She's not my sister

By BOMask

644K 14.8K 5.5K

Harley and Alix are two girls forced to live together and act like sisters since their parents decided to rem... More

Chapter 1 - Never
Chapter 2 - Deal with it
Chapter 3 - Jealous
Chapter 4 - Crash
Chapter 5 - Forget it
Chapter 6 - What did not happen
Chapter 7 - Can't help it
Chapter 8 - Tease and pretend
Chapter 9 - No talking
Chapter 10 - Secret
Chapter 11 - More acting, less thinking
Chapter 12 - Not out but about
Chapter 13 - Behind closed doors
Chapter 15 - No eggs for me
Chapter 16 - Homework
Chapter 17 - Best worst news
Chapter 18 - Sleepy whispers
Chapter 19 - One day
Chapter 20 - Ends and beggings
Chapter 21 - Papers
Chapter 22 - Come cleaner
Chapter 23 - Need
Chapter 24 - Run away
Chapter 25 - No fuel
Chapter 26 - Snake and change
Chapter 27 - No rest
Chapter 28 - Get out, stay in
Chapter 29 - Can't do this anymore
Chapter 30 - Move on
Chapter 31 - Substitutes
Chapter 32 - Say it
Chapter 33 - Again
Chapter 34 - Deals
Chapter 35 - Well behaved?
Chapter 36 - It's so hard
Chapter 37 - It changes nothing
Chapter 38 - Competition
Chapter 39 - Trust
Chapter 40 - Messages
Chapter 41 - (Un)breakable
Chapter 42 - Left to do what's right
Chapter 43 - Player 3
Chapter 44 - Headaches
Chapter 45 - P(l)ayback
Chapter 46 - We stay together
Chapter 47 - Don't press play
Chapter 48 - Dysfunctional Family
Chapter 49 - Revelations
Chapter 50 - Heroes And Villains
Chapter 51 - Fight And Flee
Chapter 52 - Don't Give Up On Her
Chapter 53 - Not As Planned
Chapter 54 - The Calm Before
Chapter 55 - The Storm (Part 1)
Chapter 56 - The Storm (Part 2)
Chapter 57 - Who Won?
Chapter 58 - Family First
A/N
A/N and a photo of a cucumber (updated)
Chapter 59 - Outcomes
A/N
Chapter 60 - The gang (part 1)
Chapter 61 - The gang (part 2)
Important A/N
Chapter 62 - New chapters, old tales

Chapter 14 - Sneaky Spiders

15.1K 339 63
By BOMask

"I don't know if this is right to say
But I remember when my nights were grey
Because of you, I can see the light of day
And I swear I knew it right away
Hope the night skies light up in my life tonight
Let the moment shine right into you and my life"

Harley's P.O.V.

I sat in the chair that had stood a few feet away from me. I was too horny and mesmerized to say anything, but Alix kept talking to me.

- "Well, your behaviour during the day has been inexcusable, so I took the liberty to punish you myself." She moved towards me and unbuttoned her top to show some cleavage.

My mouth was starting to get watery.

When Alix was in front of me she sat on my lap, putting her arms around my neck and her mouth next to my ear.

- "So I thought, what better way to punish you than get you hot and horny beyond belief and never give you the satisfaction of actually touching me?" She whispered and nipped my earlobe.

She just started and I could already feel myself getting hot. This is going to be torture.

- "Alix, please, please don't do this, it's not fair." I said, my voice low and raspy.

She chuckled a bit and started to kiss down my neck, bitting and licking it softly.

- "Oh babe, you have to pay for what you did, and since I can't get to the next class dressed like this, I'm going to have to undress, it's a shame I only have two hands, guess it's going to be a painfully slow process, good thing I already have no panties underneath this skirt, one less thing to take off." She said against my neck, making me shiver and moan at the same time.

- "Jesus fuck... I have two hands, please, please let me help." I begged, my eyes closed while I tried to control myself.

She retreated her attack on my neck and brushed her lips softly against mine, my immediate reaction was to try and kiss her, but she moved back.

- "No, no, no babe, you still haven't earned the right to touch this, first you'll have to suffer." She said, motioning to her body, clicking her tongue repeatedly and starting to get up.

- "What do I have to do for you to let my hands free?" I asked in pleading manner.

A finger was quickly covering my lips.

- "First of all, no talking unless I say so. We're going to play a game babe. If you win, I'll take those cuffs from around your wrists and you can do whatever you want with me, if you lose, I will tease you in the worst possible way and just leave you high and dry." She removed her finger from my lips and I nodded slowly.

