Aries: The Masked Man
Taurus: The Puppeteer
Gemini: Jane the Killer
Cancer: Clockwork
Leo: Laughing Jack
Virgo: Slenderman
Libra: Ticci Toby
Scorpio: Ben Drowned
Sagittarius: Offenderman
Capricorn: Ben Drowned
Aquarius: Ben Drowned
Pisces: Ben Drowned