My Hidden Secret

4: Now I Know

Alison's POV

The whole night at Emily's I couldn't help but be wide awake. But then again, how do you expect me to be able to sleep when the hottest girl I've ever seen is laying right next to me.

I was finally about to fall asleep, when I feel her shifting positions from laying on her front to laying on her back. Maybe now I can kick my little curiosity of having her to the curve afterall.

That's when I slowly scoot my body closer to hers to the point where I was practically clinging on to her side. I softly start to caress her soft skin, starting from her cheek on downwards. Unfortunately though, her clothes made it hard for me to do so.

No matter, I can always just play with her a little. I was about to do just that, when I felt something. I know I'm no A+ student in anatomy, but even I know this isn't right. It felt like she was packing a little extra, but was she really?

I wanted to be sure so I did what my first instinct was and that was to stick my hand in her pants. Surely enough, she was.

But I couldn't stop there, I kept on palming her member and occasionally stroking the tip of it as I watch her facial expressions closely.

That's when I felt Emily start to grow and harden in erection as she bit her bottom lip in her sleep. I couldn't help but love the feeling I had, knowing that it was because of me that she was feeling like this.

I wanted more but unfortunately before I could do anything else, Emily's eyes shot open and she backed away from me on the bed practically falling off.

"Wh-what a-are you d-doing Ali?" she stutters again, this time looking like she was about to cry.

"I found your not so little secret Em. But the question is, why didn't you tell me?" I ask looking at her with pure desire.

"I-I w-was afraid"

"Why?" I ask now confused.

"You'd tell people I'm a freak" she says this time really crying.

"Sweetie, don't think that. Yeah it's true. At first I wanted to destroy you but now that I actually got to know you, I kinda like you. So obviously I won't tell anyone. It can be our little secret. Under one condition though" I reply back giving her my signature smirk.

"What is it?" she asks, practically whispering it out.

"I want you to fuck me with it" I say, this time crawling to where she's at on the bed.

"W-w-what!?"

"You heard me. If you want me to keep this between us, then I want this inside of me whenever I want" I say as I grab onto her member through her sweats. "Do we have a deal?"

She stays silent for a while until she releases from my grip and gets up and walks to her drawer. I thought she was going to say no, until she came back with a condom in her hand. Now all I could think of was her having sex with other girls. Did she? I mean, why else would she have condoms on hand right?

"Ali?" Emily says breaking me out of my thoughts. I see as she's standing directly in front of me now.

"Huh? What?" I ask a bit lost.

"I asked if you were sure about this" she states.

Instead of me saying anything I just pull her sweatpants down in one swift motion, noticing that she was going commando. And the way her penis shot up from erection when the useless clothing was removed only made my desire for her hotter.

At first glance, I'm pretty sure my eyes bugged out. It was just so think and long. To be honest, I don't know if I could take it all. I never actually had sex with anyone. I mean obviously I did it to my self but that's different.

"Ali, you don't have to. It's okay I get it if you wanna tell on me. I'm used to being made fun of anyways" I hear Emily say in a sad voice.

"Sweetie, I already told you I'm not telling anyone. Now come here and give it to me" I boldly say. Damn! I hope I'm making the right choice here.

As Emily puts on the condom, I start to undress myself. Well only from the waist down, if Em really wants it then she can take the rest off herself.

I was going to ride her since I love being in control, except Emily surprised me when she threw me back down on the bed. She parted my legs slightly and positioned herself between them. At this point I'm both scared and shaking from arousal.

When she grabbed her shaft and held it above my center, I thought she would go straight in. Instead she starts to slowly tease me with the head as she moves it up and down my slit. I could literally feel myself drip at the sensation.

"Mmm baby pleaassee" I moan out in frustration, not even caring I just called her baby.

Luckily, it worked out in my favor because next thing I know I feel her slowly go in. I gasped at the feeling. At first it was slightly out of pain as she stretched me out, but after a few slow thrusts it turned into gasps and moans of pleasure.

My back was arching of the bed as I bucked my hips to meet her every thrust. I couldn't control my hands as they went from pulling on the bedsheets to pulling at the back of her shirt. I wanted her closer, I needed her.

As she began to pick up the pace, it became harder to keep quiet. I didn't want to get caught so I made a drastic move and pulled her from the back of her neck down to me, grabbing her sweet plump lips with my own.

At first she didn't kiss back, but after a while she gave in. I didn't even ask for permission as I entered her mouth with my tongue to deepen the kiss.

The moment she entered my mouth with her tongue, I lost it. I felt my inner walls tightening up as I finally hit my orgasm. She was even sweet enough to slow down and help me ride it out.

When she pulled out, I thought that we were done. That was until she started teasing me with the tip of the head again. It was making me crazy so I began to grind my hips as she did that.

Next thing I know, Emily flipped us over so I was on top this time. Since she liked teasing me so much, I decided to give her a taste of her own medicine and grind myself onto her harden member instead.

"Ahh God Ali!" She moaned out.

"Paybacks a bitch isn't it?" I reply back in a seductive tone.

"Hmm..ahhh!" She moaned out loudly as I finally positioned her little buddy and started riding her.

I went painfully slow at first, mostly to try and get used to her size. After a few thrusts I began to pick up the pace. Both of us were practically biting off our own bottom lips to keep quiet. The only sounds audible in the room now were our heavy breathing, the headboard hitting against the wall and my favorite, the sound of skin slapping upon contact.

I was grinding my hips onto hers when I got my second orgasm causing my body to collapse onto hers on its own accord.

I was about to get off when she grabbed onto my hips and held me in place, as my hips hovered above hers. Without another word, I feel her jam her harden member into me again, causing me to squeak in surprise. That's when she just starts pounding into me, roughly and quickly. Not even two minutes later, we finally came undone together.

The feeling I received when she came inside me was like nothing I've ever felt before. It was just so warm and unexpected, but I couldn't help but love the feeling.

For a slight moment I thought Emily was going to say something afterwards, but instead she just walks off into the bathroom to clean off. Even then I couldn't help but stare at her perfectly bare round ass.

When she finally came back into the room, she went straight under the covers as if nothing happened. I know I used her, but I didn't want to feel used as well. So I went to lay next to her and cuddled onto her, loving the contact of our bodies pressed together.

"Goodnight Ali" was all she said.

"Night Em" I reply as I quickly give her a peck on the lips.

I had a feeling I caught her off guard but I didn't care. Because now I really do think I'm starting to fall for this girl. I just hope she does as well.