Aries: Jeff The Killer
Taurus: Slenderman
Gemini: Clockwork
Cancer: Bloody Painter
Leo: BEN DROWNED
Virgo: Puppeteer
Libra: Laughing Jack
Scorpio: Jane The Killer
Sagittarius: Ticci Toby
Capricorn: Hoodie
Aquarius: Masky
Pisces: Eyeless Jack
a/n: I will update this frequently.