Project Athena | Reviews

By Project_Athena

10.3K 655 535

Are you looking for honest and constructive feedback on your writing? Look no further! Our team of reviewers... More

AI Usage
Rules and Guidelines
Reviewer Profile-Emily (OPEN)
Reviewer Profile-Haize (OPEN)
Reviewer Profile-Roses (OPEN)
Reviewer Profile-Nadia (Closed For Catch Up)
Reviewer Profile - Moni (Closed For Catch Up)
Reviewer Profile-Emmanuel (Hiatus)
Reviewer Profile-Carmi (Hiatus)
The Stories of the Solar Eclipse (Haize)
Shadow of the Gryphon (Carmi)
Dreams of Wonderland (Carmi)
Shadowed Sun (Roses)
Love At Dawn (Carmi)
The Greatest Villain of All Time (Roses)
How To Get Away With Evil (Carmi)
Daracka (Roses)
The Mechanical Muse (Roses)
Ocean of Blossoms and Blues (Carmi)
Captured Feelings! (Carmi)
Mirrored Face (Nadia)
Child of Prophecy (Emmanuel)
The Two Sides of A Sword (Roses)
Along Came Charlie (Emmanuel)
The Gunner and The Florist (Roses)
Kyrah Wilson and The Prophecy of Queen Adela (Emmanuel)
The Shepherds (Nadia)
Avalon: The Six Keys of Destruction (Roses)
Thoughts of An Ordinary Person (Carmi)
Lost Eden ‖ Heavens Fall (Emmanuel)
Clap - The Sound of Death (Nadia)
The Mansion (Nadia)
Fourteen Ways To Kill A Cicada (Roses)
Cosmic Fables: A Princess Odyssey(Carmi)
Rise of Azongaar (Roses)
A Midsummer Night's Dream(Nadia)
Astrid: Limbus Obscuria (Emmanuel)
Mosaicked Feelings (Carmi)
Feelstora (Emmanuel)
Monsters and Magic (Roses)
Regalia (Roses)
The Girl From Human World (Roses)
The Art of Remembering (Carmi)
A Mysterious School Trip(Nadia)
Shadowangel (Nadia)
Volume of Unvoiced Verses (Emmanuel)
Trouble In Not So Pretty Paradise (Roses)
Crooked Hearts (Nadia)
Haywire Ranger (Roses)
As The Moon Wished (Emmanuel)
Her Family (Emmanuel)
The Nephalem and The Last Elemental (Emmanuel)
Statuelike (Haize)
The Room Next Door (Haize)
Dungeon (Nadia)
They Who Slaughtered Hope (Emily)
The Elf Witch (Emily)
Nirvasan (Nadia)
We Give Unto Thee (Emily)
King Eden (Haize)
The God's Game (Emily)
The Edge of The World (Emily)
The Fenrir Saga (Roses)
SHS (Nadia)
Boy Meets Beast (Haize)
Cataract of Delusion (Nadia)
Storm Wars Lore (Haize)
They Came With Secrets (Nadia)

Moth Light (Nadia)

37 8 0
By Project_Athena

Author: theRavensWritingd3sk

Reviewer: SardonicBeauty

Genre: Romance


Moth Light is a fantasy-themed story, from what I have read so far. The story is set in a modern city where supernatural creatures live secretly among humans. The cover of the story is beautifully made, with a dark background that goes really well with the white lettering, perfectly capturing the vibe the author was going for.

The story revolves around Eula Rose, a woman who is shown to have trouble with herself, which can resonate deeply with many readers. Her thoughts and views on what is considered the "norm" for a woman are beautifully expressed. Matthias, who appears to be the male protagonist of the story, is portrayed as an ancient supernatural being who considers humans as "easy prey."

The plot begins with Eula and her friends visiting a club, where she meets Matthias. From the start, a secretive and tension-filled atmosphere is created between Eula and Matthias, engaging readers and leaving them asking for 'what happens next.' The mysterious aura set around Matthias works as a catalyst for readers' inquisitiveness towards learning more about his character and how the relationship between Eula and him develops, given how it started.

The tension between the characters builds from the moment Eula meets Matthias and reacts differently from what he usually receives. The nightclub setting creates a moody atmosphere that contrasts with Eula's hesitance, yet she feels drawn to Matthias. The details of the city streets ignite a sense of a larger mystical world lurking in the shadows.

When it comes to the technical aspects of the story, when writing in third-person point of view, it's better to use pronouns or the character's name at the beginning of the story. For example, "For hours, the woman" should be changed to "For hours, Eula" to make the readability less awkward. There are missing prepositions in some places, for example, "she was dress appropriately" should be "she was meant to dress appropriately." The sentences in the chapters are too long, which can be easily broken into shorter sentences. Shorter sentences are easier to read and understand. Long, complex sentences with lots of commas and conjunctions can be more difficult for readers to read, breaking the flow of the story. For example, "Her friends had informed her... department in the hospital." This sentence can be broken into two smaller ones.

When describing scenes and emotions, it's best to know which incident should be placed where. For example, "She hadn't gone on a night out... custody for the night" should come before "contemplating.. location," and then the changed sentence, "She carefully considered what to wear and whether any of her clothing was truly suitable for the location she had been told." Pay attention to how the sentence structure sounds. Does it sound awkward? In the previous version, the sentence "contemplating her decision... location" sounded awkward paired with the wrong placements of the actions. Another example is "She pulled on the almost too tight... together." End the sentence there. "She noticed that the white color of her top was only slightly different from her pale skin... reality." This is why the sentences you are writing should be smaller.

The finer details could be more descriptive and better. For example, the description of her getting ready, how she felt with the top on, and how she reacted to her surroundings are the finer details that, when added to a story, make it richer and more interesting.

There are places that have missing articles, like "Was a chance." There are also many places that have missing punctuation. For example, there should be a semi-colon after hips. "Flare of her hips; the dip before she reached her thighs, something she didn't see on models."

The descriptions can be worded better. For example, "He watched as she lifted her head, the red lights flaring brightly against her dark hair, the pulse..." Rather than writing the description of what Matthias sees, describe what Matthias is feeling after seeing it.

This story has all the elements of a compelling story and relatable but complex characters. I'd rate this 3 out of 5 stars. It has a lot of potential, and there is much more to uncover as the story progresses.

Good luck!

Continue Reading

You'll Also Like

3.8K 1.3K 50
First Place: Poetry ~Writer's Book Awards Third Place: Poetry ~Rose Book Awards Best Story Quote: 1st Runner-Up ~House of Cards/Clubs Poetry, to me...
68.7K 5.1K 57
When nuclear waste is stolen by jihadists in the middle of the night from an unguarded New York City hospital, the police, in a frantic race against...
1.2K 422 10
What if she's still out there somewhere, with an ear pressed to his heart. What if she's still out there somewhere, with an eye on his lips. What if...
81.1K 2.1K 31
A little AU where Lucifer and Alastor secretly loves eachother and doesn't tell anyone about it, and also Alastor has a secret identity no one else k...