- "Ok, so here is how it's gonna go. I'm going to ask you some questions, if your answers are not to my liking, or if you break my rules, then you'll get punished. If, you turn out to be a good girl, I will take the handcuffs off, letting you move and talk freely. Got it?" She asked with an eyebrow raised.

I nodded again, my eyes focused on her.

- "Ok, first of all, who's the better kisser between the two of us?" Foul play... we were always playfully having this argument.

I got a bit nervous but started to answer her question anyways. She was not winning our stupid argument. I was the better kisser. Me! Harley!

- "I mean, I do have more experience, you're a great kisser, but I've always been told to be the best. Haven't heard you complain before. Unless you usually moan in disapproval. " I said grinning at the end.

Alix's face held a grin as well, but it had mischievousness in it. Shit! I'm for sure being punished.

- "Oh Harley, wrong answer babe, wrong answer." She said starting to unbutton the rest of her top half and of course she didn't have a bra.

My mouth stood wide as I looked at Alix's perfect breasts.

- "I think I'm going to have to prove you wrong." She came and sat on my lap again. Having her this close and semi naked while I couldn't do shit was hard.

She put both hands on my neck and kissed me deeply, making me moan. Damn. She is good. She then caught hold of my hair and pulled on it, making my head tilt back and leaving my neck and throat exposed to her. She trailed her lips and tongue all over them leaving me a hot mess.

- "Who do you belong to?" She said against my throat.

- "You". My voice was barely a whisper, my breathing was fast and my entire body felt hot and tight. That was an easy one at least.

- "I can't hear you babe, who do you belong to?"

- "You! Now, please, please let me touch you Alix!" I said while she detached herself from my throat and got off my lap.

- "What did I say about talking without my permission?" She got up from my lap and turned around starting to take her skirt off, bending herself and making her ass almost get at touching distance of me.

When she was completely naked, she turned around again and moves a hand through her hair.

- "Final question babe, you get this right and I'll get you free." She said and opened her right hand, showing me a small key.

I couldn't take it anymore, I just nodded eagerly thinking about getting free and being able to touch her.

- "Am I the best you've ever had?" She asked but I could hear fear and shyness invading her voice now.

- "What do you mean?" I asked, a small smile standing in my face. Oh how the turn tables.

She shrugged in frustration.

- "You know exactly what I mean Harley! Am I the best you've had? From all of the girls you've been with, am I the best?" She asked annoyed that I was playing dumb, her whole controlling posture leaving her.

- "Well, if you want the answer to that, you've got to take these cuffs off of me." I said softly.

She bit her lower lip, thinking about it probably and moved towards me. She went around me and removed the handcuffs from around my wrists.

I quickly grabbed one of her arms and pulled her to me. I got up from the chair and put my hands on each side of her waist.

- "You're not the best." I said looking her in the eyes.

Her face fell, but I quickly put my finger underneath her chin. My facial expression was serious and warm.

- "You are the one. When I'm with you, nothing else matters. I don't have anyone else in my mind. My past does not exist, all I can feel is the present, all I can see is you. So no, you are not the best, cause I have nothing to compare you to. I've never felt the way I feel about you towards anyone else, so you are my first and only." I said tenderly.

She looked me in the eyes for a couple of seconds before she crushed her lips to mine. Our kiss held passion and I could feel her give herself entirely to me.

My hands roamed her body and our tongues danced together. She pulled me so close that it seemed like she was afraid I would disappear into thin air.

Just then, my phone rang in my jeans. We detached our mouths, but kept holding each other. I took my phone off my jeans.

Incoming call from Dad

Dad? What can he possibly want? Is he in the country?

I looked back at Alix who saw my face scrunched up.

- "Who is it?" She asked cupping my face and redirecting it towards hers concerd with my expression.

- "My dad, I don't know why he's calling, we haven't talked since my birthday." I said, mostly confused about what I was supposed to be feeling.

- "You should call him back, I'm going to get dressed. Also we should probably eat something before class as well." She said starting to move away from me.

Before she could move any further, I pulled her back to me, kissing her.

- "Sorry babe. To be continued." I said kissing her softly again and letting go so she'd dress herself.

I unlocked my phone and started a new text message to my dad.

Hey, saw your call, right now is not a good time to talk, I'm at school, but I'll call you once I get home. Text me if it's urgent.

I sent the message and turned back to face Alix who was almost ready.

- "Are you ready?" I asked putting away my phone in my jeans pocket.

