Invisible Armies

Chapter 16

"Keiran," Angus sighs. "Mate. It's all fucking memorized. Leave it be, let it settle. Tonight let's just have an evening of civilized discussion. Please."

"All right." Keiran decides to do something nice for Danielle. Raising his wine glass, he says, "To tomorrow. And to Dani for making it happen."

Angus, Estelle and Laurent echo the sentiment. Danielle awards Keiran an embarrassed smile as she sips her wine.

"You've done a bang-up job," Angus agrees.

"Thanks. I made a lot of mistakes, but at least now I'll know for next time."

"There might not be a next time as such," Estelle says. "You've done so well with the protest I think in future we'll rope you in for the important stuff."

Danielle cocks her head. "Important stuff? The protest isn't important?"

"Well, it's a vital part of the plan, of course, but in itself it'll never be the answer," Angus says. "Protests are useless."

Estelle clears her throat loudly in disagreement. Danielle smiles gratefully at her.

"Are you forgetting how we met?" Estelle asks.

"Ah," Angus says. "There is that."

Estelle explains, "We met at a protest. Our first date was in a holding cell. We both wore plastic handcuffs. It was very romantic."

"To clarify," Angus says. "Other than matchmaking for lovelorn anarchists, protests are useless. That was the chief insight that brought us here. All those people sleeping in the warehouse, they're not here to get results. They know there won't be any results. They join because it makes them feel good. And that's very nice but doesn't actually accomplish anything. Protests only work when you get a million people out in the streets every day for weeks. Anything smaller is useless. Estelle and I spent years trying to shame companies into acting like human beings are more than a fleshy shell with money inside waiting to be squeezed out. And of course this was a complete failure. Because companies don't feel shame, and most people are useless selfish cunts. So we moved onto direct action, black blocs, violent protests, destruction of property, trying to physically shut companies down. But that doesn't work either. It worked once, Seattle 1999, but that was all we got. After that they were ready for us, and the police are on their side. The G8 and WTO meet behind razor wire now, and big businesses are so distributed that it's hard to find a vital point, shutting down a single office does nothing. The black blocs get plenty of media attention, but that's only because what the TV audience really wants to see is someone's skull get split open. They won't actually care about why the black bloc is there in the first place. The proles are the problem, not the solution. Protests are useless. So how do you fight a massive transnational corporation?"

Nobody replies. Keiran hopes somebody will. He thinks he knows what Angus and Estelle intend to do with the access and information he will give them if tomorrow's plan succeeds, but he'd very much like confirmation. They've never actually explained their goals, at least not to him, but on this nervous night before the protest and the raid, they seem to have relaxed their instinctive need-to-know secrecy.

"We finally found an answer," Angus says. "Or it found us. The answer is, you don't want the media, you don't want the masses, you want management. That's how you take out a corporation. You go straight after the men in suits. Scare the bastards, intimidate them, hurt them if you have to. Make them resign. Make them think twice before they market powdered milk with insufficient nutrition as a good replacement for breastfeeding, not because they'll feel bad about killing babies, they won't, but because they're afraid we'll come after them and their colleagues. Their families if we have to. That's what we do. That's what we're doing tomorrow. We could get a hundred thousand people on the streets of La Défense chanting "Death To Kishkinda!" and they'd sit up there and smile. But when we start following them home and knocking on their front door, they'll change their tune but fucking quick."

Danielle looks as if her spaghetti sauce is made of vinegar. Keiran winces. He is glad to have his suspicions officially verified, but his toast has backfired. Danielle does not want to hear that the demonstration she has spent so much time and sweat on is useless except as a front. But no one else seems to notice her expression; Angus and Estelle are too carried away by their words, and Laurent is paying close attention to them.

"That's the ground war," Angus says. "To my mind, Estelle and I have a slight disagreement on this, the ground war is less important. Or not less important, but it's like modern militaries, before you can even fight on the ground, you have to win in the air. Except our air war is the information war. I use that word advisedly, let's not fool ourselves, people have died, they murdered Jayalitha, this is a shooting war. You have to know everything about the enemy, and control what the enemy knows." He nods to Keiran. "That's you, you're our air war. Except it's a bit of a dogfight with this P2 about."

Keiran nods.

"So why Kishkinda?" Laurent asks. "Did you suggest it to the foundation, or they to you?"

"Kishkinda are first because they're an easy target."

Keiran blinks. "First?"

"We're not going to stop with them. We're here to build a whole better world, one dead evil company at a time. Maybe we'll fail, but that's the ultimate goal, and we're entirely serious about it. Kishkinda are first because they're vulnerable. If we intimidate enough of their management into resigning, destroy enough of their information, and maybe harass the mining operations itself, we'll make that mine uneconomical. It's barely profitable as is. We can drive them bankrupt. We've got the tools, we've got the time, we've got the money."

Laurent raises his eyebrows. "Your foundation gave you enough money to wage war on a billion-dollar company? And another after that, and another after that?"

"More of a loan, really," Estelle says. "We pay them back by winning. If we do, Kishkinda stock will plummet. The foundation shorts that stock and makes millions. Which in turn builds a war chest for the next target."

Laurent whistles with admiration.

Estelle says, "I hate to use the terms of the enemy, but our war, our better world, has a very sound business model."

"The revolution will be self-financing," Keiran says. "That's beautiful. That's elegant. I wish I'd thought of it myself."

"Can we maybe stop talking business and just eat?" Danielle asks sourly.

Keiran returns to his food. He turns the scheme over in his mind as he eats, admiring it. Angus and Estelle are right. This is exactly how you fight a major corporation. Until now he has assumed that their task was quixotic, that they would never be more than a sharp stone in Kishkinda's shoe, but now he realizes, if tomorrow's raid goes well, there's an outside chance that they might actually win, that these few determined people could drive a billion-dollar company into collapse. Asymmetrical war. Like the 767s that felled the World Trade Center. Which isn't such a bad analogy. After all, even if they don't intend to hurt anyone, the people sitting around this table are planning to use crime, violence and fear to achieve their political objectives: that makes them, by any reasonable definition of the word, terrorists.