Fatal attraction//finchel//

Say Goodbye

Rachel POV
I stared at the person, who was not my Finn. He just stared back looking pissed off. I have to admit I was a little scared.
....
"Hey will, I was waiting for Finn to come so I could kil.." I didn't finish because he said
"Save it, I know about the two of you, I know everything" he said still angry
"How?" I asked looking away
" Jesse said he spotted you with your new boyfriend, I was confused and then I realized you pulled the same crap, that your brother did" he said
"What are you going to do, kill me like you killed him, huh?" I yelled angry with tears
"Don't yell at me! I took you in when you were on the streets, and this how you repay me by betraying me" he yelled back
"I was on the streets because of you! I didn't want to be an assassin! Just let me leave, let me disappear with him" I said now pleading unaware of what he was planning to do
"I can't do that Rachel, you're my best assassin," he said changing his emotion back to serious
"What are you going to do huh? Kill me?" I said un afraid
"No, that would be too easy, I'm going to kill everyone he loves, until you break it off with him" will said determined
"You don't even know where any of them are" I said
"Is that so?" He replied smirking showing me a video of a struggling Carole tied up

At that moment I knew he wouldn't stop, until he's killed everyone and has send someone else to kill a vulnerable Finn. So I did the only thing I could do

"Do we have a deal?" He asked
"Fine, but you have to let her go first, and you can't let Finn get hurt" I said crying
"Fine" he said walking out
........

Rachel POV
After he left, I broke down and started crying. As much as I love Finn, I can't let his family die because of me. So I have to hurt him to save him. If I know Finn, I can't tell him why and I have to say I don't love him, so he won't try and stop me.

Finn POV
Man, do you know how hard it is to find a star charm. It took forever but luckily I found one. I also got her an engagement so we could get married in secret. It was a little pricey, but Rachel is worth it. I hope she isn't pissed off because I took so long. I'm opening the door and I see a blank Rachel sitting.
"Hey, rach" I said
"We can't do this" she said plainly
"What do you mean?" I asked confused
She got up and said
"I can't run away with you" she said with no emotion
"Why not? They'll never find us" I told her reassuringly
"Because I don't love you" she replied with a tear slipping and looking away
"How can you say that?" I asked her
she stayed quiet, so I walked up to her and made her look at me
"Tell me to my face" I told her, still not believing my ears, she looked me in the eyes
"I-I .......don't...l-love you" she said and grabbed her bags and walked out
"Why? How could you play me like that" I told her still standing in that spot with a few tears, she turned around with tear filled eyes and said
"I'm sorry" she said walking out

Finn POV
With that I dropped to the ground and started crying, dropping the ring. I don't know what to do, do I go back and tell sue I failed. I went to the one person, who ever truly gave me good advice.

Rachel POV
I left Finn in the apartment and broke down in the car. I was on the way to the airport, and I was still crying. I got on a plane to go back to New York and face the devil himself. I failed the mission and lost the love of my life and he doesn't even know why. Before I left I saw him with a box in his hand, which just made it harder. I think he was going to propose, but now I'll never know.