- "Almost, just go ahead and eat something, I'll go and meet you at the cafeteria. It's not like we can get out of here hand in hand either way, so I better turn the hate mode on." She said sighing at the end.

I walked up to her and caressed her face.

- "I like you so much, I wish I could just let everyone know." I kissed her for a couple of seconds before I headed towards the door.

- "See you in a few. Hurry!" I said and left.

_______________________________________

Alix's P.O.V.

Once again me and Harley got interrupted by something random. I wonder if the universe is as against us as it seems to be. Well, fuck you universe! You're not going to keep us apart.

Getting all of my stuff, I got out of the storage room and went and left the key in the drama club room with the teacher. Just as I was moving to the cafeteria, James stopped me.

- "Hey Alix, how have you been doing? Still single?" He asked stepping right in front of me, blocking my way.

I rolled my eyes and breathed in deeply.

- "Ok, James. This is the first and last time I'll say this to you. Nothing is happening or will ever happen between us. I'm not your friend and I don't want to be, so there is absolutely no reason for you to talk to me or for me to talk to you. Got it? Ok, Bye!" I said moving past him, going to meet my girlfriend.

What is it with people in this place not understanding things at first? Specially rejection. God damn it.

Once I got inside the cafeteria, I saw the only people that mattered to me waiting on a table and went to them, seeing someone already had bought me lunch. Probably Harley, who tried to conceal a smile and a small blush. I think she is the "one".

______________________________________

- "Hey mom, everything good? Need help with dinner?" I heard Harley get home and talk to Julie. She went to her grandma's house in the afternoon.

- "Hi Harley, nah, it's alright, it's almost ready, Alix helped. How is your grandma?" She replied.

- "She's good, always up to no good that lady. Is Alix in her room? I really need to ask her something about a school thing."

- "Yes she is, are the two of you finally getting along?" Her mom asked suspicious.

- "Me and Alix? No mom, I just realized I could take advantage of her History notes and resumes to get better grades without trying... so I'll go and ask her about the things I need." I could hear her mom reprimand her while  chuckling a bit and footsteps getting closer.

My door closed and soon, Harley's hand was caressing my face.

- "Hey babe, missed me?" She whispered. Her smile reached her eyes that were warm and held amusement.

- "You're crazy, what if they get in Harley?" I said but couldn't help but melt into her touch and smile as well.

- "What if? I'm just here to ask you for your History notes." She said putting a hand on her chest playing innocent.

I decided to play along.

- "Oh really? Nothing else?" I said starting to move away from her and towards my desk.

She got a grip of my arm.

- "No, not really. I don't need notes, just a welcome home kiss from my girlfriend." She said in my ear.

I obliged and kissed her deeply, wrapping my arms around her neck. She led me to the bed, but we were stopped.

- "Girls! Dinner's ready, are you done in there!"

I quickly got up and Harley breathed in.

- "Yeah mom! Going!" She shouted giving me a small peck on the lips and we both left to sit at the table where my dad was already seated.

- "Hey girls, what's with the smiles?" My dad asked reminding us we should not be smiling after being alone and together in the same room.

- "No reason George. Let's eat, suddenly, I'm really hungry." Harley said sitting down next to me and moving her hand to my leg, but it disappeared as soon as it appeared.

Harley's mom sat down as well. She served our plates.

- "Any news girls?" She asked while serving the last plate and starting to eat.

- "No, not really. Everything is still the same for me." I responded and continued to eat.

- "Actually yes mom. Dad called me today." Harley answered and a smile stood on her face.

I looked at her but trying not to seem interested.

- "Oh yes sweetie? What did he want?"

- "He's going to move, guess he's going to train a new soccer club in Portugal, and he called to know if I wanted to visit soon, he said he'll pay for everything." She said not looking away from her plate.

- "Oh really? That's great right? You've always talked about wanting to go to Portugal and visit the places your grandma always talks about." Julie responded excitedly.

- "Yeah, I'd love going. Dad said it was a great place to live."

Live? Is she thinking about moving to another continent?

- "Wait, live? you're thinking about moving?!" I couldn't help but ask.

Every head in the table turned to me.

- "Wow, are you actually afraid to miss Harley honey?" My dad asked and my eyes widened.

- "No, of course not. I just wanted to know if it is an actual possibility. If it's true than we would never have to see her again." I said defensively.

- "Hey! Just so you know, if I ever left to live in another country, I'd bring my family with me. Good thing I don't consider you to be a part of it." Harley responded.

I was getting annoyed, but knew she was trying to pretend she hated me actually.

- "Good! That way I would have the house to myself!" I shouted back at her.

