This was requested by @Jamiiiiiiiieeeeeee :]
Tobias
-Would act normal at the start. *cough* calling the protagonist's problems stupid *cough*
-As the movie progressed he would glance over at you.
-Sometimes he might start crying because it hits too close to home.
-You would end up turning it off and comforting him.
-He would do the same if it affected you.
Rudolph
-Starts it off with the usual blankets and snacks.
-Similarly to Tobi he would gradually show signs of discomfort.
-You guys would finish it but watch a very happy one after.
-If it made him too uncomfortable he would hug your arm like a baby
Carmelo
-He's totally fine throughout the whole thing, but it seems to upset you.
-He would start subtly comforting you. (Putting his hand on your knee, arm around you, etc.)
-If the small gestures don't work he has a backup plan.
- My guy would YANK you over to him and play with your hair while you rest your head on his chest.
Emilio
-You guys were in his living room watching Boys Don't Cry when crIsToPHEr glanced over at the screen.
-He figured that what you were watching was "FAR too mature for his little soybean".
-Long story short, you got to watch Bambi with your boyfriend and his little sister
-All of you cried when the mom got shot. Way to fucking go Chris!!!!