Starting Over (Unexpected Encounters part 3)

Chapter 16

I grinned back at Lexie as I turned over and kissed the back of her shoulder. I got up on my hands and knees, and I reached over and pulled her underwear down her legs.

I let them fall to the floor as I pushed her legs apart, and my hand roamed in between them.

I kissed along her shoulder and to the side of her neck as my fingers found her clit and began to circle around it.

I heard a quiet moan from Lexie and I watched as her hands grasped the sheets below her.

I playfully smacked her ass as the pressure of my fingers increased. I continued to suck and nip at the sensitive skin on her neck while I teased around her center.

She pushed her hips up towards me as I gently pushed two fingers inside of her. She groaned again as I felt her tighten around me.

I began to move in and out in a steady rhythm as my free hand trailed up her back and held her down.

My thumb found her clit again and I rubbed against it as my movements continued. The sound of her moans grew louder as I worked to push her to her climax.

Her body writhed beneath my touch as my hand struggled to keep her down. I pushed deeper as I felt the orgasm come crashing over her.

I barely heard a muffled "fuck," come from her mouth as she groaned through her release.

I slowed my hand down and pulled away from her as I kissed along the side of her neck. I draped my arm over her back as I laid back down next to her.

"Shit that felt good," Lexie said between breaths.

I smirked as I brought my lips back to hers.

"Glad I could help," I said quietly.

"You can stay here if you want to," she told me as her eyes started to flutter shut.

I laid there as I debated on if I wanted to or not. We'd just had sex, it wasn't like staying would make much of a difference at this point.

"Sure," I nodded, "guess I might as well since we're both about to fall asleep."

"Yeah I'm not going to last much longer," she grinned.

I crawled off of the bed and went to the bathroom, and by the time I came back, Lexie was passed out.

I smiled to myself as I laid down next to her and pulled the blanket up over top of us.

I knew that my feelings about Lexie were complicated, but for now I was going to let myself enjoy this.

                                        ***

I woke up the next morning to the feeling of Lexie's fingers gently trailing up and down my back. I stretched as I turned over to face her and saw her grinning at me.

"Morning," she said.

"Morning," I grumbled, "how are you so wide awake right now?"

"I've been up for a while," she shrugged.

"Oh God," I said, "don't tell me you're one of those chipper morning people."

"No," Lexie laughed, "I've just had a while to wake up."

"Good," I sighed, "because that might have been a deal breaker."

"Oh really?" She asked as she wrapped her arms around my waist.

"Uh huh," I nodded.

"Good thing we don't have to worry about that then," she said as she kissed the top of my shoulder.

"As much as I'd love to stay in bed with you all day," I said, "I should probably go home soon."

"That's fine," Lexie said, "you didn't abandon me in the middle of the night so I'll take that as a win."

"I'm not that mean," I grinned.

Lexie let go of my waist and I got up out of bed and started to get dressed. She followed a few minutes later and helped me gather all of my things up.

"Are you sure you don't want breakfast or anything?" She asked as we walked towards the door.

"That's okay," I said, "thank you though."

"And thank you for coming with me last night and being so understanding," I said.

"Of course," she nodded as she leaned in to give me a kiss, "talk to you later this week?"

"Yeah," I said with a grin, "see you later Lex."

I walked out to my car and started on my way home, my mind already racing. I clearly wasn't fully over Whitney yet, and I couldn't help but think about her after what I'd done.

Had her and Malia slept together yet? I shouldn't even be wondering, but if I knew it might make me feel better...or worse.

I decided to stop and get coffee and breakfast on my way back to the apartment, and when I eventually made it back, Gabbie and Kaia were both sitting in the living room.

Kaia raised her eyebrows at me as I walked inside wearing the same clothes that I had to the party.

"Well, well, well," she said, "someone didn't make it home last night."

"Really?" I jokingly asked, "and who would that someone be?"

"It appears to be you," Gabbie said with a grin.

"Me? Oh, right," I nodded, "yeah I was at Lexie's."

"And?" Kaia asked.

"And what?" I responded.

I knew she wanted the details, but I had to mess with her first.

"You're annoying," she sighed.

"Well I can't just give you exactly what you want that easily," I said, "come on Kai, you should know this by now."

"Do you want me to beg or what?" She asked, "don't think I'm above getting down on my knees."

"Oh we know you're not," I teased.

"I mean I am dating your brother," she smirked.

"Okay," I said as I scrunched my face up, "I asked for that one, I'll admit it."

"Sure did," Kaia said.

"You two are something else," Gabbie added.

"Alright," I sighed, "well since you offered to beg..."

I paused for a moment, trying to decide how much I should tell the two of them.

"Yeah we slept together," I finally said.

There was no use even trying to keep it a secret, I knew I'd want to tell them eventually.

"Hell yeah you did!" Kaia said excitedly.

"I'm a little concerned with how happy you are about that," I said.

"And are you happy about it?" Gabbie asked.

"I um - yeah, I mean...I think so," I stuttered.

"You think so?" Gabbie repeated.

"Yes," I sighed, "I really like Lexie and she's a lot of fun, but I think we all know that I'm still not over Whitney."

——————————————