You Stole My Heart

By Storm-And-Snow

14.4K 382 84

Nerdy, invisible and unpopular, Sarah wishes for everything she doesn't have-including football star hottie Z... More

CHAPTER ONE
CHAPTER TWO
CHAPTER THREE
CHAPTER FOUR
CHAPTER FIVE
CHAPTER SIX
CHAPTER SEVEN
CHAPTER EIGHT
CHAPTER NINE
CHAPTER TEN
CHAPTER ELEVEN
CHAPTER TWELVE
CHAPTER THIRTEEN
CHAPTER FOURTEEN
CHAPTER FIFTEEN
CHAPTER SIXTEEN
CHAPTER SEVENTEEN
CHAPTER EIGHTTEEN
CHAPTER NINETEEN
CHAPTER TWENTY
CHAPTER TWENTY-ONE
CHAPTER TWENTY-TWO
CHAPTER TWENTY-THREE
CHAPTER TWENTY-FOUR
CHAPTER TWENTY-FIVE
CHAPTER TWENTY-SIX
CHAPTER TWENTY SEVEN
CHAPTER TWENTY-EIGHT
CHAPTER TWENTY-NINE
BONUS CHAPTER
CHAPTER THIRTY
CHAPTER THIRTY-ONE
CHAPTER THIRTY-TWO
CHAPTER THIRTY-THREE
CHAPTER THIRTY FOUR
CHAPTER THIRTY-FIVE
CHAPTER THIRTY SIX
CHAPTER THIRTY-SEVEN
CHAPTER THIRTY-EIGHT
CHAPTER THIRTY-NINE
CHAPTER FORTY
CHAPTER FOURTY-ONE
CHAPTER FOURTY TWO
CHAPTER FOURTY FOUR
CHAPTER FOURTY FIVE
EPILOGUE UPDATE!!!!

CHAPTER FOURTY THREE

145 5 2
By Storm-And-Snow


My mind is reeling. There is no way he's actually going to go through with something like this, is there?

Ding

I can't believe what my dad has planned. I stammer an excuse and make my way out of the room, to try and avoid dad's way too excited expression. He's grinning like he's just stumbled on a jackpot. There's no way this could...maybe it could work?

Ding

But then again it might backfire and ruin everything, and considering my parents already feeble relationship, that's not going to end well.
But what if it does?

Ding

I shake my head to clear my thoughts. I have other stuff to worry about, like answering that damn door. I make my way towards the front door, half-expecting it to be Blake, but it's Amelia again.

"Uh,hi,"

"Hi, " Her voice is quiet and uncertain, unlike the Amelia I spent most of high school avoiding, who was confident and unafraid of anything. "Um, Sabrina's car was parked outside my house, I think she's waiting for me to come home and..."

I smile in understanding.

"Say no more, come on in." She looks at me gratefully, and I lead her up to my room. Tentatively, she perches on the edge of my desk chair and takes in her surroundings.

"Cute room," She nods, and after my muttered thanks, the conversation becomes null and void.

"Well, uh, I'd better go check on Carley, she went to call Blake," as I speak, Carley enters.

"He's not picking up," she looks dejected.

"Aw, Carls, I'm sorry." Pulling her into a hug, I can't help but feel confused. Why wouldn't he answer her?

"Hey, what's she doing here?" Carley jumps away from me, and turns to Amelia. "I just saw you leave."

"Sabrina's staking out my house." Comes the simple reply, and Carley laughs.

"That bitch has issues. How'd you manage to put up with her for so long?"

"She was like a shield for me, stopped me from becoming a social outcast." Carley shoots me a look. If there's anything she despises more than early mornings, it's people afraid of being different, of standing up for who they really are. "But I've learnt my lesson. That kind of stuff doesn't matter in the real world. Reputation and image aren't everything. I just wish I'd known that sooner." She sighs heavily.

"Yeah well..." Carley shrugs. I can tell she's not exactly impressed by Amelia's former need to be popular, but she's not being openly hostile either, so...who knows, maybe she'll warm up to her.

Warm up to it, the thought has me thinking of my dads idea again. I've just got to warm up to it, he said.

I'm almost certain he's lost his mind.

And I'm not sure if that's a good thing or not.

"Hey, are those your prom dresses?" Amelia asks, excitedly, pointing at the two garment bags draped across my desk, and after being answered in the positive, insists on seeing them.

"Ohmigosh, Sarah, this dress is so...you!" She gushes, and immediately starts listing accessories would go with it, "...and a pair of silver pumps, or maybe something more flashy like gladiator style sandals..." I swallow.

"Actually, I was thinking of wearing ballet flats with it," I inform her, "just something simple, nothing attention grabbing, you know,"

"Oh no, you're so right, I mean, not about the flats, you can't wear ballet flats to prom, but I mean about the simple stuff."

"That's what I said!" Carley jumps in. "About the Ballet flats. I've been trying to tell her that she just has to wear heels to prom, but she won't listen." And like that, my best friend bonds with the former second-in-command bitch of our high school.

Over what they call my "fashion impairment,"

Hello, Carley's wearing combat boots, leggings, a denim skirt and a hoodie. 90's grunge stuff.

And I'm fashion impaired?

After discussing Carley's dress in detail as well, "you just have to wear gold with this," we head downstairs and catch up on some Teen Wolf.

