Project Athena | Reviews

Project_Athena द्वारा

10.3K 655 535

Are you looking for honest and constructive feedback on your writing? Look no further! Our team of reviewers... अधिक

AI Usage
Rules and Guidelines
Reviewer Profile-Emily (OPEN)
Reviewer Profile-Haize (OPEN)
Reviewer Profile-Roses (OPEN)
Reviewer Profile-Nadia (Closed For Catch Up)
Reviewer Profile - Moni (Closed For Catch Up)
Reviewer Profile-Emmanuel (Hiatus)
Reviewer Profile-Carmi (Hiatus)
The Stories of the Solar Eclipse (Haize)
Shadow of the Gryphon (Carmi)
Dreams of Wonderland (Carmi)
Shadowed Sun (Roses)
Love At Dawn (Carmi)
The Greatest Villain of All Time (Roses)
How To Get Away With Evil (Carmi)
Daracka (Roses)
The Mechanical Muse (Roses)
Ocean of Blossoms and Blues (Carmi)
Captured Feelings! (Carmi)
Mirrored Face (Nadia)
Child of Prophecy (Emmanuel)
The Two Sides of A Sword (Roses)
Moth Light (Nadia)
Along Came Charlie (Emmanuel)
The Gunner and The Florist (Roses)
Kyrah Wilson and The Prophecy of Queen Adela (Emmanuel)
The Shepherds (Nadia)
Avalon: The Six Keys of Destruction (Roses)
Thoughts of An Ordinary Person (Carmi)
Lost Eden ‖ Heavens Fall (Emmanuel)
Clap - The Sound of Death (Nadia)
The Mansion (Nadia)
Fourteen Ways To Kill A Cicada (Roses)
Cosmic Fables: A Princess Odyssey(Carmi)
Rise of Azongaar (Roses)
A Midsummer Night's Dream(Nadia)
Astrid: Limbus Obscuria (Emmanuel)
Mosaicked Feelings (Carmi)
Feelstora (Emmanuel)
Monsters and Magic (Roses)
Regalia (Roses)
The Girl From Human World (Roses)
The Art of Remembering (Carmi)
A Mysterious School Trip(Nadia)
Shadowangel (Nadia)
Volume of Unvoiced Verses (Emmanuel)
Trouble In Not So Pretty Paradise (Roses)
Crooked Hearts (Nadia)
Haywire Ranger (Roses)
As The Moon Wished (Emmanuel)
Her Family (Emmanuel)
The Nephalem and The Last Elemental (Emmanuel)
Statuelike (Haize)
The Room Next Door (Haize)
Dungeon (Nadia)
They Who Slaughtered Hope (Emily)
The Elf Witch (Emily)
Nirvasan (Nadia)
We Give Unto Thee (Emily)
King Eden (Haize)
The Edge of The World (Emily)
The Fenrir Saga (Roses)
SHS (Nadia)
Boy Meets Beast (Haize)
Cataract of Delusion (Nadia)
Storm Wars Lore (Haize)
They Came With Secrets (Nadia)

The God's Game (Emily)

102 9 3
Project_Athena द्वारा

Author: Rathilluser

Reviewer: OutOfMyImagination

Genre: Fantasy


Hello and thank you for requesting a review. As you requested, I focused on character depth, development, and plot within the story, and of course overall impression. I read eight chapters in total, so the review is up to that point in the story.

The God's Game offers a mysterious world ruled by cruel gods. Even kings and queens must oblige them. Here we meet River, an unwanted king's son hidden from the world. But one encounter with a king of the south will send River on an alternative path he never dreamed of.

The book cover looks great and relates to the story as well. However, the book's description lacks information, and it's not clear what the main story points are. I suggest adding more information about River, the World Build, and making sure the book description is polished and has good grammar and punctuation since that is supposed to capture readers' attention.

The story has an interesting premise, but it is hard to grasp the concept so far. There is a good start to a world build but there should be way more to it, there is a huge amount of information missing. When it comes to high fantasy books, writers need to think of all the details. I appreciated that some of the customs depending on the place were explained, but I wanted to know more.

The prologue didn't offer any valuable information. If anything, it confused me because it's not clear how the King was talking to Gods and the dialogue was confusing as well, and what was the point of carrying the baby there? Other chapters are concise and could be connected since they end abruptly.

I saw you mentioned that English is not your first language and I can feel that struggle since it's not my first language as well. I would suggest getting Grammarly since the free version offers enough to catch small errors. Your main issues are dialogue punctuation, the lack of it to be specific, and some small spelling issues, but I believe with Grammarly they would be fixed in no time.

When it comes to character development, it's very hard to judge since I didn't read that much and the chapters are very short as mentioned. The character's motives and characteristics are unclear. When writing compelling characters, try to ask yourself what drives them to each action they take. For example, why did River attend the ball? Was it because he always wanted to belong, or because he was loyal to his brother, or maybe something else? When you figure that out, try to show it and don't tell it. Introduce characters when they come up in the story to avoid confusion. Raven, his title, and his past were introduced early on, but we get to see him just in the seventh chapter. Instead, you could tell more about River, his brother, and his family.

The plot as I mentioned has potential you could focus more on world-building, and explain how the Gods work in this story since they seem important as the title and prologue suggest, but readers don't get to see that. The world setting is not clear, for example, food, travel, etc., should be included when River goes to the ball in a not-too-complicated way.

I would rate this story two out of five stars. I think it has potential, but it needs a bit more work when it comes to structure, technicalities, and plotting.

I would recommend this story to readers who love short chapters and royalty-fantasy-based books. 

पढ़ना जारी रखें

आपको ये भी पसंदे आएँगी

9.3K 368 6
Basically A malec au where magnus is Cinderella and Alec is Prince Charming. ENJOY!!! This may be based on the original Cinderella movie but it's a m...
310K 18.5K 40
You live in a different time zone Think I know what this is It's just the time's wrong
307K 21.6K 156
Tác phẩm: Toàn thế giới đều đang đợi người động tâm. Tác giả: Tố Tây Người gõ: Mia của bạn nè Beta: Hoa Hoa của bạn đây Ý là truyện này gõ nhanh quá...
1.4K 168 10
Do you want to PROMOTE your book? Enter 'The Gemlight Book Awards" now to gain reader's engagement. Entries Open tick✅ Hiring Judges ✅ The Gemlig...