Sins [Jeff the killer x reader]

Jeff the killer?

why am i smiling? you mentally question yourself, weird. You stopped whatever you were doing and go over to your clothes drawer and pick out something to wear, you pick out a gray t-shirt and a black baggy hoodie over it and a pair of black skinny jeans also with a pair of mismatched socks, once you picked everything out, you undress until you were just in your (f/c) underwear then you put on a plain black bra and then start putting everything else on. When you were done you felt you stomach growl, you sighed, then you walked over to the door and opened it and started going back to the kitchen, when you were almost there you saw Jeff still sitting at the table, he was just blankly staring out the window,

why haven't i noticed how handsome he was before? you questioned yourself, you continue to look at him, he hasn't noticed you yet You look at him starting with his feet, he was wearing black sneakers, your eyes moved up to his legs he was wearing black dress pants your eyes, which was strange considering the rest of his outfit. your eyes followed his body to his torso, he was wearing a white hoodie with blood stains on it, you then proceeded to look at his face he was unnaturally pale, he also had a very defined jaw, you then looked to his lips, they were normal apart from the smile carved into his cheeks , you made your way to his nose it was nice, not to defined but definitely not ugly in any means. Then you looked at his eyes they had dark bags under them, you then moved your gaze directly into his eyes they were a beautiful blue, he laughed a little and you realized you were making eye contact, you quickly looked away,

shit shit so embarrassing, whatever you do don't blush. you thought to yourself trying your hardest not to blush,

"checking me out huh?" Jeff asked jokingly, you looked back trying to keep your cool (lol)

"pfft why would i ever" you say back to Jeff, he just looks at you small grin on his face.

"sure whatever you say," Jeff says, as he looks at you up and down like he was now checking you out, before you could process what he was doing you hear a 'growl' come from your stomach, you look down at your stomach then back at Jeff he was now laughing,

"haha hungry again?" Jeff laughs,

"yeah, so what if i am" you say defensively as you make your way over to the fridge and open the freezer and grab a Popsicle (lol i love popsicles) before you close the freezer you turn to Jeff,

"hey Jeff, want one?" You ask, he sits up a little,

"sure" he replies, you grab two popsicles from the freezer,

(these kind are my fave! sorry if you don't like popsicles but i eat them all the time haha)

you walk back over to the kitchen table and sit across from Jeff, you hand him his popsicle then open yours, before you put it in your mouth, Jeff sighs

"is it really a good idea to eat popsicles in the winter?" Jeff asks as he also opens his popsicle,

"whats it matter there delicious" you replied with a smug expression, then you proceed to put your popsicle in your mouth, you twirl it around it in your mouth licking it innocently (lol i am trying not to make this dirty cause (y/n) is an innocent bean, but Jeff is a little pervert haha) you pull it out of your mouth and give it one last lick, then you look at Jeff who's staring at you closely blushing slightly, but all you notice is his popsicle melting onto his hand,

"Jeff eat your popsicle, its gunna melt," you say then Jeff stops looking at you than to his popsicle,

"oh" was all he said before he licked his hand of the melted goodness, then starts eating the popsicle normally

"so Jeff lets talk about you" you began, Jeff almost chokes on his popsicle and looks at you surprised,

"y-you wanna know about me?" Jeff asks slightly shocked, you just nod,

"well i mean its only far, you know practically everything about me" you say while biting your popsicle,

"so thats why" Jeff whispers, you look at him unsure of what he said,

"sure ask me whatever you want" Jeff rasped,

oh crap, i hope i didn't make him mad. you thought,

"o-okay so how are you so good at fighting?" you ask hoping you asked a good question,

"well i am a creepypasta a-" you cut him off by almost choking on your popsicle. After you were done almost dying you look at him in shock,

"CREEPYPASTA?!" you screamed Jeff was clearly taken back by your sudden outburst,

"uh yeah" he answered hesitantly,

"wait! your names Jeff" you say, He just looks at you and nods as you start making weird hand gestures as if you're putting together a puzzle, then finally you gasp coming to a realization, you then quickly shoot out of your seat,

"JEFF THE KILLER?!?" you scream once again you quickly cover your mouth realizing you were screaming then you sit back down, kinda embarrassed.

"yep that's me the famous Jeff the killer" he says proudly, you sigh realizing you were probably unknowingly boosting his ego,

"its infamous, idiot" you say,

"whatever" Jeff muttered, till a weird smile starts appearing on his face, you look at him with a confused expression,

"wait, so if you know who i am does this mean you're a fan?" Jeff asks with a devilish grin. You then burst out laughing

"hahaha i wouldn't bet on it" you laugh he looks almost disappointed,

"if i'm being honest i like you second best" you encouraged, Jeff than looks at you,

"whos first?" He asks curious, you smile a little

"Ben drowned" you reveal Jeff laughs

"you won't feel that way if you ever met him in real life" Jeff giggled

"why?" you ask

"because he's a pervert" he replied, you gasp sarcastically

"oh wow is he more of a pervert than you?" you ask in a sarcastic tone, Jeff eyes widen

"hey I'm not a pe-" before Jeff could finish,

"wanna watch a movie?" you ask

"you didn't l-"

"what kinda movie?" you think out loud as you touch your chin and think

"scary" Jeff and you say simultaneously, you both look at each other in shock for a moment before laughing. Then you both go over to the couch and pick a movie.

(whew long ass chapter... your welcome lol)