it's not living (if it's not with you) // S.R. x Reader

Expect the unexpected.

"Fuck!" I yelled, "what do you even want with me? I'm not Spencer, I can't give you the love you want."

"Well obviously I know you guys are FBI agents and he will come looking for you, I made the location obvious. Anyways I want to kill you right in front of his eyes," She smirked.

"What the fuck is wrong with you, seriously. Like who hurt you as a child?" I responded.

"That's none of your business," She spoke.

"Actually, that's my job. I figure out people for a living, so who hurt you? My guess is your father. He left you when you were younger and you don't like when men leave you for other women because it reminds you of when your dad left for another family, am I right?" She didn't respond.

"So now you're taking it out on me so you can be with Spencer, but I doubt Spencer will want to be with you after this, no offense." I kept going.

"If I can't have him, no one can." She responded.

"Didn't you guys only go on a few dates? Why care so much about him?" I asked.

"A few dates? We were seeing each other for months."

"So you mean to tell me that time you came over to the apartment you guys were already seeing each other?" I questioned, she nodded, "He told me the night before was your first date."

"It wasn't, we were together for two months at that point." She said annoyed.

"Why would he lie? Also I'm pretty sure he kissed me in that timeline." I said out loud, that kiss on the couch is making a lot more sense to me on why it was wrong, is Spencer a lowkey player?

"Great, you just added another thing to the list of why I hate you," Genevieve slashed my other arm.

"FUCK. Listen I didn't know you guys were together, he didn't tell me until the night before you came over, and he didn't even tell me your name! I think that's something between you guys, not me."

"Are you that stupid?" she questioned.

"What do you mean?"

"Spencer's in love with you, how are you that blind to it!"'She screamed.

"No he isn't why would you even say that?" His rule was not to catch feelings, why would he say that if he was in love with me.

"He didn't tell you about us, he still kissed you and had sex with you while we were together, yes I know you fucked that night, he was honest with me. That's when you became a target for me. I knew that he didn't regret sleeping with you, and I could see in his eyes he wanted more."

"Well i-i'm sorry, I had no idea you guys were together." I said lowly.

"I know, but he did so he gets to see the mess he's made," She said, playing with the knife. "How long til they arrive do you think?" I shrugged.

"Hard to tell, you were not who I expected at all to kidnap me so it might take them some extra time to figure it out." I responded. She nodded, walking away from me not before leaving another mark, this time on my leg.

Spencer please get here already, I'm in so much pain.

Spencer's POV———————
It had been an hour since Y/N had left to get the groceries. No texts or calls from her, which is rare since she's always calling to see what I want from the store. I decided to call her, but there was no answer. Another call, still no answer. I got up from the couch, put some shoes on, and walked to the grocery store. Along the way I saw a bag on the sidewalk that was almost completely identical to Y/N's, come to think of it, that is hers.