. 

"In a sec!" Sarah shouts.

"We're enjoying you getting your butt kicked by ankle-biters." Reagan laughs.

"Ow! They're biting my ankles!"

"Okay, this is serious." Sarah finally said before helping the boys. Erica and Reagan sigh before going over to help.

The three vampires eventually got all of the kids off of them and they started walking home. "I think there's a tooth in my shoe," Benny says.

"The kid had braces." Ethan groans, throwing the brackets onto the ground. 

"Maybe I have some Moleos left in my bag." As Benny rummaged through his bag, he didn't expect his girlfriend to flash her fangs at him and hiss. 

From beside her, Erica hisses. "Don't talk about eating!" She collapsed to the ground. 

Benny was still shocked that Reagan hissed at him that he didn't get to react when Sarah grabbed the collar of his shirt. "Your grandma's blood substitute. I know it tastes like shoes, but does she have any left?"

"Grandma is long gone. She has a pack-a-day habit in Moleo season." Benny tells her. "Last time I touched her stuff she put a shrunken head in my lunch. That guy wouldn't shut up."

Sarah hisses at him. 

"What is up with you vampires hissing at me?!" Benny saw the look from the three very known hungry vampires. "I mean... let's go!"

"That alpha brat is hoarding every kid in town. Now Jane's home all alone." Ethan says.

"We can't fight anyone when we're this weak. You get Jane. We'll get food." Sarah tells Ethan and he nods. 

Reagan walks over to Erica and helps her off the ground before the four walked to Benny's house.


Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

121K 3K 24
"if you knew it was a bad idea, why'd you try?" "i don't always make good decisions."
77.1K 1.5K 28
my babysitters a vampire season 1 oc x rory keaner
9.6K 285 19
★ 𝐇𝐎𝐋𝐃 𝐎𝐍 𝐓𝐈𝐆𝐇𝐓 ! • my babysitter's a vampire • fem oc x benny weir When a teenage girl decides to become a full ...
68.3K 1.3K 21
{ COMPLETED } y/n y/l/n has been best friends with ethan morgan and benny weir all her life. secretly, she is madly in love with benny. ** the charac...