Oh THAT alchemist has done it he betrayed everyone but just to save his father. Now that Varin is going to get karma for hurting the sun lady now he'll pay by the the moon lady and how she has got a score with him soon after his penance he pleaded with her to help him save his dad but she has been broken by his deed. If someone hurt one of your peps how would it feel then after constant pleas of guilt and apologies. She forgives only if he becomes more kind and more selfless.