This is a repeat scenario, just think of this as either your second mentor or a new one. :)
Aries~ Eyeless Jack
Taurus~ Nathan the Nobody
Gemini~ Ticci Toby
Cancer~ Jane the Killer
Leo~ Homicidal Liu
Virgo~ Laughing Jack
Libra~ Nurse Ann
Scorpio~ Tim
Sagittarius~ Jeff the Killer
Capricorn~ Slenderman
Aquarius~ BEN Drowned
Pisces~ Brian