Fooling Ourselves

By Kelly_Al

1.4M 33.3K 6K

It was simple. He was my brother's ex-bestfriend and now enemy. I was supposed to stay away from him. I was s... More

Prologue: How It Happened...
How We Had Our First Encounter
How I Lost An Admirer
How He Ended What Didn't Start
How Bryan Got Attacked Twice
How I Spent My Birthday
How My First Date Got Ruined
How The Bad Boy Made Me Feel Safe...
How I Met His Siblings
How He Told Me Off...
How We Ditched
How Things Went Down...
A/N
How He Came Over....
How We Left The Table...
How He Won Us Over...
How He Lost it....
How I Met His Parents...
How We Got Closer
How They Made Up...
How We Disagreed...
How He Looked Heart-Broken....
How We Smoothed Things Over...
How it was Calm before the Storm...
How The Storm Came...
How The Truth Came Out...
How It Was At School...
How The Dinner Went...
How we Talked about my Choices
How we Danced at Prom
How Everything Changed...
How He's so Beautiful...
How we Went Our Separate Ways...
How I Surprised Them
Epilogue
Bonus Chapter
New Book!
Bonus Chapter: How I Knew She Was The One
Bonus Chapter (Jace + Alicia)
New Book!

How We Got Caught....

36.6K 856 44
By Kelly_Al

Ari shared a knowing look with me when I entered school the following Monday. We had absolute fun at the carnival yesterday. We took some photos, Dylan and I, in the photo booth by ourselves and some with the group. I got to keep both after promising to copy them on Sunday and give them each a copy. I had to put the pictures in my diary and secure it carefully with the lock and place it in my drawer. Jace never touched my stuff, especially not my diary, so it was safe.

She met me at my locker and we were later joined by Theo and Thai who greeted us with a smile. James was watching Ari from across the hall while talking to Jace, and Theo seeming to notice this too, put his hand around her waist and pulled her into his side.

"Hey girlfriend," he smirked deviously.

"Hey baby," she played along and went on her tip toes to kiss his cheek.

"Enough with these actors, how are you ma belle?" Thai asked me.

"I'm great. I've never been happier," I was bubbling with joy and he looked at me suspiciously, "How are you?"

"What happened this weekend to you?" he frowned looking concerned, "You're not normally this happy."

"Nothing happened," I scoffed and poked his cheek, "I've just realized that there's so much to smile about."

"Ma belle, your happiness is killing me. I'll see you at lunch when school has brought you back a bit," Thai complained and then walked away. I returned my focus to Ari who was playing in Theo's hair teasingly and both of them were laughing as she mocked him.

"Like did you even comb it this morning?" she giggled as she fixed his hair for him.

"Why use a comb when I have you?" he flirted and then there was a loud bang in the hall way. We all turned to look at James who threw a dirty look in Ari's and Theo's direction and walked away angrily with Jace strolling behind him after rolling his eyes.

"Well that worked," I noted.

The bell then rang and everyone rushed to their classes leaving me to hurry and retrieve my books from my locker. Someone came beside me and leaned on the locker next to mine. I closed my locker and faced the person. Dylan smirked at me which immediately resulted in me smiling. His smirked changed into a real smile then.

"I love your smile. It's beautiful. You're beautiful," his cheeks turned pink when he realized what he had just said to me.

"I couldn't compare to you," I replied and went on my tip toes to place a gentle kiss on his tempting lips.

"You keep stealing my kisses and demanding some too," he teased pouting.

"Oh? Okay. I won't kiss you unless you kiss me as of now," I promised.

"No. I was joking. You can kiss me when you want," he assured me.

"No. I won't."

"Well I'm not kissing you so you'll have to initiate the kiss," he said thinking he would win.

"Well I guess we won't be kissing each other," I smiled, knowing I had both won and lost but I ignored the latter and walked away heading in the direction of my first class.

I noticed a figured watching us from a corner and I felt my heart sink. Someone had seen us? Oh no, Jace would never let up. I got closer to get a better view of the person and realized they weren't even hiding. Thai's eyes and mines made contact and I couldn't help but wear the nervous look on my face, which I was trying to hold back.

He gave me a hurt and disappointed look as he shook his head and turned and walked away from me. I suddenly had a bad feeling in my stomach about how everything would turn out. But I could trust Thai, couldn't I?

