my babysitter's brother ||| fw x reader

019. the car ride

*millies pov*
why was alyssa so uncomfortable with jack.
millie: why cant i hang out with jack?
finn: hes a bad person
millies: hes your best fr-
finn: was. he was my best friend
millie: what am i missing
they all looked at alyssa
she nodded and started to speak
alyssa: jack uh, jack raped me
millie: what?
so thats why finn is with her. he feels bad! it makes sense now
noah: its true. and i never lie to you millie.
millie: well where am i supposed to sleep?
noah: you can sleep in my room. they gave me two beds instead of one
millie: okay. well lets go then.
we all buckled up and nick started driving
i was staring at finn.
i love finn. i just realized it too late
and i know he still loves me
*alyssas pov*
everyone was looking at their phones except millie. she was staring at finn.
i mean i know they dated, but tht was like. 3 years ago. is she not over it?
i texted the girls groupchat
strange girls💘
⛈: millie is high key staring the living life out of finn
🐳: i thought it was just me that noticed
💫: she needa stay in her lane my guy.
⛈: facts man.
then we all sent memes
*finns pov*
i could feel millies eyes burning into me. i was over her. it had taken me about 2 years. im not going to let her ruin alyssa and i.
i texted the guys
strange dudes🤙🏼
🎑: uh millie is staring
🍫: shes still in love with you idiot
🤟🏼: ^
🌑: ^^
🎑: but she knows im with alyssa.
🤟🏼: well you know millie
🍫: shell go insane. you should make sure alyssa knows that.
🌑: yeah, no matter how in love with you she is, one small thing could blow it all up. no matter what it is. true or not
🎑: why are you being so inspirational and depressing man
🍫: ^
🤟🏼: ^^
🌑: just the facts
we all laughed and turned off our phones. i put alyssas phone in the aux and played high school musical
millie: OH CAN YOU PLAY TEEN BEACH MOVIE
alyssa: uh no.
millie: why not?
alyssa: because i dont like off-brand movies
millie: whats that supposed to mean?
sadie: it means that teen beach movie is a high school musical cringey ripoff
lizzy: damn sadie
we all laughed
millie: *mumbles* high school musical isnt even that good.
alyssa: mCSCUSE ME? DID I JUST HEAR YOU RIGHT?
caleb: hah. shit
millie: what? it wasnt!
alyssa: how ? how was it not good?
millie: uh its super cliché. a high school love story with friends who try to sabatoge them they feel bad apologize and in the end they win?
alyssa: teen beach movie. 10 times more cliché. a SUMMER love story. a girl with a sad backstory meets the guy of her dreams. she gets pulled away from him because something forbid them to be together. she realizes the something isnt what she wants and that its her choice. so she stays and happily ever after. its basically high school musical 2 with trashy music and a different setting.