Slenderman
You and him were in the woods. You were in his lap while looking up at the stars while slighlty singing (favorite song). You were kind of scared because you just watched (scary movie) and you didn't want to be here. You jumped at every sound, like a twig breaking or a owl hooting. Slender took notice of this and wrapped his arms around you and kissed your neck. You smiled and blushed. After a few minutes you heard a real loud howl. You then screamed and scooted closer to Slender, who jumped at your scream. You then grabbed his suit and buried your head. He wrapped his arms around you tighter and pulled his legs up. You felt alot safer now, from the tiny wolf that howled.
Jeff the Killer
You and Jeff were in the living room watching (scary movie). You've watched it over a hundred times with the lights on, but the all the lights were off. You gulped and cuddled with Jeff on the couch while the movie played. When a scary part would come you bury your head in his hoodie, which he thought was so cute. When the last scary part came on he jolted real fast making you scream. He chuckled then wrapped his arms around you. "Did I scare you?" You didn't say anything but hold up the finger.
Ben
You were watching Family Guy when the show started to act weird and disorder. You shrugged thinking it was a tease from the directors, but it started to get to you and started to make you scared. All of a sudden Ben comes out of the screen with devilish eyes and a crooked smile. He came up to you and said those words, "you shouldn't have done that." You started to cry from fear and he looked at you. "(Y-y/n)?" You started to cry more and he then hugged you tight. "I just wanted to scare you that's all. I won't do it ever again." You continued to cry while he rubbed your hair and feeling guilty.
Laughing Jack
L.J wanted to get you back for how you scared him the other day so he had an idea. You two were I'm the carnival talking when he got you by a wall and evil chuckled. You began to worry a bit. He then stuck some candy in your mouth pretending it was the poison candy. You then started to wail cry which he didn't like. He then hugged you. "I'm sorry, I just meant to scare you a little not this much." You hit his chest and cried more. He never did anything like this again.
Ticci Toby
You were watching Natasha and Avery talk to the baby. You smiled, when you heard a loud bang. You turned around and saw nothing. You looked at your kids who didn't seem to notice the sound. You shook your head and continued to watch. The lights then out, which made you say shit. They turned back around and you felt something grabb your shoulders. You screamed real loud making Natasha scream as well. Avery and Jason were laughing away with Toby. "Did I scare you sweetheart?" You glared at him and said no waffles. He then started to apologize over and over.
Offenderman
You just woke up and stretched. You got up and went to the closet and opened it. Offender tried so hard to scare you, but he failed everytime. You just looked at him while he slumped foward. "How are you not scared?!" You rolled your eyes then went to go take a shower.