***

I quickly glanced at Dylan's table and saw him laughing with some of his friends. I picked up my phone and sent a text to him letting him know that Thai saw us. I saw him read the message and roll his eyes looking bored. He typed back a message and smirked as he sent it.

'I'll bump him off later. Jk'

I giggled but then frowned afterwards because he wasn't taking this as serious as it was. I had a painful feeling about what Thai would do and how he would react when he actually spoke to me. I was pulled out of my thoughts by Theo and Thai joining us. Theo sat beside Ari and pecked her lips as he did and Thai sat beside of me.

"Hey," they both said at the same time which was the first twin-like thing I had seen them do.

"Why are you sitting here? This isn't where you should be," James growled.

"James be polite," Ari warned and he glared at her.

"Don't talk to me. I thought we had something between us and I find out on Saturday night that you're dating Theo!" he barked, "You're the one girl I actually care about and you played me!"

"Bro you sound like a girl," Theo chuckled and I gave him a warning look and he stopped.

"Shut up!" James yelled pointing at him, looking like he was ready to attack.

"You are so hypocritical! Are we both forgetting the many girls you've slept with while trying to romance me?! Oh, I've got a perfect example! The girl who you slept with from Skye's party who might I add answered your phone when I called you!" she raised her voice and glared at him, "Was I to continue with your pointless flirting and never get exclusive with someone?"

"Not if it's not me," he growled and she picked up her drink and threw it at him.

"You didn't even apologize. You really hurt me James. I ditched Skye at her birthday party to spend the night with you and then I saw you with a girl, crazy making out," she said with tears in her eyes but being the strong person she was, she held them back and walked away. Theo followed behind her and James pulled at his hair frustrated and then marched away and Jace followed behind him, looking annoyed with having to be a good friend. My phone beeped and I read the message I had received from Dylan.

'Well that was entertaining.'

I messaged him back saying, 'I'm glad that you found my best friend's pain to be funny.' I looked up at his facial expression and saw him frown and shake his head at me denying what my message had read. My phone beeped yet again and I read the next message.

'No, I'm completely team Ari. It was entertaining to see James acting like the bitch I always knew he was and then to see his girlfriend chase after him to calm him down. They make a hideous couple.'

I laughed and looked up and glared playfully at him. He winked at me and I blushed completely forgetting Thai, who was still at my table until he cleared his throat.

"You're so obvious you know," he told me and I looked at him lost for words.

"Look Thai, I need you-"

"I'm not going to tell your secret Skye. You should know better than that. I'm just hurt that you didn't think you could tell me. And what the hell do you think you're doing messing around with Dylan Martin, your brother's enemy?" he asked looking at me warningly.

"I know my brother hates him, but I really like him. I think everything about him is beautiful and that he's just misunderstood. He makes me feel safe and when I'm with him I can't help but be happy. I don't care what you say or anyone else for that matter because he'd never intentionally hurt me and he is not a bad guy," I confessed, "I know that it's wrong of me to like my brother's enemy but I can't help it."

"I know he isn't that bad a guy and you'd be good for him especially with those parents he has but I still think it's dangerous with the brother you have," Thai replied.

"Jace has been limiting me and controlling my life but those days are over now," I proclaimed.

"So when and how are you going to tell him?" he asked seriously.

"I don't know," I frowned sadly.

"Well I like you both together. It's cute, I guess. It all makes sense now, the glares I get from him and the questions you asked about him. I approve," Thai told me giving me his blessing.

"Thank you," I grinned.

"But you should be more careful. The next person to see you could be Jace or James," he warned me and I nodded agreeing.

"I will."



Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

122K 2.9K 55
Chase made my life a misery for years. He was a monster who bullied and tormented me on a daily basis and he was my worst enemy for a long time. Unt...
485K 13.7K 101
#1 in the series || "Are you going to leave?" I asked, looking up into his eyes. "Never." He said, a tired smile spread across his face. "Don't make...
767 40 17
"If you hate me so much, then why do you stick around?!" I yelled. "I don't hate you. You're just so fucking annoying!" He yelled back, throwing his...
3.1K 14 20
Trigger warning for the following: -mature content -some strong language -fighting -mentions of abuse Everything was cool. It was fine and normal...