Julie stopped us.

- "What is this nonsense?! No one's moving! Let's just have one normal family meal for a change please!"

And just like that the table got silent and quiet for the rest of the dinner.

_______________________________________

Harley's P.O.V.

I could try to shut my eyes closed and drift off to sleep, buy I really want to tell Alix that I'm not going anywhere. That and I really want to sleep in the same bed as her. I miss snuggling with her.

I got up from my bed and went to the door, looking around to check if everyone was sleeping. Once I was sure, I slipped into Alix's room.

She was laying with her back to the door, snuggling a pillow. Stupid pillow. That's my job.

I tip toed to her bed and got in, wrapping my arms around my beautiful girlfriend. What I was not expecting was for her to scream loudly.

- "Ahhhh!!!"

I quickly put my hand on her mouth trying not to wake up our parents, but it was too late. When she realized the situation we were into and that she has just screamed, her eyes widened.

We heard George and mom's footsteps, and I fled to the other side of the room, standing there uncomfortably.

- "Start moving some stuff around. Quickly." Alix whispered so fast I almost missed it.

I was confused but complied.

Our parents got in the room and Alix, being the great actress she is put on a scared face and hid partially behind the covers.

- "Honey! Are you ok? What happened? Why is Harley he-" George asked preoccupied and half asleep still, but was cut off by Alix's louder voice.

- "A spider! Right there! Please kill it dad!" She said pointing towards somewhere in the room close to where I stood.

She so smart. I simply continued playing along. Speaking now.

- "Where Alix? I can't find it! Where did you see the damn spider?" I asked moving some more stuff around.

George tried to find it for a couple of seconds as well.

- "Honey, are you sure you saw a spider? Maybe you dreamt of it, there is nothing here." He said.

- "I came running thinking she was being kidnapped and after all she dreamt of a spider." I said with my hands on my waist trying to convince our parents.

Alix pretended to calm down and ran a hand through her hair.

- "Yeah, maybe I dreamt it. Sorry for waking you up guys. I'll just go back to sleep. Thanks." She said in an apologetic manner to our parents.

- "It's okay honey, sleep thight. See you tomorrow." George said still confused, starting to leave the room with my mom.

Alix looked at me with wide eyes, like she was saying "What the hell Harley!", but my mom's voice got my attention.

- "Harley, aren't you coming? Let Alix sleep!"

I nodded and went out of her room, closing the door and turning to my mom.

- "She did it on purpose!" I said pointing to Alix's door.

My mom was confused now but quickly dismissed me.

- "Harley, go to sleep and stop being childish, you're not making sense, she had a bad dream. I'll see you tomorrow." She said kissing my cheek and going to her room on the end of the hall.

I pretend to go to my room, but as soon as our parents room door was closed, I moved towards Alix's room once more.

Before I could open the door, Alix opened it herself, letting me in.

- "What the hell Harley?! Are you trying to scare me to death?" She whisper yelled.

- "I know, I know, I'm sorry, I was just, I came here to-"

- "I know exactly what you came here to do!" She said crossing her arms on her chest.

- "No! I mean... yes, that too, but I wanted to say I appreciate the fact that you'd be sad if I left." I said putting my hands on her waist.

She put her hands on my upper chest and pushed me slightly.

- "And who said I would be sad." She said with squinted eyes.

My browns furrowed.

- "You wouldn't?"

- "Yes, okay, I got sad and I would've been sad if you left, but next time we have to plan this if we don't want them to know." She said breathing deeply at the end and pointing towards the door.

- "Next time?" I asked, a smile on my face.

She instantly smiled as well, but pushed me towards the door.

- "Yes, next time, now go." She said putting a hand on the door's handle.

I quickly turned around and stole a kiss from her.

- "Ok, good night babe, see you tomorrow." I said kissing her once more before leaving the room.

I can't wait for next time.

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

723K 26.2K 37
Sam, a shy, 16 year old, closeted lesbian who has anxiety issues and abusive parents meets Avery, a soon to be Beta, who wasn't expecting to find her...
123K 3K 34
Erotic romance rewrite of "Ride Me" The new story of Harley and Colten! You do NOT need to read the original to follow along to this one. *MATURE CO...
14.5K 476 43
Completed 04/11/23 [CHAPTERS ARE SCHEDULED FOR EVERY SATURDAY 10AM UK] Harley Bennett thought she had the perfect life, stable job and a loving boyf...
719 61 20
For the hopeless romantics like myself🤭(start might be a little slow but trust me it's worth it) Scared to feel, scared to love, scared to live. She...