(Is Dylan O'Brian cute or what?)

"I'd better get going, thanks for letting me hang out with you guys," Amelia sighs wistfully as she gets up to leave. I get up and walk her to the door. "Thanks so much for this, I've been in Sabrina's shadow so long I forgot what it's like to just hang out with friends, without the pressure of impressing anyone."

"Again, no clue how you put up with that bitch for so long."

"You have no idea. I think I'm going to spend my lifetime apologizing to people for the way I acted." She laughs softly, "well, any way, thank you so much for this." She pulls me into a sudden, bone-crushing hug, before heading off to her car, turning to wave just before she climbs in.
I hope Sabrina's given up on her stake-out by now.

I chew my lip as I examine the list.

"Let's see, we've got-what, no, we've got flour at home, we just need some vanilla flavoring-"

"No, let's make it chocolate!" Carley chimes in. We got kinda bored after Amelia left, so we went down to the supermarket to find some ingredients for cupcakes.

"Fine, then grab some Oreos for the icing, oh, and could you get some skittles, I've been craving them all day,"

"That's because you're wearing them in your ears, twat," she rolls her eyes and gestures to my earrings, laughing as she heads away, towards to candy isle, and I go in search of cupcake wrappers.

"Sarah! Sarah! Wait up!" A girl's voice calls, and I turn around only to be tackled by Mia, as she hugs me fiercely. "Hey sweetie, I haven't seen you in a long time." I wrap my arms around her tiny frame.

"I know, you didn't come visit, and I don't know why. I mean, seriously, Zac and Sabrina ended forever ago. Why didn't you make your move?" She demands, and I blush red.

"Who are you here with?" I ask, trying to change the subject.

Big mistake. Her eyes glint mischievously, and she starts dragging me down isle 16.

"Zac, look who I found!"

Of course he's here, I groan inwardly. Where else would he be, when I decide to go to the supermarket?

"Sarah, hey!" He grins as he packs three cans of tuna into his cart, then turns to Mia. Seriously, three cans of icky fish. Three cans. "Hey, why don't you go get some Lucky Charms for you and Sean?"

"Suuure," she drags out the word like she knows something. "Don't worry about me, take all the time you need," she sings and skips off down the isle.

"What was that about?" I ask, even though I know full well that in her evil little mind she's playing matchmaker. And she is soooo not subtle about it.

"No clue," Zac shrugs, but his cheeks are tinged red. "Anyway, what're you doing here? I haven't seen you around school lately."

That's because I've been avoiding you.

"Yeah no, I've been busy. Carley and I decided to make cupcakes and needed ingredients so yeah," I gesture to my basket of cupcake stuff.

An image of Monica and Chandler on their wedding day pops into my mind and I try to shove it out, as well as Shane telling me to give Zac a chance. Nope, not hearing none of that.

And I'm also not paying attention to Zac's hands which are twitching nervously.

"So, you going to prom, Skittles?" He tugs at my left earring, and I jump, which make him smile wider.

"Actually, I'm thinking of just staying home, I mean, I don't have a date and getting a dress is just so much effort." Why the hell did I say that? Of course I'm going, and I already have a damn dress.

"Aw, come on, you've gotta go to prom, I mean, it's Prom. It's like...it's like skipping Thanksgiving football."

"I did skip Thanksgiving football. My dad gets...rowdy."

"All the more reason to not skip prom. Come on, how many high school experiences are you going to let slip through your fingers, huh?"

"Well,"

"Come on, Shane, Blake, Ryder and I will all be there," woah, woah, woah, when did Shane, Zac, Blake and Ryder become a thing? Zac and Ryder? Yes. Blake and Shane, yes. Shane and Zac, yes. But Blake hates Zac and Ryder, well, not hates, but avoids. "Think about it. I'll even take you dress shopping if it's that much of an effort." He winks, and I roll my eyes.

"Fine, I'll think about it." What am I saying, of course I'm going! He leans forward and presses his lips to mine gently. It's barely a kiss, more like a peck, and it's over before I can even react.

"I'll see you there Skittles," he whispers, and it makes my knees wobble. Then he's gone, pushing his cart down the isle like nothing happened.

Wait, what did just happen?

----------------------------------------
Heeeeeeey guys!

Can you believe that we've been writing YSMH for over a year now? And now it's almost finished!

And all you silent readers, come on, we know you're there, leave us a comment, say hi, tell us Sarah should just man up and make out with Zac. Or that she should go back to Shane, or hey, maybe you ship Sarah and Blake. (We won't judge you, promise,)

Just let us know!

Don't forget to:

~*~*~VOTE~*~*~ ~*~*~COMMENT~*~*~ ~*~*~FOLLOW~*~*~

Hope you guys enjoyed this, and well, see ya next update!
Xoxo
Storm and Snow 💋

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

297K 10.1K 44
What will happen when the guy you've been crushing for what feels like forever is paired with your best friend on a fake marriage and you get stuck w...
107 0 14
Samantha had always been the new girl, moving from place to place as her parents pursued their careers. When she started her senior year at a new sch...
438 3 53
It started in Sammie and Ambrie's senior year. They have been friends since the 8th grade. Sammie has a crush on this guy named Nolan who they have k...
359K 10.3K 41
Follow my Instagram for any updates and if you have any questions: @nikki_k123 Ellie has lived in Santa Barbara her entire life with her parents and...