Aries: Bloody Painter
Taurus: Ben Drowned
Gemini: Jane the Killer
Cancer: Jeff the Killer
Leo: Slenderman
Virgo: The Puppeteer
Libra: Ticci Toby
Scorpio: Laughing Jack
Sagittarius: Offenderman
Capricorn: Masky
Aquarius: Trenderman
Pisces: Sally but she burns the whole house down, she leaves the ashes afterwards and now you've got to explain to your family that you've got nowhere to live.