fair game - lizzie olsen [DISCONTINUED]

Chapter 18 | former lovers

I furrowed my brows upon reading her text but it was removed when Katie messaged that she's on her way to my place. I never told anyone about my relationship with Katie, we liked it private but eventually one of her fans stalked us on our vacation and caught us doing couple things which spread out on the entire internet. We had to break up because of it but we remained good friends, and for all that I know is that there are still feelings left for each other but we couldn't, it's too risky.

-changed Unknown Number to Katie 💋-

Katie 💋
Hi, love! I just want to let you know that I'm omw! 💓 I hope you have food, I'm starving. 🤤 | 3:17 pm

Me
I'm food. Kidding. 🙄 I'll make you food, what you want? I'm a pretty decent cook now. Anyways, can't wait to see your lovely face again! 🤓 | 3:18 pm

Katie 💋
Oh, is that so? 😏 You can definitely be food, i'm not picky. But you can make me anything delicious, I hope you are better now. Love you! 😘 | 3:18 pm

Me
Haha! Too bad i'm not available. 😎 I'll see you! <3 | 3:18 pm
Seen . 3:18 pm

When Katie arrived on my doorstep we hugged each other tight as she gave me a kiss on my cheek. I let her in my place as we sat down the couch, I offered her water in which she said 'thank you.' "So tell me about this new actress." She asked and I teasingly took a deep breath as she giggled.

"Her name is Elizabeth Olsen. Lizzie, for short. She have a seven year old son, almost eight this month. She is married to a singer. We're not together-" Katie then cut me off before I could finish.

"Wait, she's married? So you two...? Never happened???" I giggled at her response.

"I honestly thought she was over him since he abused them. Her son even got hospitalized because of him, and she's letting him release. It's stupid."

"Did you guys do it?" I looked at her and she immediately knew the answer so she just nodded her head and smiled.

"Was she better than me?"

"Katie!"

"I'm just kidding! Sorry! Geez." We both laughed it off as we both ended up watching the new episode of Supergirl S6 after I cooked her food. After watching the latest episode, Katie placed her head on my shoulder which made me look at her and she fell asleep. "Katie?" She hummed in response. "Come, I'm gonna let you sleep in my bed." I said but she shakes her head and wrapped her arms around me. "I want to stay here with you on the couch, please?" She lazingly stated which I find cute.

I lie down on the couch as I let Katie sleep on top of me, her neck snuggled on the crook of my neck as I placed my arm around her. I also fell asleep and didn't think of anything else.

Lizzie's pov

Being with Robbie again in the same household was weird until we had a talk. He sounds pretty convincing to me, so I let myself comfortable around him again. We ended up having sex for the first time again, and I wasn't expecting it to happen so soon. I'm stupid I know. I still love y/n but I'm married to Robbie. I hate betraying her like this, and I'm guilty for treating her like shit. I should go and apologize to her.

Since she's not replying to my message I drove myself to her place. I knocked on her door and no one was answering so I called her phone. After a few rings, no one was still answering so I just let myself in. I'm sure she'll be fine with it?

When I opened the door, I called out to her and no one answered. When I closed the door behind me I went and walked up to the living room and saw y/n with another girl cuddling on the couch. My heart dropped as soon as I saw what was in front of me. Who is she? Why is she on top of her? Why do they look comfortable with each other? I accidentally let go of the bag in my hand as it make a loud thud against the floow which slowly woke y/n up.

When she fully opened her eyes, she saw me and her eyes widened as she glanced to the girl on top of her then back to me. "Lizzie..."