You catch them doing something embarrassing...
(The song above is for Capricorn reference)
Aries: Dark Link
You caught His Royal Darkness prancing around the room to Lindsey Stirling.
Taurus: Masky
He wasn't being mean to Sally. Well, he found it embarrassing, so...
Gemini: Laughing Jack
He was singing along to "Barbie Girl" by Aqua.
(I WANT THAT SONG TO ROT AND BURN IN THE FIERY PITS OF HELL)
Cancer: Ticci Toby
You caught him eating waffles
(Mind you, he doesn't obsessively eat waffles, and fangirls like to pretend he does. That's why it was embarrassing for him.)
Leo: Nina The Killer
You caught her making out with a picture of Jeff.
(Sure, this was kinda normal for her, but it was just gross to you.)
Virgo: Zero
You caught her talking to her rats.
(She likes to keep the rats a secret.)
Libra: Bloody Painter
You found him oggling over his notebook full of pictures he drew of Judge Angels, giggling.
(He likes to keep that notebook a secret)
Scorpio: Jeff The Killer
You caught him screaming his lungs out to Marylin Manson.
(He basically has a very big problem with people watching him sing, so this embarrassed him)
Sagittarius: BEN Drowned
You caught him uh... Um... Er...
*cough*jacking off*cough*
(You choose who made him)
Capricorn: Liu/Sully
You caught them singing the "Sausage" song while posing and dancing.
(Is that what it's called?)
Aquarius: Kagekao
You caught him annoying over an anime character
(You choose anime and character)
Pisces: Jane The Killer
You caught her singing "Painted Smile" by Madame Macabre.
(A/N I AM SO SORRY SAGITTARIUS!!!)