You Left Me With These Broken Lies (Sequel to TBSIATG; Andy Biersack Story)

Prologue

I looked from Jay and Andy, uncertain of what I was going to do. I didn't know what to think. With the time that I've spent with Jay, I've grown to love him a little bit. I really liked him. I was really growing on the fact that I loved him.

But then, Andy came into the picture. I couldn't forget that he was my first true love. We'd been to hell together and back. I still did love him.

All the same, I couldn't let him into my life again. I still loved him and he knew that. Yet, he went to date Scout again. After all that she's done to him, he still goes back to her. It hurt me. He betrayed me. I have never liked Scout. I always knew that she was bad news.

He was still with her at this point and yet he was asking for me again. He was just as bad as her now. He was going to cheat on her to get me back again. That wasn't going to happen.

I shook my head. "I'm sorry Andy. I can't do this anymore. You've hurt me one too many times. Bringing Scout into this picture crossed the line."

I walked over to Jay and clutched his arm. He smiled and wrapped an arm around my waist. I leaned my head in against his chest.

I looked up at him and said, "Jay?"

"Yeah?" he replied.

"I'm letting you hold my heart. Be careful with it," I whispered.

I closed my eyes and buried my face into his chest, allowing him to hold me close and kiss the top of my head.

"Thank you Heather," Jay said.

Andy simply stood there in shock, not registering what was happening. When he did, he felt a pang of sadness.

I pulled away from Jay to see the sadness lingering in Andy's crystalline blue eyes. I grimaced, seeing him the way he was. I brushed it off and allowed Jay to walk me away. Andy had hurt me for the last time. I wasn't going to have his bull crap anymore.

Not again.