Aries: Laughing Jack
Taurus: Masky
Gemini: Jeff
Cancer: Ticci Toby
Leo: BEN
Virgo: Jane
Libra: Nina (?)
Scorpio: Slenderman
Sagittarius: Homicidal Liu
Capricorn: Lost Silver (Sweet Bby)
Aquarius: Smile Dog (imagine offender trynna get in your bed and smile just straight up biting his leg I guess chewing up Jeff's hoodie was practice for this moment)
Pisces: He does not dare to come close to you while your asleep
